Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson doubts the Mecklenburg declaration of independence
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson thanks Adams for three letters and argues at length that the newly printed Mecklenburg declaration of independence is a hoax. He also regrets that Ticknor and Bowditch have turned down posts at his university and announces a trip to his other home.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 876 words · 4 min read
The letter
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I am in your debt for your letters of May 21, May 27 and June 22. The first, which Mr. Greenwood22 delivered, gave me the pleasure of his acquaintance; and it is always a pleasure to become acquainted with gentlemen of fair-mindedness, worth and knowledge, as I found Mr. Greenwood to be. The one about Mr. Samuel Adams Wells33 will not be forgotten when the time and place come for it to be used to his advantage. But what has caught my particular attention is the paper from Mecklenburg County44 of North Carolina, published in the Essex Register,55 which you were so kind as to enclose in your last letter, of June 22.66 You seem to think it genuine. I believe it spurious. I take it to be a quite unjustifiable hoax, like the story of the volcano78 that was told us in such detail some half dozen years ago, as having broken out in North Carolina, in that part of the country and perhaps in that very county of Mecklenburg, for I do not remember its exact location. If this paper really was taken from the Raleigh Register, as stated, I wonder that it should have escaped Ritchie,89 who gathers what is good from every paper, as the bee does from every flower; and the National Intelligencer910 too, which is edited by a North Carolinian. And I wonder that the fire should blaze out all at once in Essex, 1,000 miles from where the spark is said to have fallen. But if it really was taken from the Raleigh Register, who is the narrator? And is the name signed to it real, or is it as fictitious as the paper itself? It appeals, too, to an original book, which is burned; to Mr. Alexander, who is dead;1011 to a joint letter from Caswell,1112 Hewes1213 and Hooper,1314 all dead; to a copy sent to the dead Caswell; and to another sent to Dr. Williamson,1415 whose memory, now probably dead, did not recall this gigantic step of his state’s county of Mecklenburg in the history he has written of North Carolina. Horry,1516 too, is silent in his history of Marion, whose field of action was the country bordering on Mecklenburg. Ramsay,1617 Marshall,1718 Jones, Girardin,1819 Wirt,1920 historians of the neighboring states, are all silent. When Mr. Henry’s resolutions,2021 which fell far short of independence, flew like lightning through every paper and set both sides of the Atlantic alight, this flaming declaration of the same date, declaring the independence of Mecklenburg County of North Carolina, absolving it from British allegiance and renouncing all political connection with that nation, is never heard of, although it too was sent to Congress. It is not known even a year later, when a similar proposition is first made2122 in that body. Armed with this bold example, would you not have thundered at our timid brethren for the fears that kept them lagging? Would not every advocate of independence have rung the glories of Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, in the ears of the doubting Dickinson2223 and the others who hung so heavily on us? Yet the example of independent Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, was never once quoted. The paper speaks, too, of the continued efforts of their delegation (Caswell, Hooper, Hewes) “in the cause of liberty and independence.” Now you remember as well as I do that we had no greater Tory2324 in Congress than Hooper; that Hewes was very wavering, sometimes firm, sometimes feeble, depending on whether the day was clear or cloudy; that Caswell, indeed, was a good Whig and kept these gentlemen up to the mark while he was present; but that he soon left us, and their line of conduct then became uncertain until Penn came,2425 and he fixed Hewes and the vote of the state. I must not be understood to suggest any doubt about the state of North Carolina. No state was firmer or further forward. Nor do I affirm positively that this paper is a fabrication, because the proof of a negative can only rest on presumption. But I shall believe it one until positive and solemn proof of its authenticity is produced. And if the name of McKnitt2526 is real, and not part of the fabrication, it needs to be vindicated by producing such proof. For the present I must be an unbeliever in this apocryphal gospel.
