Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson on prophets, Henry and the Essex junto
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson sends Adams his pamphlet on the batture case. He describes the Richmond prophet Christopher McPherson and the Shawnee Prophet, and ties British intrigue with the Indians to John Henry’s mission to New England Federalists.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 934 words · 5 min read
The letter
Monticello, April 20, 1812
Monticello Apr. 20. 12.
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I now have it in my power to send you a piece of homespun11 in return for the one I received from you. It is not of the fine texture or delicate character of yours. Or, to drop our metaphor, it is not filled, as yours was, with the display of imagination that makes for excellence in literature; it is a mere sober, dry and formal piece of logic.22 The subject itself refuses ornament.33 Yet you may have enough left of your old taste for reading law to cast an eye over some of the questions it discusses. At any rate, accept it as an offering of esteem and friendship.
I have it now in my power to send you a piece of homespun1 in return for that I recieved from you. not of the fine texture, or delicate character of yours, or, to drop our metaphor, not filled as that was with that display of imagination which constitutes excellence in Belles lettres, but a mere sober, dry and formal piece of Logic2. ornari res ipsa negat3. yet you may have enough left of your old taste for law reading to cast an eye over some of the questions it discusses. at any rate accept it as the offering of esteem and friendship.
You wish to know something about the Richmond and Wabash prophets.44 Of Nimrod Hewes55 I had never heard before. Christopher McPherson66 I have known for twenty years. He is a man of color who was brought up as a bookkeeper by a merchant, his master, and was afterward freed. He had understanding enough to post his ledger from his journal, but not enough to hold up against attacks of nervous melancholy and the gloomy forebodings they inspire. He became crazy and foggy, his head always in the clouds, rhapsodizing about things that neither he nor anyone else could understand. I think he told me he had visited you in person while you were in office, and that he wrote you letters,79 which you have probably forgotten amid the mass of letters from that crazy class whose complaints, terrors and mysticisms every president in turn has regularly received. McPherson was too honest for anybody to bother him, and too harmless to be a case for the madhouse,810 although, I believe, we are told in the old Book that “every man that is mad, and makes himself a prophet, you should put in prison and in the stocks.”911
You wish to know something of the Richmond & Wabash prophets4. of Nimrod Hewes5 I never before heard. Christopher Macpherson6 I have known for 20. years. he is a man of color, brought up as a bookkeeper by a merchant, his master, & afterwards enfranchised7. he had understanding enough to post up his ledger from his journal, but not enough to bear up against Hypochondriac affections8 and the gloomy forebodings they inspire. he became crazy, foggy, his head always in the clouds, and rhapsodising what neither himself nor any one else could understand. I think he told me he had visited you personally while you were in the administration, and wrote you letters9, which you have probably forgotten in the mass of the correspondencies of that crazy class, of whose complaints, and terrors, and mysticisms, the several presidents have been the regular depositories. Macpherson was too honest to be molested by any body, & too inoffensive to be a subject for the Mad-house10; altho’, I believe, we are told in the old Book that ‘every man that is mad11, & maketh himself a prophet, thou shouldest put him in prison & in the stocks.’
