Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson defends new words and materialism
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson reports on his health and the rising University of Virginia, answers the North American Review’s criticisms of its plan, defends the coining of new words, and replies to Adams’s puzzling letter on matter and spirit with a frank creed of materialism.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 1,823 words · 9 min read
The letter
I am a great defaulter in our correspondence, my dear Sir, but my broken health rarely lets me write, and when it does, matters of business press their claims imperiously. I am getting better, however, though slowly. Swollen legs are now my only serious symptom, and I believe they come from extreme weakness. I can walk only a little, but I ride six or eight miles a day without tiring, and in a few days I shall try to visit my other home,22 after a twelve months’ absence from it. Our University,33 four miles away, gives me frequent exercise, and all the more often because I am directing its architecture. Its plan is unique, and it is becoming a sight that travelers come to see. I have lately had a chance to read a critique of this institution in your North American Review44 of last January. I had been somewhat anxious to see what that able journal would say of us, and I was relieved to find much agreement of opinion in it. Even where it ventured criticisms, I found that they would have been headed off if we had set out our plan more fully. But a fuller account was ruled out by the nature of the paper reviewed: it was merely a report of outlines,55 not a detailed treatise, and it was addressed to a legislature, not to a learned academy. For example, to encourage the legislature to add Anglo-Saxon66 to our plan, the report said that it would amply reward the few weeks of attention that alone would be needed to learn it. I left both the length of time and the degree of learning vague on purpose, because I know that it takes little time to learn it well enough to be useful, well enough to teach the derivations of our language in a way that may satisfy ordinary students, while those who aim at a scholarly knowledge of it would need more time. In a letter I had occasion to write to Mr. Croft77 (who sent you, I believe, as he did me, a copy of his treatise on the English and German languages88 as a preliminary to an etymological dictionary he was planning), I explained to him an easy method for simplifying the study of Anglo-Saxon and lessening the terrors and difficulties of its crude alphabet and unsettled spelling. But this subject goes beyond the bounds of a letter, as it went beyond the bounds of a report to the legislature. Mr. Croft died, I believe, before he had made any progress on the work he had planned.
I am a great defaulter, my dear Sir, in our correspondence, but prostrate health rarely permits me to write; and, when it does, matters of business imperiously press their claims. I am getting better however, slowly, swelled legs being now the only serious symptom, and these, I believe, proceed from extreme debility. I can walk but little; but I ride 6. or 8. miles a day without fatigue; & within a few days, I shall endeavor to visit my other home2, after a twelve month’s absence from it. our University3, 4. miles distant, gives me frequent exercise, and the oftener as I direct it’s architecture. it’s plan is unique, and it is becoming an object of curiosity for the traveller. I have lately had an opportunity of reading a critique on this institution in your North American Review4 of January last, having been not without anxiety to see what that able work would say of us: and I was relieved on finding in it much coincidence of opinion, and even, where criticisms were indulged, I found they would have been obviated had the developements of our plan been fuller. but these were restrained by the character of the paper reviewed, being merely a report of outlines5, not a detailed treatise, & addressed to a legislative body, not to a learned academy. e.g. as an inducement to introduce the Anglo-Saxon6 into our plan, it was said that it would reward amply the few weeks of attention which alone would be requisite for it’s attainment; leaving both term and degree under an indefinite expression, because I know that not much time is necessary to attain it to an useful degree, sufficient to give such instruction in the etymologies of our language as may satisfy ordinary students, while more time would be requisite for those who would propose to attain a critical knolege of it. in a letter which I had occasion to write to mr Crofts7 (who sent you, I believe, as well as myself, a copy of his treatise on the English & German languages8, as preliminary to an Etymological dictionary he meditated) I went into explanations with him of an easy process for simplifying the study of the Anglo-Saxon, and lessening the terrors, & difficulties presented by it’s rude Alphabet, & unformed orthography. but this is a subject beyond the bounds of a letter, as it was beyond the bounds of a Report to the legislature. mr Crofts died, I believe, before any progress was made in the work he had projected.