I am in debt to you for your letters of May 21. 27. & June 22. the first delivered me by mr Greenwood2 gave me the gratification of his acquaintance; and a gratification it always is to be made acquainted with gentlemen of candor, worth and information, as I found mr Greenwood to be. that on the subject of mr Samuel Adams Wells3 shall not be forgotten in time and place, when it can be used to his advantage. but what has attracted my peculiar notice is the paper from Mecklenburg county4 of N. Carolina, published in the Essex Register5 which you were so kind as to inclose in your last of June 22.6 and you seem to think it genuine. I believe it spurious. I deem it to be a very unjustifiable quiz7, like that of the Volcano8, so minutely related to us as having broken out in N. Carolina, some half dozen years ago, in that part of the country, and perhaps in that very county of Mecklenburg, for I do not remember it’s precise locality. if this paper be really taken from the Raleigh Register, as quoted, I wonder it should have escaped Ritchie9, who culls what is good from every paper, as the bee from every flower; and the National Intelligencer10 too, which is edited by a N. Carolinian. and that the fire should blaze out all at once in Essex, 1000. miles from where the spark is said to have fallen. but if really taken from the Raleigh Register, who is the Narrator, and is the name subscribed real, or is it as fictitious as the paper itself? it appeals too to an original book, which is burnt, to mr Alexander who is dead11, to a joint letter from Caswell12, Hughes13 and Hooper14, all dead, to a copy sent to the dead Caswell, and another sent to Doctr Williamson15, whose memory, now probably dead, did not recollect, in the history he has written of N. Carolina, this Gigantic step of it’s county of Mecklenburg. Horry16 too is silent in his history of Marion, whose scene of action was the country bordering on Mecklenburg. Ramsay17, Marshal18, Jones, Girardin19, Wirt20, historians of the adjacent states, all silent. when mr Henry’s resolutions21, far short of independance, flew like lightning thro’ every paper, and kindled both sides of the Atlantic, this flaming declaration, of the same date, of the independance of Mecklenburg county of N. Carolina, absolving it from British allegiance, and abjuring all political connection with that nation, altho’ sent to Congress too, is never heard of. it is not known even a twelve month after when a similar proposition is first made22 in that body. armed with this bold example, would not you have addressed our timid brethren in peals of thunder, on their tardy fears? would not every advocate of independance have rung the glories of Mecklenburg county in N. Carolina in the ears of the doubting Dickinson23 and others, who hung so heavily on us? yet the example of independant Mecklenburg county in N. Carolina, was never once quoted. the paper speaks too of the continued exertions of their delegation, (Caswell, Hooper, Hughes) ‘in the cause of liberty and independance.’ now you remember as well as I do, that we had not a greater tory24 in Congress than Hooper: that Hughes was very wavering, sometimes firm, sometimes feeble, according as the day was clear or cloudy; that Caswell indeed was a good whig, and kept these gentlemen to the notch, while he was present; but that he left us soon, and their line of conduct became then uncertain until Penn came25, who fixed Hughes and the vote of the state. I must not be understood as suggesting any doubtfulness in the state of N. Carolina. no state was more fixed or forward. nor do I affirm positively that this paper is a fabrication: because the proof of a negative can only be presumptive. but I shall believe it such until positive and solemn proof of it’s authenticity shall be produced. and if the name of M’Knitt26 be real, and not a part of the fabrication, it needs a vindication by the production of such proof. for the present I must be an unbeliever in this apocryphal gospel.
I am glad to learn that Mr. Ticknor2627 has returned safely to his friends, but I should have been much gladder had he accepted the professorship in our university, which we would have formally offered him. Mr. Bowditch2728 also turns us down. So bewitching is the bond of the sweet native soil.2829 Our wish is to obtain natives where they can be found, men like these gentlemen, of the first rank of learning in their respective fields; but since we prefer foreigners of the first rank to natives of the second, we shall certainly have to go, for several of our professors, to countries more advanced in science than we are.
I am glad to learn that mr Tickner27 is safely returned to his friends. but should have been much gladder had he accepted the Professorship in our University, which we should have offered him in form. mr Bowditch28 too refuses us. so fascinating is the vinculum of the dulce natale solum29. our wish is to procure natives where they can be found, like these gentlemen, of the first order of acquirement in their respective lines; but, preferring foreigners of the 1st order to natives of the 2d we shall certainly have to go, for several of our Professors, to countries more advanced in science than we are.
