Adams to Jefferson
Adams on prophets, the stocks and New England plotters
John Adams to Thomas Jefferson
Adams praises Jefferson’s batture pamphlet and jokes about putting false prophets in the stocks. He then recounts the Hillhouse amendments and Pickering’s secession schemes, and warns that federal trade and naval policy is driving New England toward an upheaval.
- From
- Quincy, Massachusetts
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 893 words · 4 min read
The letter
Quincy, May 3, 1812
Quincy. May 3. 1812
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I wrote to you on the first of this month11 to acknowledge receiving your “Proceedings”22 and so on, and I now repeat my thanks for it. It is as masterly a pamphlet as I have ever read, and worthy in every way of the mind that composed it and the pen that committed it to writing. There is wit and fancy in it, and enough delicate touches of satire, to make it entertaining. Meanwhile the wealth of learning, the close reasoning and the accurate criticism must have required a patience in investigation that is very uncommon at your age.
I wrote you on the first of this month1 acknowledging the receipt of your “Proceedings2” &c and now repeat my thanks for it. It is as masterly a pamphlet as ever I have read; and every way worthy of the Mind that composed and the pen which commited it to writing. There is witt and fancy and delicate touches of Satyr enough in it to make it entertaining while the profusion of learning the close reasoning and accurate Criticism must have required a Patience of Investigation that at your Age is very uncommon.
On the second of the month your letter of April 2033 was sent to me from the post office. How it got separated from the pamphlet I do not know. I thank you for the account of the Wabash Prophet.44 McPherson,55 Parson Austin66 and Abraham Brown made themselves well enough known to me when I was in the government. They all assumed the character of ambassadors extraordinary from the Almighty. But since I required miracles as proof of their credentials, and they did not perform any, I never gave a public audience to any of them.
On the second of the Month your Letter of the 20. of April3 was Sent me from the Post Office. How it was seperated from the pamphlet I know not. I thank you for the Account of the Wabash Prophet4. Macpherson5 parson Austin6 and Abraham Brown made themselves Sufficiently known to me when I was in the Government. They all assumed the Character of Ambassadors extraordinary from The Almighty: but as I required miracles in proof of their Credentials, and they did not perform any, I never gave publick Audience to either of them.
Though I have long acknowledged your superiority in most branches of science and literature, I little thought I would be compelled to confess it in biblical knowledge. I had forgotten the custom of putting prophets in the stocks, and I had to turn to the concordance to find Jeremiah 29:2677 for your text. At the same time I found, in Jeremiah 20:2–3, that Jeremiah himself had been put in the stocks. Many may think it impious, but I could not help wishing that the ancient practice had been continued down to more modern times, and that all the prophets, at least from Peter the Hermit88 to Nimrod Hughes99 inclusive, had been confined in the stocks and kept from spreading so many delusions and shedding so much blood. Nimrod’s mad rant was sent to me by Christopher along with his own, and I lent it to a neighbor, in whose house some visitors saw and read it. Could you believe that it spread a great deal of terror, and a serious fear that one third of the human race would be destroyed on the fourth day of next month? Since my neighbors are far from remarkably superstitious, I could not have believed what experience has now shown me.
Though I have long acknowledged your Superiority in most branches of Science and Litterature; I little thought of being compelled to confess it, in Biblical Knowledge. I had forgotten the custom of putting Prophets in the Stocks, and was obliged to have recourse to the concordance to discover Jer. 29. 267 for your Text, and found at the same time Jer. 20.2.3 that Jeremiah himself had been put in the Stocks. It may be thought impiety by many, but I could not help wishing that the ancient practice had been continued down to more modern times and that all the Prophets at least from Peter the hermit8, to Nimrod Hews9 inclusively had been confined in the Stocks and prevented from Spreading So many delusions and Shedding So much blood. Could you believe that the mad rant of Nimrod which was Sent to me, by Christopher with his own and which I lent to a Neigbour in whose house it was Seen and read by Some Visitors, Spread a great deal of terror and a Serious Apprehension that one third of the human race would be destroyed on the fourth day of the next month? As my neighbours are far from being remarkably Superstitious I could not have believed what has appeared in experience.