The reviewer expresses doubt, rather than a firm judgment, about our placing military and naval architecture in the department of pure mathematics. Military architecture covers fortifications and field works, and these, with their bastions, curtains, hornworks, redoubts,99 and so on, rest on a technical combination of lines and angles. They are designed for attack and defense, both using and resisting the effects of bombs, cannonballs, assaults by scaling ladder, and so on. But lines and angles make up the whole of elementary geometry, a branch of pure mathematics. And the paths of bombs, balls and other projectiles, the necessary companions of military works, though no part of their architecture, belong to the conic sections,1010 a branch of higher geometry. Diderot and d’Alembert, therefore, in their tree of knowledge,1111 have placed military architecture in the department of elementary geometry. Naval architecture teaches the best shape and construction of ships. To find that best shape it turns to the problem of the solid of least resistance,1212 a problem of higher geometry. And the projectiles that belong to it fall under the same branch, as in the case before. It is true that, as far as it concerns the action of the water on the rudder and oars, and of the wind on the sails, it may be placed in the department of mechanics, as Diderot and d’Alembert have done. But since it belongs quite as much to geometry, and since in its military character it is allied to military architecture, it simplified our plan to place both under the same head. These reasons are so obvious that I am sure a second thought would have been enough to reconcile the reviewer to their location under the head of pure mathematics. For this word location, see Bailey, Johnson, Sheridan, Walker,1313 and so on. But if dictionaries are to be the judges of language, in which of them shall we find neologism? No matter. It is a good word, pleasant-sounding and obvious, and it expresses an idea that would otherwise need a roundabout phrase. The reviewer was therefore justified in using it, although at the same time he marked as unauthorized centrality, grade and sparse, all of which have long been used in common speech and writing. I am a friend to neology.1414 It is the only way to give a language richness and a pleasing sound. Without it we should still be held to the vocabulary of Alfred or of Ulfilas,1515 and held to their state of science as well, for I am sure they had no words that could have carried the ideas of oxygen, cotyledons, zoophytes, magnetism, electricity, hyaline, and thousands of others: ideas that did not then exist and could not have been communicated in the state of their language. What a language French has become since the time of the French Revolution, through the free introduction of new words! It is the richest and most eloquent in the living world, and it would equal Greek, had Greek not been regularly modifiable almost without end. Their rule was that whenever their language supplied or adopted a root, all its branches, in every part of speech, were made legitimate by giving them their proper endings: αδελφος,1616 αδελφη, αδελφιδιον, αδελφοτης, αδελφιξις, αδελφιδους, αδελφικος, αδελφιζω, αδελφικως. And this should be the law of every language. Thus, having adopted the adjective fraternal, we have a root that should make legitimate fraternity, fraternation, fraternization, fraternism, to fraternate, fraternize, fraternally. And give our language the word neologism as a root, and it should give us its fellow nouns, neology, neologist, neologization; its adjectives neologous, neological, neologistical; its verb neologize; and its adverb neologically. Dictionaries are only the storehouses of words already made legitimate by usage; society is the workshop in which new ones are shaped. When a person uses a new word, society rejects it if it is badly formed; if it is well formed, society adopts it, and in due time it is laid up in the storehouse of the dictionaries. And if, in this process of sound neologization, our brethren across the Atlantic do not choose to come with us, we may furnish, after the Ionians,1717 a second example of a colonial dialect improving on its parent. But enough of criticism. Let me turn to your puzzling letter of May 121818 on matter, spirit, motion, and so on. Its crowd of doubts kept me from sleep. I read it and laid it down; read it, and laid it down, again and again. To give my mind rest, I was finally obliged to fall back on my habitual anodyne,1919 “I feel, therefore I exist.”2020 I feel bodies that are not myself, so there are other existences. I call them matter. I feel them changing place, and this gives me motion. Where there is an absence of matter, I call it void, or nothing, or immaterial space. On the basis of sensation, of matter and motion, we may raise the structure of all the certainties we can have or need. I can conceive of thought as an action of a particular organization of matter, formed for that purpose by its creator, just as attraction is an action of matter, or magnetism of the lodestone. When the person who denies the Creator the power of giving matter the mode of action called thinking can show how the Creator could give the sun the mode of action called attraction, which reins the planets in the track of their orbits, or how an absence of matter can have a will and by that will set matter in motion, then the materialist may fairly be required to explain the process by which matter exercises the faculty of thinking. Once we leave the basis of sensation, everything is adrift. To talk of immaterial existences is to talk of nothings. To say that the human soul, angels and God are immaterial is to say that they are nothings, or that there is no God, no angels, no soul. I cannot reason otherwise, but I believe I am supported in my creed of materialism by Locke, Tracy and Stewart.2121 At what age of the Christian church this heresy of immaterialism, this masked atheism, crept in, I do not know. But a heresy it certainly is. Jesus taught nothing of it. He told us indeed that “God is a spirit,”2222 but he has not defined what a spirit is, nor said that it is not matter. And the ancient Fathers generally, if not universally, held it to be matter: light and thin indeed, an ethereal gas, but still matter. Origen2323 says, “God is in fact bodily, but bodiless only in comparison with heavier bodies.” Tertullian2424 says, “For what is God but a body?” and again, “Who will deny that God is a body? Although God is a spirit, spirit too is a body, of its own kind, in its own form.” St. Justin Martyr2525 says, “We say that the divine is bodiless—not because it is bodiless, but because to be contained by nothing is nobler than to be contained; for this reason we call it bodiless.” And St. Macarius,2626 speaking of angels, says, “For although they are subtle, yet in substance, form and shape, according to the fineness of their nature, they are fine bodies.” And St. Augustine, St. Basil, Lactantius, Tatian, Athenagoras2727 and others, whose writings I do not claim to know well, are said by those who do know them to teach the same doctrine. Turn to your d’Argens Ocellus,2828 pages 97 and 105, and to his Timaeus, page 17, for these quotations. In England these immaterialists might have been burned until the 29th year of Charles II, when the writ for the burning of a heretic2929 was abolished; and here they might have been burned until the Revolution, since that statute did not extend to us. Now that all heresies have been done away with among us, these schismatics are merely atheists. They differ from the materialist atheist only in their belief that “nothing made something,” and from the materialist deist, who believes that matter alone can act on matter. Rejecting, therefore, every source of information but my senses, I rid myself of the Pyrrhonisms3030 with which indulging in speculations beyond nature and contrary to it so uselessly occupies and disturbs the mind. A single sense may indeed sometimes be deceived, but rarely, and never all our senses together, with their faculty of reasoning. They give evidence of realities, and there are enough of these for all the purposes of life without plunging into the bottomless abyss of dreams and phantoms. I am satisfied, and kept busy enough, with the things that are, without tormenting or troubling myself about those that may indeed be, but of which I have no evidence. I am sure that I really know many, many things, and none more surely than that I love you with all my heart, and I pray that your life may continue until you are tired of it yourself.