The Wabash prophet1012 is a very different character: more rogue than fool, if being a rogue is not the greatest of all follies. He came to notice while I was in office, and so naturally became a proper subject of inquiry for me. The inquiry was made with diligence. His declared aim was the reformation of his red brethren and their return to their original way of living. He claimed to be in constant communication with the Great Spirit, and said that the Great Spirit had instructed him to make known to the Indians that he had created them distinct from the Whites, of different natures, for different purposes, and had placed them under different circumstances suited to their natures and destinies, and that they must turn back from all the ways of the Whites to the habits and opinions of their forefathers. They must not eat the flesh of hogs, cattle, sheep and so on, because the deer and buffalo had been created for their food. They must not make bread of wheat, but of Indian corn. They must not wear linen or wool, but dress like their fathers in the skins and furs of wild animals. They must not drink hard liquor; and I do not remember whether he extended his bans to the gun and gunpowder, in favor of the bow and arrow. I concluded from all this that he was a visionary, wrapped in the clouds of his people’s ancient past, vainly trying to lead his brethren back to the imagined bliss of their golden age. I thought there was little danger that he would convert many of them from the habits and comforts they had learned from the Whites to the hardships and privations of savagism, and no great harm if he did. So we let him go on unmolested. But his followers increased until the English thought him worth corruption,1113 and found him corruptible. I suppose his views then changed; but what he did as a result happened after I left office, and so it is unknown to me. Nor have I ever been told what particular acts on his part produced an actual commencement of hostilities1214 on ours. I have no doubt, however, that his later proceedings are only a separate chapter, like that of Henry1315 and Lord Liverpool,1416 in the Book of the Kings of England.1517 Your son1618 had got wind of this mission of Henry’s at the time of the embargo,1719 and told me of it. But he had learned nothing about the particular agent, although what he had found out about the agent’s workings now appears to have been correct. He mentioned a detail that Henry has not clearly brought forward: the Eastern states1820 were not to be asked to make a formal act of separation from the Union and to take part in the war against it, a measure thought much too strong for their people. Instead they were to declare themselves neutral, and in return they were to have peace and free trade, the lure most likely to win the people’s consent. Since there was no sign that Henry was the go-between in this negotiation of the Essex junto,1921 suspicion fell on Pickering2022 and his nephew Williams in London.2123 If Pickering was wronged in this, the grounds for the suspicion are to be found in his known practices and avowed opinions; and the grounds for suspecting his accomplices lie in the sameness of their sentiments and language with Henry’s, and later in the fluttering of the wounded pigeons.
The Wabash prophet12 is a very different character, more rogue than fool, if to be a rogue is not the greatest of all follies. he arose to notice while I was in the administration, and became of course a proper subject of enquiry for me. the enquiry was made with diligence. his declared object was the reformation of his red brethren, and their return to their pristine manner of living. he pretended to be in constant communication with the great spirit, that he was instructed by him to make known to the Indians that they were created by him distinct from the Whites, of different natures, for different purposes, & placed under different circumstances, adapted to their natures & destinies: that they must return from all the ways of the Whites to the habits and opinions of their forefathers. they must not eat the flesh of hogs, of bullocks, of sheep Etc. the deer & buffalo having been created for their food; they must not make bread of wheat, but of Indian corn. they must not wear linen nor woollen, but dress like their fathers in the skins and furs of wild animals. they must not drink ardent spirits; and I do not remember whether he extended his inhibitions to the gun and gunpowder, in favor of the bow and arrow. I concluded from all this that he was a visionary, inveloped in the clouds of their antiquities, and vainly endeavoring to lead back his brethren to the fancied beatitudes of their golden age. I thought there was little danger of his making many proselytes from the habits and comforts they had learned from the Whites to the hardships and privations of savagism, and no great harm if he did. we let him go on therefore unmolested. but his followers increased till the English thought him worth corruption13, and found him corruptible. I suppose his views were then changed; but his proceedings in consequence of them were after I left the administration, and are therefore unknown to me; nor have I ever been informed what were the particular acts on his part which produced an actual commencement of hostilities14 on ours. I have no doubt however that his subsequent proceedings are but a chapter apart, like that of Henry15 & Ld Liverpool16, in the Book of the Kings of England17. Of this mission of Henry your son18 had got wind, in the time of the embargo19, & communicated it to me. but he had learned nothing of the particular agent, altho’, of his workings, the information he had obtained appears now to have been correct. he stated a particular which Henry has not distinctly brought forward, which was that the Eastern states20 were not to be required to make a formal act of separation from the Union, and to take a part in the war against it; a measure deemed much too strong for their people: but to declare themselves in a state of neutrality, in consideration of which they were to have peace and free commerce, the lure most likely to ensure popular acquiescence. having no indications of Henry as the intermediate in this negociation of the Essex junto21, suspicions fell on Pickering22 and his nephew Williams in London23. if he was wronged in this, the ground of the suspicion is to be found in his known practices & avowed opinions, as of that of his accomplices in the sameness of sentiment and of language with Henry, and subsequently by the fluttering of the wounded pidgeons.