I set out within three or four days for my other home,2930 whose distance and roundabout mails are great obstacles to correspondence. I shall stay there about two months; and there, here and everywhere, I am and always shall be affectionately and respectfully yours.
I set out within 3. or 4. days for my other home30, the distance of which and it’s cross mails, are great impediments to epistolary communications. I shall remain there about 2. months: and there, here and every where, I am and shall always be affectionately & respectfully Your’s.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Notes2930
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop plantation house in Albemarle County, Virginia. He began building it in 1769, and it was his main home in retirement. The letter closes with his plan to leave it for his second house in Bedford County.
Sources: Encyclopedia Virginia: Monticello (opens in a new tab); Monticello: House FAQ (opens in a new tab)
Francis William Pitt GreenwoodPerson
Francis William Pitt Greenwood (1797–1843) was a young Unitarian minister at Boston’s New South Church and later minister of King’s Chapel. He traveled south in 1819 and visited Monticello, carrying Adams’s letter of 21 May 1819, which introduced him.
Adams to Jefferson, May 21, 1819
Sources: King's Chapel: Rev. Francis William Pitt Greenwood (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: William Eustis to Thomas Jefferson, 24 May 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Samuel Adams WellsPerson
Samuel Adams Wells (1787–1840), a Boston merchant and grandson of the patriot Samuel Adams, was collecting material for a life of his grandfather. In his letter of 27 May 1819, Adams asked Jefferson to recommend Wells to President Monroe for a post on the commission that would settle American claims under the new treaty with Spain.
Adams to Jefferson, May 27, 1819
Sources: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 27 May 1819 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Samuel Adams Wells, 12 May 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Mecklenburg DeclarationEvent
This text claimed that a meeting at Charlotte, in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, declared independence from Britain on 20 May 1775. It first appeared in the Raleigh Register on 30 April 1819 and was widely reprinted. Its authenticity is still disputed. A milder set of ‘Mecklenburg Resolves’, dated 31 May 1775, was later found printed in a June 1775 South Carolina newspaper.
Sources: Charlotte Museum of History: Evidence For and Against the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab)
Essex RegisterBook or text
A newspaper of Salem, Massachusetts. On 5 June 1819 it reprinted the Mecklenburg text, crediting it to the Raleigh Register, and Adams sent Jefferson that issue. Adams later defended the paper’s editors for printing it.
Sources: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 28 July 1819 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: William Bentley to John Adams, 14 August 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 22 June 1819Cross-reference
Adams’s letter of 22 June 1819 enclosed the newspaper. In it he called the Mecklenburg paper one of the greatest curiosities and deepest mysteries he had come across, and asked how it could have been kept from him.
Adams to Jefferson, June 22, 1819
Source: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 22 June 1819 (opens in a new tab)
North Carolina volcano hoaxEvent
In early 1812, during the New Madrid earthquakes, the Raleigh Register printed a letter signed John Clarke Edwards. It described a volcanic eruption in Buncombe County, in the North Carolina mountains. Rival papers soon exposed the story as fiction. Jefferson’s guess that it happened in Mecklenburg County was mistaken.
Sources: New Madrid Compendium (University of Memphis): 'Volcanic Eruption' (opens in a new tab); New Madrid Compendium (University of Memphis): 'We are informed...' (opens in a new tab)
Thomas RitchiePerson
Thomas Ritchie (died 1854) edited the Richmond Enquirer, Virginia’s leading Republican newspaper, from 1804 to 1845. Jefferson read it closely and called it the best newspaper in America.
Sources: Library of Virginia: Thomas Ritchie (opens in a new tab); Library of Virginia: Thomas Ritchie, Individual Biography (opens in a new tab)
National IntelligencerBook or text
This was the leading newspaper of Washington, D.C. Its editor, Joseph Gales Jr. (1786–1860), joined it in 1807. He was born in England but grew up in Raleigh, where his father published the Raleigh Register, the paper the Mecklenburg text was credited to.