The reviewer expresses doubt, rather than decision, on our placing Military, and Naval architecture in the department of Pure Mathematics. Military architecture embraces fortification and field works, which with their bastions, curtains, hornworks, redoubts9 Et. are based on a technical combination of lines & angles. these are adapted to offence and defence, with and against the effects of bombs, balls, escalades Etc. but lines and angles make the sum of elementary geometry, a branch of Pure Mathematics: and the direction of the bombs, balls, and other projectiles, the necessary appendages of military works, altho’ no part of their architecture, belong to the Conic sections10, a branch of transcendental geometry. Diderot & Dalembert therefore, in their Arbor scientiae11, have placed military architecture in the department of elementary geometry. Naval architecture teaches the best form and construction of vessels; for which best form it has recourse to the question of the Solid of least resistance12, a problem of transcendental geometry. and it’s appurtenant projectiles belong to the same branch, as in the preceding case. it is true that so far as respects the action of the water on the rudder and oars, and of the wind on the sails, it may be placed in the department of Mechanics, as Diderot & Dalembert have done: but belonging quite as much to geometry, and allied in it’s military character, to military architecture, it simplified our plan to place both under the same head. these views are so obvious that I am sure they would have required but a second thought to reconcile the reviewer to their location under the head of Pure Mathematics. for this word location, see Bailey Johnson, Sheridan, Walker13 Etc. but if Dictionaries are to be the Arbiters of language, in which of them shall we find neologism? no matter. it is a good word, well sounding, obvious, and expresses an idea which would otherwise require circumlocution. the Reviewer was justifiable therefore in using it; altho’ he noted at the same time, as unauthoritative, centrality, grade, sparse; all which have been long used in common speech and writing. I am a friend to neology14. it is the only way to give to a language copiousness & euphony. without it we should be still held to the vocabulary of Alfred or of Ulphilas15; and held to their state of science also: for I am sure they had no words which could have conveyed the ideas of Oxigen, cotyledons, zoophytes, magnetism, electricity, hyaline, and thousands of others expressing ideas not then existing, nor of possible communication in the state of their language. What a language has the French become since the date of their revolution, by the free introduction of new words! the most copious and eloquent in the living world; and equal to the Greek, had not that been regularly modifiable almost ad infinitum. their rule was that whenever their language furnished or adopted a root, all it’s branches, in every part of speech were legitimated by giving them their appropriate terminations. αδελφος16. αδελφη, αδελφιδιον, αδελφοτης, αδελφιξις, αδελφιδους, αδελφικος, αδελφιζω, αδελφικως. and this should be the law of every language. thus, having adopted the adjective fraternal, it is a root, which should legitimate fraternity, fraternation, fraternisation, fraternism, to fraternate, fraternise, fraternally. and give the word neologism to our language, as a root, and it should give us it’s fellow-substantives, neology, neologist, neologisation; it’s adjectives neologous, neological, neologistical, it’s verb neologise, & adverb neologically: Dictionaries are but the depositories of words already legitimated by usage. society is the work-shop in which new ones are elaborated. when an individual uses a new word, if illformed it is rejected in society, if well-formed, adopted, and, after due time, laid up in the depository of dictionaries. and if, in this process of sound neologisation, our transatlantic brethren shall not chuse to accompany us, we may furnish, after the Ionians17, a second example of a colonial dialect improving on it’s primitive.—but enough of criticism: let me turn to your puzzling letter of May 1218. on matter, spirit, motion Etc. it’s croud of scepticisms kept me from sleep. I read it, & laid it down: read it, and laid it down, again, and again: and to give rest to my mind, I was obliged to recur ultimately to my habitual anodyne19, ‘I feel: therefore I exist20.’ I feel bodies which are not myself: there are other existencies then. I call them matter. I feel them changing place. this gives me motion. where there is an absence of matter, I call it void, or nothing, or immaterial space. on the basis of sensation, of matter and motion, we may erect the fabric of all the certainties we can have or need. I can concieve thought to be an action of a particular organisation of matter, formed for that purpose by it’s creator, as well as that attraction is an action of matter, or magnetism of loadstone. when he who denies to the Creator the power of endowing matter with the mode of action called thinking shall shew how he could endow the Sun with the mode of action called attraction, which reins the planets in the tract of their orbits, or how an absence of matter can have a will, and, by that will, put matter into motion, then the materialist may be lawfully required to explain the process by which matter exercises the faculty of thinking. when once we quit the basis of sensation all is in the wind. to talk of immaterial existences is to talk of nothings. to say that the human soul, angels, god, are immaterial, is to say they are nothings, or that there is no god, no angels, no soul. I cannot reason otherwise: but I believe I am supported in my creed of materialism by Locke, Tracy, & Stewart21. at what age of the Christian church this heresy of immaterialism, this masked atheism crept in, I do not know. but a heresy it certainly is. Jesus taught nothing of it. he told us indeed that ‘God is a spirit22,’ but he has not defined what a spirit is, nor said that it is not matter. and the antient fathers generally, if not universally, held it to be matter: light and thin indeed, an etheriel gas; but still matter. Origen23 says ‘Deus reapse corporalis est; sed graviorum tantum corporum ratione, incorporeus.’ Tertullian24 ‘quid enim deus nisi corpus?’ and again ‘quis negabit deum esse corpus? etsi deus spiritus, spiritus etiam corpus est, sui generis, in sua effigie.’ St Justin Martyr25 ‘το θειον φαμεν ειναι αςωματον· ουκ ὁτι αςωματον,·—επειδη δε το μη κρατειςθαι ὑπο τινος, του κρατειςθαι τιμιωτερον εϚι, δια τουτο καλουμεν αυτον αςωματον.’ and St Macarius26, speaking of angels says ‘quamvis enim subtilia sint, tamen in substantiâ, formâ et figurâ, secundum tenuitatem naturae eorum, corpora sunt tenuia.’ and St Austin, St Basil, Lactantius, Tatian, Athenagoras27 and others, with whose writings I pretend not a familiarity, are said by those who are, to deliver the same doctrine. turn to your Ocellus d’Argens28 97. 105. and to his Timaeus 17. for these quotations. in England these Immaterialists might have been burnt until the 29. Car. 2. when the writ de haeretico comburendo29 was abolished: and here until the revolution, that statute not having extended to us. all heresies being now done away with us, these schismatists are merely atheists, differing from the material Atheist only in their belief that ‘nothing made something,’ and from the material deist who believes that matter alone can operate on matter. Rejecting all organs of information therefore but my senses, I rid myself of the Pyrrhonisms30 with which an indulgence in speculations hyperphysical and antiphysical so uselessly occupy and disquiet the mind. a single sense may indeed be sometimes decieved, but rarely: and never all our senses together, with their faculty of reasoning. they evidence realities; and there are enough of these for all the purposes of life, without plunging into the fathomless abyss of dreams & phantasms. I am satisfied, and sufficiently occupied with the things which are, without tormenting or troubling myself about those which may indeed be, but of which I have no evidence. I am sure that I really know many, many, things, and none more surely than that I love you with all my heart, and pray for the continuance of your life until you shall be tired of it yourself.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Notes3030
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s hilltop house and plantation just outside Charlottesville, in Albemarle County, Virginia. The university he describes in this letter was being built about four miles away.
Source: Thomas Jefferson Foundation, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
Poplar Forest, Jefferson’s plantation in Bedford County, Virginia. From 1806 he built an octagonal brick house there as a retreat from the stream of visitors at Monticello, and he usually stayed there for weeks at a time, several times a year.
Sources: Monticello Encyclopedia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab)
University of VirginiaPlace
The University of Virginia, which the state legislature chartered on 25 January 1819 on the site of Central College near Charlottesville. Jefferson planned its course of study and designed its ‘academical village’ of pavilions and colonnades around a lawn. It took in its first students in 1825.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: University of Virginia (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: University of Virginia, The Architecture of the (opens in a new tab)
North American ReviewBook or text
A Boston magazine founded in 1815 that became one of the country’s leading literary and critical journals. Jefferson probably calls it ‘your’ review because it was published in Adams’s state of Massachusetts. Its January 1820 number carried a long review of the plan for the University of Virginia.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: North American Review (opens in a new tab)
Rockfish Gap ReportBook or text
State commissioners met at a tavern in Rockfish Gap, a pass in the Blue Ridge, on 1–4 August 1818 to choose a site and sketch a plan for Virginia’s university. This is their report. Jefferson drafted it, and it was presented to the General Assembly in December 1818.
Sources: Founders Online: Rockfish Gap Report of the University of Virginia Commissioners, 4 August 1818 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Jefferson's Draft of the Rockfish Gap Report, ca. 28 June 1818 (opens in a new tab)
Anglo-Saxon studiesIdea
Anglo-Saxon is Old English, the language of England before the Norman Conquest. Jefferson valued it as the root of modern English and wrote an essay on simpler ways to learn it. The University of Virginia went on to offer what scholars count as the first college course in Old English in America.
Sources: Monticello Encyclopedia: Anglo-Saxon Language (opens in a new tab); Stanley R. Hauer, "Thomas Jefferson and the Anglo-Saxon Language," PMLA (opens in a new tab)
Sir Herbert CroftPerson
Sir Herbert Croft (1751–1816) was an English clergyman and author, best known for the novel Love and Madness. He spent years collecting words for a dictionary meant to improve on Samuel Johnson’s but never got it into print, and he died in Paris on 26 April 1816. In the original, Jefferson writes the name ‘Crofts’.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Herbert Croft (opens in a new tab); Trinity College Cambridge Archives: Croft, Sir Herbert (1751-1816), writer and lexicographer (opens in a new tab)
Croft’s pamphlet on English and GermanBook or text
Croft’s pamphlet comparing the two languages was printed at Hamburg in 1797, written as an open letter to Britain’s Princess Royal. Jefferson answered Croft on 30 October 1798. He praised the dictionary scheme and set out his own ideas for making Anglo-Saxon easier to learn.