This letter, with what it encloses, has given you enough, I presume, of law and the prophets.2224 So I will add to it only my respectful homage to Mrs. Adams, and to you my assurances of affectionate esteem and respect.
This letter, with what it encloses, has given you enough I presume, of law and the prophets24. I will only add to it therefore the homage of my respects to mrs Adams, and to yourself the assurances of affectionate esteem and respect.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Notes2224
homespunCross-reference
Picks up the joke in Adams’s letter of 1 January 1812, which called the two volumes of John Quincy Adams’s Lectures on Rhetoric and Oratory (1810) ‘homespun’. At first Jefferson took the word literally and wrote back about home-made cloth.
Adams to Jefferson, January 1, 1812
Sources: Library of Congress, American Treasures: "Two Pieces of Homespun" (archived) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 3 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the enclosed pamphletBook or text
This is the pamphlet Jefferson enclosed: his brief in the batture case, printed in New York in 1812 for his lawyers. It defends what his administration did about Edward Livingston’s claim to the batture, a strip of riverbank land at New Orleans. Livingston’s damages suit against Jefferson was dismissed in December 1811 for lack of jurisdiction.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson's Preface to his Statement on the Batture Case, 25 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson's Statement on the Batture Case, 31 July 1810 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
ornari res ipsa negatQuotation
Latin for ‘the subject itself refuses ornament.’ It comes from Book 3 of the Astronomica, a Latin teaching poem on the stars by the Roman poet Manilius. The full line goes on to say that the subject is content simply to be taught.
the Richmond and Wabash prophetsCross-reference
Answers Adams’s letter of 10 February 1812. Adams had been sent prophecy pamphlets from Richmond and asked to learn more about their authors and about the Indian ‘Prophet of the Wabash’.
Nimrod HewesPerson
Probably Nimrod Hughes of Washington County, Virginia. His pamphlet of prophecy, dated 1810, said that a third of mankind would be destroyed on 4 June 1812. Christopher McPherson publicly endorsed it and mailed a copy to Adams.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 25 October 1811 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Christopher McPhersonPerson
Christopher McPherson (c.1763–1817) was born enslaved in Louisa County, Virginia. He served for years as a clerk and storekeeper for the Scottish merchant David Ross, who freed him by deed in 1792. Later, in Richmond, he proclaimed himself a prophet and predicted the end of the world.
Source: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
McPherson’s letters to AdamsEvent
In 1799 McPherson wrote to President Adams warning that the end of the world was near, and in January 1800 he sent an address to Adams and the Senate through two senators. In October 1811 he sent Adams the pamphlets that prompted Adams’s question.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 25 October 1811 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Mad-housePlace
Virginia’s Public Hospital for Persons of Insane and Disordered Minds at Williamsburg. McPherson had in fact been jailed and sent there in 1811, but on 14 June 1811 its directors declared him sane.
Source: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
every man that is madQuotation
Jefferson quotes Jeremiah 29:26 in the King James Version almost word for word. In that verse a false prophet writes from Babylon urging the Jerusalem priests to lock Jeremiah in the stocks as a madman.
Source: Jeremiah 29:26 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
the Wabash prophetPerson
Tenskwatawa (c.1775–1836) was a Shawnee religious leader and the younger brother of Tecumseh. He told his followers to give up alcohol and American goods and ways. From 1808 his village, Prophetstown, stood on the Tippecanoe River near where it joins the Wabash.
Sources: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab); The Prophet (Shawnee leader), Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
British dealings with the ProphetEvent
Jefferson’s charge rests on real links. In 1808 Tecumseh went to the British Indian Department at Amherstburg, in Upper Canada, and asked for arms and provisions. In the winter of 1810–11 Prophetstown received several shipments of British supplies.