The transition from one set of crazy people to another is not unnatural. There were two gentlemen who sat together in the Senate of the United States for several years and became very intimate friends, uncommonly fond of each other. These were Mr. Pickering1010 and Mr. Hillhouse.1111 The circle in Boston who were in the former’s confidence understood the two to be perfectly united in opinion. The latter made no secret of his opinion that an amputation—a surgical operation, as he called it—had become necessary. He made a motion in the Senate for an amendment of the Constitution1212 that was in fact a total alteration of it, into as absurd and as arbitrary an aristocracy as was ever imagined, and he published this plan in a pamphlet. Pickering’s friends in Boston at first gave out that he agreed completely with Hillhouse in this project, and I heard some of them say that they went along with them all the way. I at once wrote an examination of it1313 and put it into the hands of the Anthologists1414 for publication; but because I had made rather free with some of their favorites, they declined to print it. Yet that manuscript, or something else, put them so out of love with the plan that they at once hushed it into oblivion. This project of a new constitution, which you must remember, was supposed to be meant for the arm or the leg, or the head or the tail, that the surgical operation was to cut off. I have heard that Mr. Pickering, on one of his journeys to the Senate of the United States, carried with him from his friends in Boston a project of a division1515 along the Potomac, the Delaware or the Hudson—that is, as far as they could succeed. He communicated it to General Hamilton, who could not see his way clear to it, and to Mr. King,1616 who liked it just as little. There can be little doubt that there is a party in New England, encouraged by more or fewer kindred spirits in every state in the Union, who wish to push the nation into a war with France1717 and to shelter themselves and their commerce under the wings of the British Navy at almost any price.
The transition from one Set of crazy people to another is not unnatural. There were two Gentlemen in the Senate of The United States together for several Years, who became very intimate Friends and uncommonly fond of each other. These were Mr Pickering10 and Mr Hillhouse11. They were understood by the Circle in Boston, who were in the Confidence of the former, to be perfectly united in Opinion. The latter made no Secret of his Opinion, that an Amputation and a Surgical Operation as he called it, was become necessary and he made a motion in Senate, for an Amendment of the Constitution12 which was indeed a total Alteration of it to as absurd and as arbitrary an Aristocracy as ever was imagined. This plan he published in a Pamphlet. P.’s friends in Boston at first gave out that he perfectly concurred with H. in this project, and I heard Some of them Say, that they went along with them throughout. I immediately wrote an Examination of it13, and put it into the hands of the Anthologists14 for publication: but as I had made pretty free with some of their favourites they declined printing it. But that Manuscript or Something else, put them So out of conceit of it, that they immediately hushed it into Oblivion. This Project of a new constitution, which you must remember, was Supposed to be intended for the Arm or the Leg, or the head or the Tail that was to be cut off by the chirurgical operation. I have heard that Mr P. once on his Journey to the Senate of U.S. carried with him from his friends in Boston a Project of a Division15 by the Potomac, the Delaware or the Hudson i.e as far as they could Succeed, and communicated it to Gen. Hamilton who could not See his Way clear, and to Mr King16, who liked it as little. That there is a Party in New England, encouraged by more or less of kindred Spirits in every State in the Union, who wish to urge the Nation to a War with France17 and to shelter themselves and their commerce under the Wings of the British Navy at almost any rate there can be little doubt.
I have long opposed these people in all such projects. But the national government, by embargoes,1818 non-importations, non-intercourses,1919 and above all by its opposition to any naval power,2020 has been constantly playing popularity into their hands. The consequence will soon be, if it is not already, that I and my sons2121 and all my friends will be hated throughout New England worse than Burr or Bonaparte ever was. If these measures are persisted in, there will be a convulsion as certainly as there is a sky over our heads.
I have long opposed these People in all Such Projects: but the national Government by Embargoes18, Non importations, Non Intercourses19, and above all by the opposition to any naval Power20, have been constantly playing popularity into their hands and the consequence will Soon be, if it is not already that I and my Sons21 and all my Friends will be hated throughout New England worse than Burr ever was or Bonaparte. If these measures are persisted in there will be a Convulsion as certainly as there is a Sky over our heads.