Source: Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Herbert Croft, 30 October 1798 (opens in a new tab)
fortification termsWord
These are the standard parts of a fortress of the period. Bastions are pointed projections from the main wall that let defenders fire along it. Curtains are the straight stretches of wall between bastions. A hornwork is an outwork whose front has two half-bastions, and a redoubt is a small enclosed work that can be defended on every side.
Sources: Réseau Vauban illustrated glossary: Hornwork (opens in a new tab); American Battlefield Trust: Glossary of Fortification Terms (opens in a new tab)
conic sectionsIdea
These are the curves made by slicing a cone with a plane: the circle, ellipse, parabola and hyperbola. Galileo showed in his Two New Sciences (1638) that a projectile, leaving air resistance aside, travels along a parabola. That is why gunnery could be treated as a branch of higher geometry.
Source: University of Virginia, Galileo and Einstein: Galileo on Projectiles (opens in a new tab)
tree of knowledge of the EncyclopédieBook or text
Latin for ‘tree of knowledge’. Jefferson means the chart printed in 1751 in the first volume of the Encyclopédie, edited by Denis Diderot and Jean le Rond d’Alembert. Following Francis Bacon, it sorts all learning under memory, reason and imagination and draws each science as a branch.
Sources: MIT Libraries exhibit: Systême figuré des connaissances humaines (opens in a new tab); ARTFL Encyclopédie Project, University of Chicago (opens in a new tab)
solid of least resistanceIdea
Isaac Newton posed this problem in Book II of his Principia (1687) and gave a solution there. It asks what shape of body, symmetrical around its axis, meets the least resistance when it moves through a fluid along that axis. Solving it calls for the methods of the calculus.
Sources: Newton, Principia, Book II, Section VII, translated by Ian Bruce (opens in a new tab); Plakhov, "Newton's aerodynamic problem in media of chaotically moving particles" (arXiv) (opens in a new tab)
English dictionariesBook or text
These are four standard English dictionaries of the 1700s: Nathan Bailey’s Universal Etymological English Dictionary (1721), Samuel Johnson’s Dictionary of the English Language (1755), Thomas Sheridan’s General Dictionary of the English Language (1780), and John Walker’s Critical Pronouncing Dictionary (1791).
Sources: Grolier Club exhibition: Lexicography in the Early 18th Century (opens in a new tab); Grub Street Project: Sheridan, A General Dictionary of the English Language (1780) (opens in a new tab)
neologyWord
Neology is the coining of new words, or the use of old words in new senses. Its relative ‘neologism’ had come into English from French only around 1772.
Sources: Merriam-Webster: neology (opens in a new tab); Merriam-Webster: neologism (opens in a new tab)
UlfilasPerson
Ulfilas, or Wulfila (c. 311–383), was a bishop and missionary to the Goths. He is credited with inventing a Gothic alphabet and with the oldest Bible translation in any Germanic language. Jefferson pairs him with Alfred the Great, the ninth-century English king, as examples of the earliest written forms of the Germanic languages.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Ulfilas (opens in a new tab)
Greek word familyLanguage
These Greek words all grow from the root adelphos, ‘brother’. In order they mean brother, sister, little brother, brotherhood, kinship between brothers, nephew, brotherly, to call someone brother, and in a brotherly way.
Source: Perseus Scaife ATLAS: Liddell–Scott–Jones Greek Lexicon entry (opens in a new tab)
Ionian GreekIdea
Ionic was the Greek dialect of the cities that settlers from Athens founded on the coast of Asia Minor from about 1000 BC. The oldest Greek prose, including Herodotus’s history and the early philosophers, was written in it until Attic took its place in the 400s BC.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Ionic dialect (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 12 May 1820Cross-reference
In his letter of 12 May 1820 from Montezillo, Adams called the dispute between spirit and matter pointless, since we know the essence of neither. He drew on Berkeley and on the infinite divisibility of matter, and ended by resting on Jefferson’s ‘pillow of ignorance’.
Adams to Jefferson, May 12, 1820
Source: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 12 May 1820 (opens in a new tab)
anodyneWord
In its older medical sense, an anodyne is a remedy that eases pain or soothes. Here it means a reliable calming thought. It does not mean ‘bland’, the word’s usual sense today.
I feel, therefore I existQuotation
Jefferson reworks René Descartes’s ‘I think, therefore I am’ (‘Je pense, donc je suis’) from the Discourse on Method (1637). By putting feeling in place of thinking, he makes the senses, rather than pure thought, the starting point of certainty.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: cogito, ergo sum (opens in a new tab)
Locke, Tracy and StewartPerson
Three philosophers of the mind. John Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690) allowed that God might give matter the power to think. Antoine Destutt de Tracy (1754–1836) was a French ‘Idéologue’ whose Treatise on Political Economy Jefferson revised in translation. Dugald Stewart (1753–1828) was a Scottish philosopher of the common-sense school.