Sources: NCpedia: Gales, Joseph, Jr. (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Gales, Joseph (opens in a new tab)
John McKnitt AlexanderPerson
John McKnitt Alexander (about 1733–1817) is named in the 1819 text as clerk of the Mecklenburg meeting. His original minutes were said to have burned with his house in 1800. He died on 10 July 1817, two years before the paper appeared.
Sources: Charlotte Museum of History: Evidence For and Against the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab)
Richard CaswellPerson
Richard Caswell (1729–1789) represented North Carolina in the Continental Congress in 1774 and 1775. He resigned in 1775 after the provincial congress made him one of the colony’s treasurers, and he became the first governor of the independent state.
Sources: NCpedia: Caswell, Richard (opens in a new tab); American Battlefield Trust: Richard Caswell (opens in a new tab)
Joseph HewesPerson
Joseph Hewes (1730–1779) was a merchant and North Carolina delegate who signed the Declaration of Independence. In the original, Jefferson spells his name ‘Hughes’. Adams’s letter of 22 June said Hewes’s vote finally made the colonies unanimous. NCpedia calls him a reluctant revolutionary who came to support independence by March 1776.
Sources: NCpedia: Hewes, Joseph (opens in a new tab); National Constitution Center: Joseph Hewes (opens in a new tab)
William HooperPerson
William Hooper (1742–1790) was a Boston-born, Harvard-trained lawyer who settled in Wilmington, North Carolina. He sat in Congress from 1774 to 1777. A social conservative who had once backed the royal government, he missed the vote on independence on 2 July 1776 but later signed the Declaration.
Sources: NCpedia: Hooper, William (opens in a new tab); National Constitution Center: William Hooper (opens in a new tab)
Hugh WilliamsonPerson
Hugh Williamson (1735–1819) was a physician, scientist and North Carolina delegate to the Constitutional Convention. In 1812 he published a two-volume History of North Carolina. He had in fact died on 22 May 1819, about seven weeks before this letter.
Sources: NCpedia: Williamson, Hugh (opens in a new tab); East Carolina University Digital Collections: The History of North Carolina, v. 1 (opens in a new tab)
Horry’s life of MarionBook or text
The Life of General Francis Marion (1809) was credited to Peter Horry, an officer in Marion’s brigade, and to the popular writer Mason Locke Weems, who did most of the writing. Marion led partisan raids against the British and Loyalists in South Carolina.
Sources: HathiTrust: The Life of General Francis Marion (opens in a new tab); Project Gutenberg: The Life of General Francis Marion (opens in a new tab)
David RamsayPerson
David Ramsay (1749–1815), a Charleston physician and politician, wrote The History of the Revolution of South-Carolina (1785), a general history of the American Revolution, and a life of Washington. That made him the chief historian of South Carolina’s role in the war.
Sources: Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia: David Ramsay (opens in a new tab); Online Library of Liberty: Ramsay, David: A Bibliography (opens in a new tab)
Marshall’s Life of WashingtonBook or text
This is John Marshall, the Virginian Chief Justice, whose five-volume Life of George Washington (1804–1807) was also a history of the Revolution. Jefferson thought it Federalist in outlook. In the original, Jefferson spells the name ‘Marshal’.
Source: Wythepedia: Life of George Washington (opens in a new tab)
Burk’s History of Virginia, volume 4Book or text
Skelton Jones and Louis Hue Girardin wrote the fourth volume (1816) of John Daly Burk’s History of Virginia, which covers the Revolution through Yorktown. After Burk died in 1808, Jones took up the work but died in 1812. Girardin finished it with Jefferson’s encouragement.
Sources: Library of Virginia: Imprint Record, The History of Virginia, vol. 4 (1816) (opens in a new tab); Wythepedia: The History of Virginia (opens in a new tab)
Wirt’s life of Patrick HenryBook or text
William Wirt (1772–1834), a Virginia lawyer, published Sketches of the Life and Character of Patrick Henry in 1817, after more than a decade of gathering recollections. Jefferson had sent him notes on Henry in 1812.