My better half bids me present to you her respect and regards of long standing, along with those of your old friend,
My better half, charges me to present you her ancient respect and regards with those of your old Friend
John Adams
John Adams
Notes2121
Adams’s letter of 1 MayCross-reference
Adams’s letter of 1 May 1812 reported that Jefferson’s pamphlet had reached him in a wrapper addressed in Jefferson’s hand but with no letter inside. This letter follows it up two days later, after the missing covering letter arrived.
Jefferson’s batture pamphletBook or text
Jefferson’s pamphlet The Proceedings of the Government of the United States, in Maintaining the Public Right to the Beach of the Missisipi (New York, 1812). In it he defended his decision as president to seize the New Orleans batture, a strip of riverbank claimed by Edward Livingston, who then sued him personally.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson's Preface to his Statement on the Batture Case, 25 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to Henry Wheaton, 5 July 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s letter of 20 AprilCross-reference
Jefferson’s letter of 20 April 1812 offered the pamphlet as ‘homespun’ in return for the Adams family writings Adams had sent him. It also answered Adams’s questions about the Richmond and Wabash prophets and quoted the Bible on putting false prophets in the stocks.
Jefferson to Adams, April 20, 1812
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 20 April 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Wabash ProphetPerson
Tenskwatawa (about 1775–1836), the Shawnee religious leader and brother of Tecumseh. He urged Native peoples to reject white ways, and in 1808 the brothers founded Prophetstown where the Tippecanoe meets the Wabash. William Henry Harrison’s troops defeated his followers there on 7 November 1811, which badly damaged his standing.
Sources: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab); Tenskwatawa, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
Christopher McPhersonPerson
Christopher McPherson (about 1763–1817) was born enslaved in Virginia, freed in 1792, and worked as a clerk in Richmond. After a religious conversion he called himself ‘Pherson, son of Christ’ and prophesied the end of the world. He had written to Adams while Adams was president. In the original, Adams spells the name ‘Macpherson’.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 29 January 1800 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
David AustinPerson
David Austin (1759–1831), a Yale graduate who became a Presbyterian pastor at Elizabethtown, New Jersey, in 1788. He was one of the best-known millennial preachers of his day, forecasting the approaching reign of Christ. He bombarded presidents with letters, and in 1802 Jefferson asked him to stop writing.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson Papers: David Austin to Thomas Jefferson (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); David Austin to Thomas Jefferson, 30 March 1801 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Jeremiah 29:26Quotation
This verse, which Jefferson quoted in his letter, reads in the King James Bible: ‘every man that is mad, and maketh himself a prophet, that thou shouldest put him in prison, and in the stocks.’ Stocks were a wooden frame that locked an offender’s feet or hands as a public punishment.
Source: Jeremiah 29:26 and 20:2–3 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
Peter the HermitPerson
Peter the Hermit (about 1050–1115), a French ascetic and one of the most influential popular preachers of the First Crusade. With Walter Sansavoir he led the ‘People’s Crusade’ of 1096, an ill-fated mass march east that set out ahead of the main armies.
Source: Peter the Hermit, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Nimrod Hughes’s prophecyBook or text
Nimrod Hughes of Washington County, Virginia, wrote the tract A Solemn Warning to All the Dwellers upon Earth (1811) after ten months in jail at Abingdon. It foretold that a third of mankind would be destroyed on 4 June 1812, and it ran through many editions. Adams’s copy came from Christopher McPherson. In the original, Adams spells the name ‘Hews’.
Sources: A Solemn Warning to all the Dwellers upon Earth, Library of Virginia imprint record (opens in a new tab); Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
Timothy PickeringPerson
Timothy Pickering (1745–1829) was Adams’s own secretary of state until Adams fired him in 1800. He served as a Federalist senator from Massachusetts from 1803 to 1811, and he was the most prominent figure in the ‘Essex Junto’, a group of hard-line New England Federalists.