Sources: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Supplement to John Locke (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Dugald Stewart (opens in a new tab)
God is a spiritQuotation
Jesus says this to the Samaritan woman at the well in John 4:24. The King James Version reads: ‘God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.’
Source: John 4:24 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
Origen on God’s bodyQuotation
Origen (c. 185–c. 254) was a theologian and teacher of Alexandria. The Latin means roughly: ‘God is in fact bodily, and is called bodiless only in comparison with grosser bodies.’ The wording probably comes from Pierre-Daniel Huet’s commentary on Origen, which Jefferson quoted to Thomas Cooper the day before writing this letter.
Sources: Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 14 August 1820 (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Origen (summary) (opens in a new tab)
Tertullian on God’s bodyQuotation
Tertullian (c. 160–after 220) was a Latin Christian writer of Carthage. The quotations mean ‘For what is God but a body?’ and ‘Who will deny that God is a body? Though God is a spirit, spirit is a body of its own kind, in its own form.’ The second comes from chapter 7 of his Against Praxeas.
Sources: Tertullian, Against Praxeas, Latin text and English translation (Evans), tertullian.org (opens in a new tab); Bibliothek der Kirchenväter: Adversus Praxean (opens in a new tab)
Justin Martyr on the divineQuotation
Justin Martyr (c. 100–c. 165) was a Christian apologizt, executed at Rome, who blended Greek philosophy with Christian teaching. The Greek says, in substance, that we call the divine ‘bodiless’ not because it truly lacks a body, but because being contained by nothing is nobler than being contained. Jefferson took it secondhand, from the d’Argens volumes he cites below.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: St. Justin Martyr (opens in a new tab)
Macarius on angelsQuotation
Macarius the Egyptian (c. 300–390) was a Desert Father who helped establish monasticism in Egypt. The Latin says that angels, however subtle, are still bodies in substance, form and shape, as fine as their nature is fine.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macarius the Egyptian (opens in a new tab)
other Church FathersPerson
Five early Christian writers: Augustine of Hippo (354–430), who appears here as ‘St Austin’, an older English form of his name; Basil of Caesarea (c. 330–379); the Latin apologizt Lactantius (c. 250–c. 325); and Tatian and Athenagoras, Greek defenders of Christianity in the second century.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: patristic literature (opens in a new tab)
d’Argens’s Ocellus and TimaeusBook or text
These are French editions by Jean-Baptiste de Boyer, Marquis d’Argens: Ocellus Lucanus (1762) and Timée de Locres (1763). Each prints a Greek text ascribed to an early Pythagorean, with a French translation and long commentary. Jefferson’s numbers are page references, and ‘your’ suggests that Adams owned copies.
Sources: Founders Online: de Bure Frères invoice listing d'Argens's Ocellus Lucanus and Timée de Locres (opens in a new tab); Sowerby, Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson, vol. II, p. 26 (Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
writ for burning hereticsLaw and politics
Latin for ‘on the burning of a heretic’. This was the English writ under which condemned heretics were burned. An act of Parliament of 1677, cited by regnal year as 29 Charles II, chapter 9, abolished the writ and with it the death penalty for heresy.
Sources: legislation.gov.uk: Act for taking away the Writ De Heretico comburendo, 29 Cha. 2 c. 9 (opens in a new tab); The Statutes Project: 1677, 29 Charles 2 c.9, Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction Act (opens in a new tab)
PyrrhonismIdea
Pyrrhonism is thoroughgoing doubt, named after Pyrrho of Elis (c. 360–c. 272 BC), founder of ancient Greek skepticism. He taught that we should suspend judgment about what can truly be known and live by appearances.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Pyrrhonism (opens in a new tab)
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s hilltop house and plantation just outside Charlottesville, in Albemarle County, Virginia. The university he describes in this letter was being built about four miles away.
Source: Thomas Jefferson Foundation, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
Poplar Forest, Jefferson’s plantation in Bedford County, Virginia. From 1806 he built an octagonal brick house there as a retreat from the stream of visitors at Monticello, and he usually stayed there for weeks at a time, several times a year.
Sources: Monticello Encyclopedia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: Poplar Forest (opens in a new tab)
University of VirginiaPlace
The University of Virginia, which the state legislature chartered on 25 January 1819 on the site of Central College near Charlottesville. Jefferson planned its course of study and designed its ‘academical village’ of pavilions and colonnades around a lawn. It took in its first students in 1825.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: University of Virginia (opens in a new tab); Encyclopedia Virginia: University of Virginia, The Architecture of the (opens in a new tab)
North American ReviewBook or text
A Boston magazine founded in 1815 that became one of the country’s leading literary and critical journals. Jefferson probably calls it ‘your’ review because it was published in Adams’s state of Massachusetts. Its January 1820 number carried a long review of the plan for the University of Virginia.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: North American Review (opens in a new tab)
Rockfish Gap ReportBook or text
State commissioners met at a tavern in Rockfish Gap, a pass in the Blue Ridge, on 1–4 August 1818 to choose a site and sketch a plan for Virginia’s university. This is their report. Jefferson drafted it, and it was presented to the General Assembly in December 1818.