Source: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab)
the Battle of TippecanoeEvent
The fighting broke out at the Battle of Tippecanoe on 7 November 1811. Warriors from Prophetstown attacked Governor William Henry Harrison’s camp before dawn. After the battle Harrison burned the town, and Tenskwatawa lost his standing as a religious leader.
Sources: Battle of Tippecanoe, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab)
John HenryPerson
John Henry was an adventurer whom Sir James Craig, governor-general of Canada, sent to New England in 1809 to report on Federalist discontent. Henry later sold his letters to Madison’s government, and Madison sent them to Congress on 9 March 1812, six weeks before this letter.
Sources: Papers of James Madison, Presidential Series, vol. 4 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Elbridge Gerry to James Madison, 2 January 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Lord LiverpoolPerson
Robert Banks Jenkinson, 2nd Earl of Liverpool, was Britain’s Secretary for War and the Colonies from 1809 to 1812. The papers Henry sold included a dispatch from Liverpool approving the secret agent’s conduct. Liverpool became prime minister in June 1812.
Sources: Robert Banks Jenkinson, 2nd earl of Liverpool, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Retirement Series, vol. 4 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Book of the KingsQuotation
Probably a mock-biblical phrase. The Old Testament Books of Kings keep sending readers to ‘the book of the chronicles of the kings’ for the rest of a king’s deeds (for example 1 Kings 14:19). Jefferson borrows that style for the record of British intrigue.
Source: 1 Kings 14:19 (King James Version), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
your sonPerson
John Quincy Adams, then a senator from Massachusetts. In 1808 he warned Jefferson privately that New England Federalists were talking with Britain about breaking away. The conversation became a matter of public dispute in 1825, when Jefferson and William Branch Giles exchanged letters about it.
Sources: To Thomas Jefferson from William Branch Giles, 15 December 1825 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From Thomas Jefferson to William Branch Giles, 25 December 1825 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the embargoLaw and politics
The Embargo Act of December 1807 banned American ships from sailing to foreign ports, to put pressure on Britain and France. It hit New England’s shipping hard. Congress replaced it in March 1809 with the narrower Non-Intercourse Act.
Sources: Embargo Act, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Embargos: Economic Warfare on the Eve of the War of 1812, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab)
the Eastern statesWord
At this time ‘the Eastern states’ was the usual name for New England, where Federalist opposition to the embargo was strongest. Jefferson used the same phrase in January 1809, complaining that the embargo had ‘federalized the 5. eastern states’.
Source: From Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Mann Randolph, 2 January 1809 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Essex juntoIdea
The name began with a circle of linked politicians and merchants from Essex County, Massachusetts. Their Republican opponents later applied it to the hard-line New England Federalists, whom they accused of favoring separation from the Union. Historians disagree about how organized the group really was.
Sources: Essex Junto, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Essex Junto, Encyclopedia.com (Dictionary of American History) (opens in a new tab)
Timothy PickeringPerson
Timothy Pickering (1745–1829) served as a Federalist senator from Massachusetts from 1803 to 1811. Adams had dismissed him as secretary of state in May 1800, after Pickering refused to resign over his attacks on Adams’s peace mission to France. That history makes the name pointed in a letter to Adams.
Samuel WilliamsPerson
Samuel Williams was the son of Pickering’s sister Lydia. He served as U.S. consul at London from 1798 to 1801 and afterwards worked there as a banker. Adams himself had nominated him to the London consulate in December 1797.
Sources: From John Adams to United States Senate, 4 December 1797 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Papers of George Washington, Retirement Series, vol. 2 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
law and the prophetsQuotation
A pun on the biblical phrase for the Hebrew scriptures, as in Matthew 22:40: ‘On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.’ Here the ‘law’ is the batture pamphlet, and the ‘prophets’ are McPherson and Tenskwatawa.