Sources: Timothy Pickering, Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State (opens in a new tab); Timothy Pickering, U.S. Senate featured biography (opens in a new tab)
James HillhousePerson
James Hillhouse (1754–1832), a Connecticut Federalist who sat in the U.S. Senate from 1796 to 1810 and was treasurer of Yale College for half a century. He later served as a Connecticut delegate to the Hartford Convention of 1814.
Source: HILLHOUSE, James, History, Art & Archives, U.S. House of Representatives (opens in a new tab)
Hillhouse’s amendments of 1808Event
On 12 April 1808 Hillhouse laid a set of amendments before the Senate and then printed them with his explanations. They called for annual House elections, three-year Senate terms, abolition of the vice presidency, and a one-year president picked by drawing lots among the sitting senators.
Adams’s review of HillhouseBook or text
Adams’s critique of the Hillhouse plan, drafted after April 1808, was left unfinished and stayed in manuscript. It reached print only in the mid-nineteenth century, in volume 6 of The Works of John Adams, edited by his grandson Charles Francis Adams.
Sources: John Adams, Review of Hillhouse's proposed amendments, 1808 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The Works of John Adams, vol. 6 (Internet Archive) (opens in a new tab)
the Anthology SocietyPlace
These were the members of Boston’s Anthology Society, a club of Federalist-leaning literary men led by the Reverend William Emerson. They published the Monthly Anthology and Boston Review until 1811 and founded the Boston Athenaeum library in 1807.
Source: Literature and the Monthly Anthology, Encyclopedia.com (opens in a new tab)
the Northern Confederacy schemeEvent
In 1803–1804 Pickering and other New England Federalists talked of splitting the northern states from the Union into a ‘Northern Confederacy’. Hamilton and Rufus King both refused to back the idea. In his last letter, dated 10 July 1804, the eve of his duel with Burr, Hamilton warned that breaking up the Union would bring no good.
Sources: Alexander Hamilton to Theodore Sedgwick, 10 July 1804 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Essex Junto, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Rufus KingPerson
Rufus King (1755–1827), a Massachusetts-born Federalist who became one of New York’s first U.S. senators. He served as American minister to Great Britain from 1796 to 1803 and shared his party’s warmth toward Britain.
Source: Rufus King, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
war with Britain or FranceEvent
In the Napoleonic Wars both Britain and France seized American ships. In spring 1812 Republicans were moving toward war with Britain, while many New England Federalists, dependent on British trade, thought France the true enemy. Congress declared war on Britain on 18 June 1812, six weeks after this letter.
Sources: The Napoleonic Wars and the United States, 1803–1815, Office of the Historian (opens in a new tab); 'War Hawks' urge military confrontation with Britain, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
the embargoesLaw and politics
Adams means Jefferson’s Embargo Act of December 1807, which barred American ships from foreign trade until its repeal in March 1809, and the new 90-day embargo that Madison signed on 4 April 1812, a month before this letter. Both struck hard at New England’s shipping.
Sources: Embargo Act, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); James Madison to Congress, 1 April 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
non-importation and non-intercourseLaw and politics
These were trade laws aimed at Britain and France: the Non-Importation Act of 1806, which banned certain British goods; the Non-Intercourse Act of March 1809, which replaced the embargo; and the ban on British trade that Madison revived in February 1811 under Macon’s Bill No. 2.
Sources: Embargos: Economic Warfare on the Eve of the War of 1812, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab); The Napoleonic Wars and the United States, 1803–1815, Office of the Historian (opens in a new tab)
Republican naval policyIdea
Jefferson and his party cut back the oceangoing navy that Adams’s administration had built up and relied instead on small coastal gunboats. In 1807 Jefferson called gunboats the only useful defense on the water and a navy a ‘ruinous folly’.
Sources: From Thomas Jefferson to United States Congress, 10 February 1807 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Early American Stances on the Size and Role of the Military, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab)
John Quincy Adams’s breakPerson
Adams’s eldest son, John Quincy Adams, voted for Jefferson’s embargo as a senator from Massachusetts. In June 1808 the angry Federalist legislature chose his successor months early, and he resigned his seat and went over to the Republicans.