Sources: Wythepedia: Sketches of the Life and Character of Patrick Henry (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Editorial Note on Jefferson's notes for Wirt (opens in a new tab)
Patrick Henry’s 1775 resolutionsEvent
These are probably the resolutions Patrick Henry carried in the Virginia Convention on 23 March 1775, during his ‘liberty or death’ speech. They called for raising militia and putting Virginia into ‘a posture of defence’. They aimed at armed resistance, not separation from Britain.
Sources: Avalon Project: Resolutions of the Virginia Convention, March 1775 (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: The Virginia Revolutionary Conventions, 1774–1776 (opens in a new tab)
Lee ResolutionEvent
On 7 June 1776, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia moved in Congress that the colonies ‘are, and of right ought to be, free and independent States.’ Congress adopted the motion on 2 July 1776. That was more than a year after the date claimed for the Mecklenburg declaration.
Sources: National Archives: Lee Resolution (1776) (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: Lee's Resolution (1776) (opens in a new tab)
John DickinsonPerson
John Dickinson (1732–1808) of Pennsylvania led the case for delay in 1776. He argued that independence should wait until the colonies had a foreign alliance. He did not vote for independence on 2 July and never signed the Declaration.
Sources: National Constitution Center: John Dickinson (opens in a new tab); Monticello: John Dickinson (opens in a new tab)
toryWord
Strictly, a tory was an American who sided with the Crown during the Revolution. Jefferson uses the word loosely here. Hooper was a patriot who signed the Declaration, but Jefferson remembered him as the delegate most reluctant to break with Britain.
Sources: Merriam-Webster: Tory (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Hooper, William (opens in a new tab)
John PennPerson
John Penn (1740 or 1741–1788), a North Carolina lawyer, was elected in 1775 to take Caswell’s seat in Congress. He and Hewes cast North Carolina’s vote for independence on 2 July 1776, and he signed the Declaration.
Sources: NCpedia: Penn, John (opens in a new tab); North Carolina History Project: John Penn (1741–1788) (opens in a new tab)
Joseph McKnitt AlexanderPerson
The 1819 account was supplied by Dr. Joseph McKnitt Alexander, son of the clerk John McKnitt Alexander. In 1819 the papers were associated with ‘J McKnitt’, and McKnitt was a real family name. The exact signature printed in the Raleigh Register is uncertain.
Sources: Founders Online: William Bentley to John Adams, 14 August 1819 (opens in a new tab); UNC Libraries: Joseph McKnitt Alexander Papers (opens in a new tab)
George TicknorPerson
George Ticknor (1791–1871), a Boston scholar, came home in 1819 from four years of study in Europe, mostly at Göttingen. He then took up Harvard’s new Smith professorship of French and Spanish. Jefferson had hoped to recruit him for the new University of Virginia. In the original, the name is spelled ‘Tickner’.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: George Ticknor (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: George Ticknor to Thomas Jefferson, 13 February 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Nathaniel BowditchPerson
Nathaniel Bowditch (1773–1838) was a Salem mathematician and navigator, then president of an insurance company there. In November 1818 he declined Jefferson’s offer of the mathematics professorship at the planned university, citing his commitments in Salem.
Sources: Founders Online: Nathaniel Bowditch to Thomas Jefferson, 4 November 1818 (opens in a new tab); University of Virginia Astronomy: Early Astronomy at UVA (opens in a new tab)
vinculum of the dulce natale solumLanguage
This is Latin for ‘the bond of the sweet native soil’, meaning the pull of home. ‘Natale solum’ (native soil) echoes Ovid, who wrote from exile that the native soil draws everyone by some sweetness he could not name (Letters from the Black Sea 1.3.35).
Source: The Latin Library: Ovid, Epistulae ex Ponto, Book 1 (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
This is Poplar Forest, Jefferson’s retreat house and plantation in Bedford County near Lynchburg, roughly 70 to 90 miles south of Monticello and about three days’ travel away. He began the house in 1806 and usually stayed there for weeks at a time, several times a year.
Sources: Encyclopedia Virginia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab); Monticello: Route to Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab)
One more note explains a word of the original that the modern text does not use. Switch to the original to read it.