Source: Matthew 22:40 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
2 more notes explain words of the original that the modern text does not use. Switch to the original to read them.
homespunCross-reference
Picks up the joke in Adams’s letter of 1 January 1812, which called the two volumes of John Quincy Adams’s Lectures on Rhetoric and Oratory (1810) ‘homespun’. At first Jefferson took the word literally and wrote back about home-made cloth.
Adams to Jefferson, January 1, 1812
Sources: Library of Congress, American Treasures: "Two Pieces of Homespun" (archived) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 3 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the enclosed pamphletBook or text
This is the pamphlet Jefferson enclosed: his brief in the batture case, printed in New York in 1812 for his lawyers. It defends what his administration did about Edward Livingston’s claim to the batture, a strip of riverbank land at New Orleans. Livingston’s damages suit against Jefferson was dismissed in December 1811 for lack of jurisdiction.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson's Preface to his Statement on the Batture Case, 25 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson's Statement on the Batture Case, 31 July 1810 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
ornari res ipsa negatQuotation
Latin for ‘the subject itself refuses ornament.’ It comes from Book 3 of the Astronomica, a Latin teaching poem on the stars by the Roman poet Manilius. The full line goes on to say that the subject is content simply to be taught.
the Richmond and Wabash prophetsCross-reference
Answers Adams’s letter of 10 February 1812. Adams had been sent prophecy pamphlets from Richmond and asked to learn more about their authors and about the Indian ‘Prophet of the Wabash’.
Nimrod HewesPerson
Probably Nimrod Hughes of Washington County, Virginia. His pamphlet of prophecy, dated 1810, said that a third of mankind would be destroyed on 4 June 1812. Christopher McPherson publicly endorsed it and mailed a copy to Adams.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 25 October 1811 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Christopher McPhersonPerson
Christopher McPherson (c.1763–1817) was born enslaved in Louisa County, Virginia. He served for years as a clerk and storekeeper for the Scottish merchant David Ross, who freed him by deed in 1792. Later, in Richmond, he proclaimed himself a prophet and predicted the end of the world.
Source: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
enfranchisedWord
Here this means freed from slavery, not given the vote. Ross formally freed McPherson in 1792, though by then McPherson had already lived as a free man for many years.
Source: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
hypochondriac affectionsWord
In Jefferson’s day ‘hypochondria’ meant a nervous melancholy: low spirits, gloom and loss of interest in life. It did not mean the modern fear of being ill. ‘Affections’ here means disorders.
Source: John Hill, Hypochondriasis: A Practical Treatise (1766), Project Gutenberg (opens in a new tab)
McPherson’s letters to AdamsEvent
In 1799 McPherson wrote to President Adams warning that the end of the world was near, and in January 1800 he sent an address to Adams and the Senate through two senators. In October 1811 he sent Adams the pamphlets that prompted Adams’s question.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 25 October 1811 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Mad-housePlace
Virginia’s Public Hospital for Persons of Insane and Disordered Minds at Williamsburg. McPherson had in fact been jailed and sent there in 1811, but on 14 June 1811 its directors declared him sane.
Source: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
every man that is madQuotation
Jefferson quotes Jeremiah 29:26 in the King James Version almost word for word. In that verse a false prophet writes from Babylon urging the Jerusalem priests to lock Jeremiah in the stocks as a madman.
Source: Jeremiah 29:26 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
the Wabash prophetPerson
Tenskwatawa (c.1775–1836) was a Shawnee religious leader and the younger brother of Tecumseh. He told his followers to give up alcohol and American goods and ways. From 1808 his village, Prophetstown, stood on the Tippecanoe River near where it joins the Wabash.
Sources: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab); The Prophet (Shawnee leader), Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
British dealings with the ProphetEvent
Jefferson’s charge rests on real links. In 1808 Tecumseh went to the British Indian Department at Amherstburg, in Upper Canada, and asked for arms and provisions. In the winter of 1810–11 Prophetstown received several shipments of British supplies.