Source: John Quincy Adams: Break with the Federalists, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 1 MayCross-reference
Adams’s letter of 1 May 1812 reported that Jefferson’s pamphlet had reached him in a wrapper addressed in Jefferson’s hand but with no letter inside. This letter follows it up two days later, after the missing covering letter arrived.
Jefferson’s batture pamphletBook or text
Jefferson’s pamphlet The Proceedings of the Government of the United States, in Maintaining the Public Right to the Beach of the Missisipi (New York, 1812). In it he defended his decision as president to seize the New Orleans batture, a strip of riverbank claimed by Edward Livingston, who then sued him personally.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson's Preface to his Statement on the Batture Case, 25 February 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to Henry Wheaton, 5 July 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s letter of 20 AprilCross-reference
Jefferson’s letter of 20 April 1812 offered the pamphlet as ‘homespun’ in return for the Adams family writings Adams had sent him. It also answered Adams’s questions about the Richmond and Wabash prophets and quoted the Bible on putting false prophets in the stocks.
Jefferson to Adams, April 20, 1812
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 20 April 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the Wabash ProphetPerson
Tenskwatawa (about 1775–1836), the Shawnee religious leader and brother of Tecumseh. He urged Native peoples to reject white ways, and in 1808 the brothers founded Prophetstown where the Tippecanoe meets the Wabash. William Henry Harrison’s troops defeated his followers there on 7 November 1811, which badly damaged his standing.
Sources: Tenskwatawa, Dictionary of Canadian Biography (opens in a new tab); Tenskwatawa, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
Christopher McPhersonPerson
Christopher McPherson (about 1763–1817) was born enslaved in Virginia, freed in 1792, and worked as a clerk in Richmond. After a religious conversion he called himself ‘Pherson, son of Christ’ and prophesied the end of the world. He had written to Adams while Adams was president. In the original, Adams spells the name ‘Macpherson’.
Sources: Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Christopher McPherson, 29 January 1800 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
David AustinPerson
David Austin (1759–1831), a Yale graduate who became a Presbyterian pastor at Elizabethtown, New Jersey, in 1788. He was one of the best-known millennial preachers of his day, forecasting the approaching reign of Christ. He bombarded presidents with letters, and in 1802 Jefferson asked him to stop writing.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson Papers: David Austin to Thomas Jefferson (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); David Austin to Thomas Jefferson, 30 March 1801 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Jeremiah 29:26Quotation
This verse, which Jefferson quoted in his letter, reads in the King James Bible: ‘every man that is mad, and maketh himself a prophet, that thou shouldest put him in prison, and in the stocks.’ Stocks were a wooden frame that locked an offender’s feet or hands as a public punishment.
Source: Jeremiah 29:26 and 20:2–3 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
Peter the HermitPerson
Peter the Hermit (about 1050–1115), a French ascetic and one of the most influential popular preachers of the First Crusade. With Walter Sansavoir he led the ‘People’s Crusade’ of 1096, an ill-fated mass march east that set out ahead of the main armies.
Source: Peter the Hermit, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Nimrod Hughes’s prophecyBook or text
Nimrod Hughes of Washington County, Virginia, wrote the tract A Solemn Warning to All the Dwellers upon Earth (1811) after ten months in jail at Abingdon. It foretold that a third of mankind would be destroyed on 4 June 1812, and it ran through many editions. Adams’s copy came from Christopher McPherson. In the original, Adams spells the name ‘Hews’.
Sources: A Solemn Warning to all the Dwellers upon Earth, Library of Virginia imprint record (opens in a new tab); Christopher McPherson (ca. 1763–1817), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
Timothy PickeringPerson
Timothy Pickering (1745–1829) was Adams’s own secretary of state until Adams fired him in 1800. He served as a Federalist senator from Massachusetts from 1803 to 1811, and he was the most prominent figure in the ‘Essex Junto’, a group of hard-line New England Federalists.
Sources: Timothy Pickering, Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State (opens in a new tab); Timothy Pickering, U.S. Senate featured biography (opens in a new tab)
James HillhousePerson
James Hillhouse (1754–1832), a Connecticut Federalist who sat in the U.S. Senate from 1796 to 1810 and was treasurer of Yale College for half a century. He later served as a Connecticut delegate to the Hartford Convention of 1814.