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop plantation house in Albemarle County, Virginia. He began building it in 1769, and it was his main home in retirement. The letter closes with his plan to leave it for his second house in Bedford County.
Sources: Encyclopedia Virginia: Monticello (opens in a new tab); Monticello: House FAQ (opens in a new tab)
Francis William Pitt GreenwoodPerson
Francis William Pitt Greenwood (1797–1843) was a young Unitarian minister at Boston’s New South Church and later minister of King’s Chapel. He traveled south in 1819 and visited Monticello, carrying Adams’s letter of 21 May 1819, which introduced him.
Adams to Jefferson, May 21, 1819
Sources: King's Chapel: Rev. Francis William Pitt Greenwood (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: William Eustis to Thomas Jefferson, 24 May 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Samuel Adams WellsPerson
Samuel Adams Wells (1787–1840), a Boston merchant and grandson of the patriot Samuel Adams, was collecting material for a life of his grandfather. In his letter of 27 May 1819, Adams asked Jefferson to recommend Wells to President Monroe for a post on the commission that would settle American claims under the new treaty with Spain.
Adams to Jefferson, May 27, 1819
Sources: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 27 May 1819 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Samuel Adams Wells, 12 May 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Mecklenburg DeclarationEvent
This text claimed that a meeting at Charlotte, in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina, declared independence from Britain on 20 May 1775. It first appeared in the Raleigh Register on 30 April 1819 and was widely reprinted. Its authenticity is still disputed. A milder set of ‘Mecklenburg Resolves’, dated 31 May 1775, was later found printed in a June 1775 South Carolina newspaper.
Sources: Charlotte Museum of History: Evidence For and Against the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab)
Essex RegisterBook or text
A newspaper of Salem, Massachusetts. On 5 June 1819 it reprinted the Mecklenburg text, crediting it to the Raleigh Register, and Adams sent Jefferson that issue. Adams later defended the paper’s editors for printing it.
Sources: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 28 July 1819 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: William Bentley to John Adams, 14 August 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 22 June 1819Cross-reference
Adams’s letter of 22 June 1819 enclosed the newspaper. In it he called the Mecklenburg paper one of the greatest curiosities and deepest mysteries he had come across, and asked how it could have been kept from him.
Adams to Jefferson, June 22, 1819
Source: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 22 June 1819 (opens in a new tab)
quizWord
Here ‘quiz’ means a hoax or practical joke. It was a common sense of the word around 1800 and is now obsolete. It has nothing to do with a test.
Source: Merriam-Webster: The Word History of 'Quiz' (opens in a new tab)
North Carolina volcano hoaxEvent
In early 1812, during the New Madrid earthquakes, the Raleigh Register printed a letter signed John Clarke Edwards. It described a volcanic eruption in Buncombe County, in the North Carolina mountains. Rival papers soon exposed the story as fiction. Jefferson’s guess that it happened in Mecklenburg County was mistaken.
Sources: New Madrid Compendium (University of Memphis): 'Volcanic Eruption' (opens in a new tab); New Madrid Compendium (University of Memphis): 'We are informed...' (opens in a new tab)
Thomas RitchiePerson
Thomas Ritchie (died 1854) edited the Richmond Enquirer, Virginia’s leading Republican newspaper, from 1804 to 1845. Jefferson read it closely and called it the best newspaper in America.
Sources: Library of Virginia: Thomas Ritchie (opens in a new tab); Library of Virginia: Thomas Ritchie, Individual Biography (opens in a new tab)
National IntelligencerBook or text
This was the leading newspaper of Washington, D.C. Its editor, Joseph Gales Jr. (1786–1860), joined it in 1807. He was born in England but grew up in Raleigh, where his father published the Raleigh Register, the paper the Mecklenburg text was credited to.
Sources: NCpedia: Gales, Joseph, Jr. (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Gales, Joseph (opens in a new tab)
John McKnitt AlexanderPerson
John McKnitt Alexander (about 1733–1817) is named in the 1819 text as clerk of the Mecklenburg meeting. His original minutes were said to have burned with his house in 1800. He died on 10 July 1817, two years before the paper appeared.