Source: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab)
the Battle of TippecanoeEvent
The fighting broke out at the Battle of Tippecanoe on 7 November 1811. Warriors from Prophetstown attacked Governor William Henry Harrison’s camp before dawn. After the battle Harrison burned the town, and Tenskwatawa lost his standing as a religious leader.
Sources: Battle of Tippecanoe, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab)
John HenryPerson
John Henry was an adventurer whom Sir James Craig, governor-general of Canada, sent to New England in 1809 to report on Federalist discontent. Henry later sold his letters to Madison’s government, and Madison sent them to Congress on 9 March 1812, six weeks before this letter.
Sources: Papers of James Madison, Presidential Series, vol. 4 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Elbridge Gerry to James Madison, 2 January 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Lord LiverpoolPerson
Robert Banks Jenkinson, 2nd Earl of Liverpool, was Britain’s Secretary for War and the Colonies from 1809 to 1812. The papers Henry sold included a dispatch from Liverpool approving the secret agent’s conduct. Liverpool became prime minister in June 1812.
Sources: Robert Banks Jenkinson, 2nd earl of Liverpool, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Papers of Thomas Jefferson, Retirement Series, vol. 4 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Book of the KingsQuotation
Probably a mock-biblical phrase. The Old Testament Books of Kings keep sending readers to ‘the book of the chronicles of the kings’ for the rest of a king’s deeds (for example 1 Kings 14:19). Jefferson borrows that style for the record of British intrigue.
Source: 1 Kings 14:19 (King James Version), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
your sonPerson
John Quincy Adams, then a senator from Massachusetts. In 1808 he warned Jefferson privately that New England Federalists were talking with Britain about breaking away. The conversation became a matter of public dispute in 1825, when Jefferson and William Branch Giles exchanged letters about it.
Sources: To Thomas Jefferson from William Branch Giles, 15 December 1825 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From Thomas Jefferson to William Branch Giles, 25 December 1825 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the embargoLaw and politics
The Embargo Act of December 1807 banned American ships from sailing to foreign ports, to put pressure on Britain and France. It hit New England’s shipping hard. Congress replaced it in March 1809 with the narrower Non-Intercourse Act.
Sources: Embargo Act, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Embargos: Economic Warfare on the Eve of the War of 1812, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab)
the Eastern statesWord
At this time ‘the Eastern states’ was the usual name for New England, where Federalist opposition to the embargo was strongest. Jefferson used the same phrase in January 1809, complaining that the embargo had ‘federalized the 5. eastern states’.
Source: From Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Mann Randolph, 2 January 1809 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Essex juntoIdea
The name began with a circle of linked politicians and merchants from Essex County, Massachusetts. Their Republican opponents later applied it to the hard-line New England Federalists, whom they accused of favoring separation from the Union. Historians disagree about how organized the group really was.
Sources: Essex Junto, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Essex Junto, Encyclopedia.com (Dictionary of American History) (opens in a new tab)
Timothy PickeringPerson
Timothy Pickering (1745–1829) served as a Federalist senator from Massachusetts from 1803 to 1811. Adams had dismissed him as secretary of state in May 1800, after Pickering refused to resign over his attacks on Adams’s peace mission to France. That history makes the name pointed in a letter to Adams.
Samuel WilliamsPerson
Samuel Williams was the son of Pickering’s sister Lydia. He served as U.S. consul at London from 1798 to 1801 and afterwards worked there as a banker. Adams himself had nominated him to the London consulate in December 1797.
Sources: From John Adams to United States Senate, 4 December 1797 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Papers of George Washington, Retirement Series, vol. 2 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
law and the prophetsQuotation
A pun on the biblical phrase for the Hebrew scriptures, as in Matthew 22:40: ‘On these two commandments hang all the law and the prophets.’ Here the ‘law’ is the batture pamphlet, and the ‘prophets’ are McPherson and Tenskwatawa.
Source: Matthew 22:40 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 20 April 1812 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-04-02-0517
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of June 22, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 20 April 1812. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-04-02-0517. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1812-04-20-jefferson-to-adams/.