Source: HILLHOUSE, James, History, Art & Archives, U.S. House of Representatives (opens in a new tab)
Hillhouse’s amendments of 1808Event
On 12 April 1808 Hillhouse laid a set of amendments before the Senate and then printed them with his explanations. They called for annual House elections, three-year Senate terms, abolition of the vice presidency, and a one-year president picked by drawing lots among the sitting senators.
Adams’s review of HillhouseBook or text
Adams’s critique of the Hillhouse plan, drafted after April 1808, was left unfinished and stayed in manuscript. It reached print only in the mid-nineteenth century, in volume 6 of The Works of John Adams, edited by his grandson Charles Francis Adams.
Sources: John Adams, Review of Hillhouse's proposed amendments, 1808 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The Works of John Adams, vol. 6 (Internet Archive) (opens in a new tab)
the Anthology SocietyPlace
These were the members of Boston’s Anthology Society, a club of Federalist-leaning literary men led by the Reverend William Emerson. They published the Monthly Anthology and Boston Review until 1811 and founded the Boston Athenaeum library in 1807.
Source: Literature and the Monthly Anthology, Encyclopedia.com (opens in a new tab)
the Northern Confederacy schemeEvent
In 1803–1804 Pickering and other New England Federalists talked of splitting the northern states from the Union into a ‘Northern Confederacy’. Hamilton and Rufus King both refused to back the idea. In his last letter, dated 10 July 1804, the eve of his duel with Burr, Hamilton warned that breaking up the Union would bring no good.
Sources: Alexander Hamilton to Theodore Sedgwick, 10 July 1804 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Essex Junto, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Rufus KingPerson
Rufus King (1755–1827), a Massachusetts-born Federalist who became one of New York’s first U.S. senators. He served as American minister to Great Britain from 1796 to 1803 and shared his party’s warmth toward Britain.
Source: Rufus King, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
war with Britain or FranceEvent
In the Napoleonic Wars both Britain and France seized American ships. In spring 1812 Republicans were moving toward war with Britain, while many New England Federalists, dependent on British trade, thought France the true enemy. Congress declared war on Britain on 18 June 1812, six weeks after this letter.
Sources: The Napoleonic Wars and the United States, 1803–1815, Office of the Historian (opens in a new tab); 'War Hawks' urge military confrontation with Britain, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
the embargoesLaw and politics
Adams means Jefferson’s Embargo Act of December 1807, which barred American ships from foreign trade until its repeal in March 1809, and the new 90-day embargo that Madison signed on 4 April 1812, a month before this letter. Both struck hard at New England’s shipping.
Sources: Embargo Act, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); James Madison to Congress, 1 April 1812 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
non-importation and non-intercourseLaw and politics
These were trade laws aimed at Britain and France: the Non-Importation Act of 1806, which banned certain British goods; the Non-Intercourse Act of March 1809, which replaced the embargo; and the ban on British trade that Madison revived in February 1811 under Macon’s Bill No. 2.
Sources: Embargos: Economic Warfare on the Eve of the War of 1812, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab); The Napoleonic Wars and the United States, 1803–1815, Office of the Historian (opens in a new tab)
Republican naval policyIdea
Jefferson and his party cut back the oceangoing navy that Adams’s administration had built up and relied instead on small coastal gunboats. In 1807 Jefferson called gunboats the only useful defense on the water and a navy a ‘ruinous folly’.
Sources: From Thomas Jefferson to United States Congress, 10 February 1807 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Early American Stances on the Size and Role of the Military, American Battlefield Trust (opens in a new tab)
John Quincy Adams’s breakPerson
Adams’s eldest son, John Quincy Adams, voted for Jefferson’s embargo as a senator from Massachusetts. In June 1808 the angry Federalist legislature chose his successor months early, and he resigned his seat and went over to the Republicans.
Source: John Quincy Adams: Break with the Federalists, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 3 May 1812 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-05-02-0011
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of June 12, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 3 May 1812. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-05-02-0011. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1812-05-03-adams-to-jefferson/.