Sources: Founders Online: Rockfish Gap Report of the University of Virginia Commissioners, 4 August 1818 (opens in a new tab); Founders Online: Jefferson's Draft of the Rockfish Gap Report, ca. 28 June 1818 (opens in a new tab)
Anglo-Saxon studiesIdea
Anglo-Saxon is Old English, the language of England before the Norman Conquest. Jefferson valued it as the root of modern English and wrote an essay on simpler ways to learn it. The University of Virginia went on to offer what scholars count as the first college course in Old English in America.
Sources: Monticello Encyclopedia: Anglo-Saxon Language (opens in a new tab); Stanley R. Hauer, "Thomas Jefferson and the Anglo-Saxon Language," PMLA (opens in a new tab)
Sir Herbert CroftPerson
Sir Herbert Croft (1751–1816) was an English clergyman and author, best known for the novel Love and Madness. He spent years collecting words for a dictionary meant to improve on Samuel Johnson’s but never got it into print, and he died in Paris on 26 April 1816. In the original, Jefferson writes the name ‘Crofts’.
Sources: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Herbert Croft (opens in a new tab); Trinity College Cambridge Archives: Croft, Sir Herbert (1751-1816), writer and lexicographer (opens in a new tab)
Croft’s pamphlet on English and GermanBook or text
Croft’s pamphlet comparing the two languages was printed at Hamburg in 1797, written as an open letter to Britain’s Princess Royal. Jefferson answered Croft on 30 October 1798. He praised the dictionary scheme and set out his own ideas for making Anglo-Saxon easier to learn.
Source: Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Herbert Croft, 30 October 1798 (opens in a new tab)
fortification termsWord
These are the standard parts of a fortress of the period. Bastions are pointed projections from the main wall that let defenders fire along it. Curtains are the straight stretches of wall between bastions. A hornwork is an outwork whose front has two half-bastions, and a redoubt is a small enclosed work that can be defended on every side.
Sources: Réseau Vauban illustrated glossary: Hornwork (opens in a new tab); American Battlefield Trust: Glossary of Fortification Terms (opens in a new tab)
conic sectionsIdea
These are the curves made by slicing a cone with a plane: the circle, ellipse, parabola and hyperbola. Galileo showed in his Two New Sciences (1638) that a projectile, leaving air resistance aside, travels along a parabola. That is why gunnery could be treated as a branch of higher geometry.
Source: University of Virginia, Galileo and Einstein: Galileo on Projectiles (opens in a new tab)
tree of knowledge of the EncyclopédieBook or text
Latin for ‘tree of knowledge’. Jefferson means the chart printed in 1751 in the first volume of the Encyclopédie, edited by Denis Diderot and Jean le Rond d’Alembert. Following Francis Bacon, it sorts all learning under memory, reason and imagination and draws each science as a branch.
Sources: MIT Libraries exhibit: Systême figuré des connaissances humaines (opens in a new tab); ARTFL Encyclopédie Project, University of Chicago (opens in a new tab)
solid of least resistanceIdea
Isaac Newton posed this problem in Book II of his Principia (1687) and gave a solution there. It asks what shape of body, symmetrical around its axis, meets the least resistance when it moves through a fluid along that axis. Solving it calls for the methods of the calculus.
Sources: Newton, Principia, Book II, Section VII, translated by Ian Bruce (opens in a new tab); Plakhov, "Newton's aerodynamic problem in media of chaotically moving particles" (arXiv) (opens in a new tab)
English dictionariesBook or text
These are four standard English dictionaries of the 1700s: Nathan Bailey’s Universal Etymological English Dictionary (1721), Samuel Johnson’s Dictionary of the English Language (1755), Thomas Sheridan’s General Dictionary of the English Language (1780), and John Walker’s Critical Pronouncing Dictionary (1791).
Sources: Grolier Club exhibition: Lexicography in the Early 18th Century (opens in a new tab); Grub Street Project: Sheridan, A General Dictionary of the English Language (1780) (opens in a new tab)
neologyWord
Neology is the coining of new words, or the use of old words in new senses. Its relative ‘neologism’ had come into English from French only around 1772.
Sources: Merriam-Webster: neology (opens in a new tab); Merriam-Webster: neologism (opens in a new tab)
UlfilasPerson
Ulfilas, or Wulfila (c. 311–383), was a bishop and missionary to the Goths. He is credited with inventing a Gothic alphabet and with the oldest Bible translation in any Germanic language. Jefferson pairs him with Alfred the Great, the ninth-century English king, as examples of the earliest written forms of the Germanic languages.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Ulfilas (opens in a new tab)
Greek word familyLanguage
These Greek words all grow from the root adelphos, ‘brother’. In order they mean brother, sister, little brother, brotherhood, kinship between brothers, nephew, brotherly, to call someone brother, and in a brotherly way.
Source: Perseus Scaife ATLAS: Liddell–Scott–Jones Greek Lexicon entry (opens in a new tab)
Ionian GreekIdea
Ionic was the Greek dialect of the cities that settlers from Athens founded on the coast of Asia Minor from about 1000 BC. The oldest Greek prose, including Herodotus’s history and the early philosophers, was written in it until Attic took its place in the 400s BC.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Ionic dialect (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 12 May 1820Cross-reference
In his letter of 12 May 1820 from Montezillo, Adams called the dispute between spirit and matter pointless, since we know the essence of neither. He drew on Berkeley and on the infinite divisibility of matter, and ended by resting on Jefferson’s ‘pillow of ignorance’.