Sources: Charlotte Museum of History: Evidence For and Against the Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Mecklenburg Declaration of Independence (opens in a new tab)
Richard CaswellPerson
Richard Caswell (1729–1789) represented North Carolina in the Continental Congress in 1774 and 1775. He resigned in 1775 after the provincial congress made him one of the colony’s treasurers, and he became the first governor of the independent state.
Sources: NCpedia: Caswell, Richard (opens in a new tab); American Battlefield Trust: Richard Caswell (opens in a new tab)
Joseph HewesPerson
Joseph Hewes (1730–1779) was a merchant and North Carolina delegate who signed the Declaration of Independence. In the original, Jefferson spells his name ‘Hughes’. Adams’s letter of 22 June said Hewes’s vote finally made the colonies unanimous. NCpedia calls him a reluctant revolutionary who came to support independence by March 1776.
Sources: NCpedia: Hewes, Joseph (opens in a new tab); National Constitution Center: Joseph Hewes (opens in a new tab)
William HooperPerson
William Hooper (1742–1790) was a Boston-born, Harvard-trained lawyer who settled in Wilmington, North Carolina. He sat in Congress from 1774 to 1777. A social conservative who had once backed the royal government, he missed the vote on independence on 2 July 1776 but later signed the Declaration.
Sources: NCpedia: Hooper, William (opens in a new tab); National Constitution Center: William Hooper (opens in a new tab)
Hugh WilliamsonPerson
Hugh Williamson (1735–1819) was a physician, scientist and North Carolina delegate to the Constitutional Convention. In 1812 he published a two-volume History of North Carolina. He had in fact died on 22 May 1819, about seven weeks before this letter.
Sources: NCpedia: Williamson, Hugh (opens in a new tab); East Carolina University Digital Collections: The History of North Carolina, v. 1 (opens in a new tab)
Horry’s life of MarionBook or text
The Life of General Francis Marion (1809) was credited to Peter Horry, an officer in Marion’s brigade, and to the popular writer Mason Locke Weems, who did most of the writing. Marion led partisan raids against the British and Loyalists in South Carolina.
Sources: HathiTrust: The Life of General Francis Marion (opens in a new tab); Project Gutenberg: The Life of General Francis Marion (opens in a new tab)
David RamsayPerson
David Ramsay (1749–1815), a Charleston physician and politician, wrote The History of the Revolution of South-Carolina (1785), a general history of the American Revolution, and a life of Washington. That made him the chief historian of South Carolina’s role in the war.
Sources: Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia: David Ramsay (opens in a new tab); Online Library of Liberty: Ramsay, David: A Bibliography (opens in a new tab)
Marshall’s Life of WashingtonBook or text
This is John Marshall, the Virginian Chief Justice, whose five-volume Life of George Washington (1804–1807) was also a history of the Revolution. Jefferson thought it Federalist in outlook. In the original, Jefferson spells the name ‘Marshal’.
Source: Wythepedia: Life of George Washington (opens in a new tab)
Burk’s History of Virginia, volume 4Book or text
Skelton Jones and Louis Hue Girardin wrote the fourth volume (1816) of John Daly Burk’s History of Virginia, which covers the Revolution through Yorktown. After Burk died in 1808, Jones took up the work but died in 1812. Girardin finished it with Jefferson’s encouragement.
Sources: Library of Virginia: Imprint Record, The History of Virginia, vol. 4 (1816) (opens in a new tab); Wythepedia: The History of Virginia (opens in a new tab)
Wirt’s life of Patrick HenryBook or text
William Wirt (1772–1834), a Virginia lawyer, published Sketches of the Life and Character of Patrick Henry in 1817, after more than a decade of gathering recollections. Jefferson had sent him notes on Henry in 1812.
Sources: Wythepedia: Sketches of the Life and Character of Patrick Henry (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Editorial Note on Jefferson's notes for Wirt (opens in a new tab)
Patrick Henry’s 1775 resolutionsEvent
These are probably the resolutions Patrick Henry carried in the Virginia Convention on 23 March 1775, during his ‘liberty or death’ speech. They called for raising militia and putting Virginia into ‘a posture of defence’. They aimed at armed resistance, not separation from Britain.