Adams to Jefferson, May 12, 1820
Source: Founders Online: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 12 May 1820 (opens in a new tab)
anodyneWord
In its older medical sense, an anodyne is a remedy that eases pain or soothes. Here it means a reliable calming thought. It does not mean ‘bland’, the word’s usual sense today.
I feel, therefore I existQuotation
Jefferson reworks René Descartes’s ‘I think, therefore I am’ (‘Je pense, donc je suis’) from the Discourse on Method (1637). By putting feeling in place of thinking, he makes the senses, rather than pure thought, the starting point of certainty.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: cogito, ergo sum (opens in a new tab)
Locke, Tracy and StewartPerson
Three philosophers of the mind. John Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690) allowed that God might give matter the power to think. Antoine Destutt de Tracy (1754–1836) was a French ‘Idéologue’ whose Treatise on Political Economy Jefferson revised in translation. Dugald Stewart (1753–1828) was a Scottish philosopher of the common-sense school.
Sources: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Supplement to John Locke (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Dugald Stewart (opens in a new tab)
God is a spiritQuotation
Jesus says this to the Samaritan woman at the well in John 4:24. The King James Version reads: ‘God is a Spirit: and they that worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.’
Source: John 4:24 (King James Version), Bible Hub (opens in a new tab)
Origen on God’s bodyQuotation
Origen (c. 185–c. 254) was a theologian and teacher of Alexandria. The Latin means roughly: ‘God is in fact bodily, and is called bodiless only in comparison with grosser bodies.’ The wording probably comes from Pierre-Daniel Huet’s commentary on Origen, which Jefferson quoted to Thomas Cooper the day before writing this letter.
Sources: Founders Online: Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 14 August 1820 (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Origen (summary) (opens in a new tab)
Tertullian on God’s bodyQuotation
Tertullian (c. 160–after 220) was a Latin Christian writer of Carthage. The quotations mean ‘For what is God but a body?’ and ‘Who will deny that God is a body? Though God is a spirit, spirit is a body of its own kind, in its own form.’ The second comes from chapter 7 of his Against Praxeas.
Sources: Tertullian, Against Praxeas, Latin text and English translation (Evans), tertullian.org (opens in a new tab); Bibliothek der Kirchenväter: Adversus Praxean (opens in a new tab)
Justin Martyr on the divineQuotation
Justin Martyr (c. 100–c. 165) was a Christian apologizt, executed at Rome, who blended Greek philosophy with Christian teaching. The Greek says, in substance, that we call the divine ‘bodiless’ not because it truly lacks a body, but because being contained by nothing is nobler than being contained. Jefferson took it secondhand, from the d’Argens volumes he cites below.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: St. Justin Martyr (opens in a new tab)
Macarius on angelsQuotation
Macarius the Egyptian (c. 300–390) was a Desert Father who helped establish monasticism in Egypt. The Latin says that angels, however subtle, are still bodies in substance, form and shape, as fine as their nature is fine.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Macarius the Egyptian (opens in a new tab)
other Church FathersPerson
Five early Christian writers: Augustine of Hippo (354–430), who appears here as ‘St Austin’, an older English form of his name; Basil of Caesarea (c. 330–379); the Latin apologizt Lactantius (c. 250–c. 325); and Tatian and Athenagoras, Greek defenders of Christianity in the second century.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: patristic literature (opens in a new tab)
d’Argens’s Ocellus and TimaeusBook or text
These are French editions by Jean-Baptiste de Boyer, Marquis d’Argens: Ocellus Lucanus (1762) and Timée de Locres (1763). Each prints a Greek text ascribed to an early Pythagorean, with a French translation and long commentary. Jefferson’s numbers are page references, and ‘your’ suggests that Adams owned copies.
Sources: Founders Online: de Bure Frères invoice listing d'Argens's Ocellus Lucanus and Timée de Locres (opens in a new tab); Sowerby, Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson, vol. II, p. 26 (Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
writ for burning hereticsLaw and politics
Latin for ‘on the burning of a heretic’. This was the English writ under which condemned heretics were burned. An act of Parliament of 1677, cited by regnal year as 29 Charles II, chapter 9, abolished the writ and with it the death penalty for heresy.
Sources: legislation.gov.uk: Act for taking away the Writ De Heretico comburendo, 29 Cha. 2 c. 9 (opens in a new tab); The Statutes Project: 1677, 29 Charles 2 c.9, Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction Act (opens in a new tab)
PyrrhonismIdea
Pyrrhonism is thoroughgoing doubt, named after Pyrrho of Elis (c. 360–c. 272 BC), founder of ancient Greek skepticism. He taught that we should suspend judgment about what can truly be known and live by appearances.
Source: Encyclopaedia Britannica: Pyrrhonism (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 15 August 1820 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-16-02-0152
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of January 9, 2026. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 15 August 1820. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-16-02-0152. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1820-08-15-jefferson-to-adams/.