Sources: Avalon Project: Resolutions of the Virginia Convention, March 1775 (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: The Virginia Revolutionary Conventions, 1774–1776 (opens in a new tab)
Lee ResolutionEvent
On 7 June 1776, Richard Henry Lee of Virginia moved in Congress that the colonies ‘are, and of right ought to be, free and independent States.’ Congress adopted the motion on 2 July 1776. That was more than a year after the date claimed for the Mecklenburg declaration.
Sources: National Archives: Lee Resolution (1776) (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: Lee's Resolution (1776) (opens in a new tab)
John DickinsonPerson
John Dickinson (1732–1808) of Pennsylvania led the case for delay in 1776. He argued that independence should wait until the colonies had a foreign alliance. He did not vote for independence on 2 July and never signed the Declaration.
Sources: National Constitution Center: John Dickinson (opens in a new tab); Monticello: John Dickinson (opens in a new tab)
toryWord
Strictly, a tory was an American who sided with the Crown during the Revolution. Jefferson uses the word loosely here. Hooper was a patriot who signed the Declaration, but Jefferson remembered him as the delegate most reluctant to break with Britain.
Sources: Merriam-Webster: Tory (opens in a new tab); NCpedia: Hooper, William (opens in a new tab)
John PennPerson
John Penn (1740 or 1741–1788), a North Carolina lawyer, was elected in 1775 to take Caswell’s seat in Congress. He and Hewes cast North Carolina’s vote for independence on 2 July 1776, and he signed the Declaration.
Sources: NCpedia: Penn, John (opens in a new tab); North Carolina History Project: John Penn (1741–1788) (opens in a new tab)
Joseph McKnitt AlexanderPerson
The 1819 account was supplied by Dr. Joseph McKnitt Alexander, son of the clerk John McKnitt Alexander. In 1819 the papers were associated with ‘J McKnitt’, and McKnitt was a real family name. The exact signature printed in the Raleigh Register is uncertain.
Sources: Founders Online: William Bentley to John Adams, 14 August 1819 (opens in a new tab); UNC Libraries: Joseph McKnitt Alexander Papers (opens in a new tab)
George TicknorPerson
George Ticknor (1791–1871), a Boston scholar, came home in 1819 from four years of study in Europe, mostly at Göttingen. He then took up Harvard’s new Smith professorship of French and Spanish. Jefferson had hoped to recruit him for the new University of Virginia. In the original, the name is spelled ‘Tickner’.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: George Ticknor (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: George Ticknor to Thomas Jefferson, 13 February 1819 (opens in a new tab)
Nathaniel BowditchPerson
Nathaniel Bowditch (1773–1838) was a Salem mathematician and navigator, then president of an insurance company there. In November 1818 he declined Jefferson’s offer of the mathematics professorship at the planned university, citing his commitments in Salem.
Sources: Founders Online: Nathaniel Bowditch to Thomas Jefferson, 4 November 1818 (opens in a new tab); University of Virginia Astronomy: Early Astronomy at UVA (opens in a new tab)
vinculum of the dulce natale solumLanguage
This is Latin for ‘the bond of the sweet native soil’, meaning the pull of home. ‘Natale solum’ (native soil) echoes Ovid, who wrote from exile that the native soil draws everyone by some sweetness he could not name (Letters from the Black Sea 1.3.35).
Source: The Latin Library: Ovid, Epistulae ex Ponto, Book 1 (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
This is Poplar Forest, Jefferson’s retreat house and plantation in Bedford County near Lynchburg, roughly 70 to 90 miles south of Monticello and about three days’ travel away. He began the house in 1806 and usually stayed there for weeks at a time, several times a year.
Sources: Encyclopedia Virginia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab); Monticello: Route to Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 9 July 1819 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-14-02-0491
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of June 15, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 9 July 1819. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-14-02-0491. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1819-07-09-jefferson-to-adams/.