Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson recalls how the American navy began
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson answers Adams’s questions about where the navy came from. He recalls his push for warships against the Barbary pirates and his plan for roofed dry docks, and he weighs what navies cost against what they are worth.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 727 words · 4 min read
The letter
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I have racked my memory and ransacked my papers so that I could answer the questions in your letter of October 15,22 but to little purpose. My papers give me nothing, and my memory only generalities. This much I know. While I was in Europe, I was anxious about the fate of our seamen. We were negotiating for some of them, who were then held captive in Algiers,33 and all of them were in the same danger. So I formed, without any doubt, the opinion that our government should provide a naval force large enough to keep the Barbary states in order as soon as it could, and we exchanged views on this subject, as you note.44 When I returned to the United States and took part in the administration under General Washington, I held to that opinion constantly. In December 1790,55 the first Congress that met after I took office referred a question to me, and I used the occasion to report in favor of a force large enough to protect our Mediterranean trade. I laid before them an accurate statement of the whole Barbary force, both public and private. I think General Washington approved of building warships to that extent. General Knox66 I know did. But what Colonel Hamilton’s opinion was I do not remember in the least. Your recollections on that point are certainly supported by his well-known anxiety for a close connection with Great Britain, since he might have feared that collisions between their ships and ours would endanger it. Randolph was then attorney general,77 but I have also entirely forgotten his opinion on the question. Some warships were accordingly built88 and sent into the Mediterranean. I need not list for you the additions to them in your time,99 since you are well known always to have been an advocate for the wooden walls of Themistocles.1010 Some of the ships you added were sold under an act of Congress1111 passed while you were in office. I thought later that public safety might require some additional strong ships to be prepared and ready for the first moment of a war, provided they could be protected against the decay that is unavoidable if they are kept in the water, and kept free of the expense of officers and men. With this in view I proposed that they be built in dry docks1212 above the level of the tidewater and covered with roofs. I further advised that the sites for these docks be chosen where water could be drawn from a higher level, like that of the Tiber at Washington, so that the ships could be floated out on the principle of a lock. But the majority in the legislature was against any addition to the navy, and the minority, although in favor of it in their judgment, voted against it on the principle of opposition. We are now, I understand, building ships to remain on the stocks1313 under shelter until they are wanted, and then they will be launched and finished. On my plan they could be in service at an hour’s notice. On this one, finishing them after launching will take time. This is all I remember about the origin and progress of our navy. The navy of the late war1414 certainly raised our rank and reputation among nations. Yet a navy is a very expensive machine. It is admitted that in ten or twelve years a ship decays entirely, or, if it is kept in repair, costs as much as building a new one would. It is also admitted that a nation able to count on twelve or fifteen years of peace would gain by burning its navy and building a new one in time. Its size, therefore, must be governed by circumstances. Since I proposed a force adequate to the piracies of the Mediterranean, a similar need has arisen in our own seas1515 for a considerable addition to that force. Indeed, I wish we could make an agreement with the naval powers of Europe: they would keep down the pirates of the Mediterranean and the slave ships on the coast of Africa,1616 and we would perform the same duties for the society of nations in our seas. In this way we would avoid those collisions between the warships of different nations that breed wars and are the weightiest objection to navies. I salute you with constant affection and respect.
I have racked my memory, and ransacked my papers to enable myself to answer the enquiries of your favor of Oct. 15.2 but to little purpose. my papers furnish me nothing, my memory generalities only. I know that while I was in Europe, & anxious about the fate of our seafaring men, for some of whom, then in captivity in Algiers3 we were treating, and all were in like danger, I formed undoubtingly the opinion that our government, as soon as practicable, should provide a naval force sufficient to keep the Barbary states in order, and on this subject we communicated together as you observe4. when I returned to the US. and took part in the administration under Genl Washington I constantly maintained that opinion, and in Dec. 90.5 took advantage of a reference to me from the first Congress which met after I was in office to report in favor of a force sufficient for the protection of our Mediterranean commerce, and I laid before them an accurate statement of the whole Barbary force, public and private. I think Genl Washington approved of building vessels of war to that extent. Genl Knox6 I know did. but what was Colo Hamilton’s opinion I do not in the least remember. your recollections on that subject are certainly corroborated by his known anxieties for a close connection with Great Britain, for which he might apprehend danger from collisions between their vessels and ours. Randolph was then Attorney General7; but his opinion on the question I also entirely forget. some vessels of war were accordingly built8 and sent into the Mediterranean. the additions to these in your time9 I need not note to you, who are well known to have ever been an advocate for the wooden walls of Themistocles10. some of those you added were sold under an act of Congress11 passed while you were in office. I thought afterwards that the public safety might require some additional vessels of strength to be prepared and in readiness for the first moment of a war, provided they could be preserved against the decay which is unavoidable if kept in the water, and clear of the expence of officers & men. with this view I proposed that they should be built in dry docks12 above the level of the tide waters, and covered with roofs. I further advised that places for these docks should be selected where there was a command of water on a higher level, as that of the Tyber at Washington, by which the vessels might be floated out, on the principle of a lock. but the majority of the legislature was against any addition to the navy, & the minority, altho’ for it in judgment, voted against it on a principle of opposition. we are now, I understand building vessels to remain on the stocks13 under shelter until wanted, when they will be launched & finished. on my plan they could be in service at an hour’s notice. on this the finishing, after launching will be a work of time. this is all I recollect about the origin & progress of our navy. that of the late war14 certainly raised our rank & character among nations. yet a navy is a very expensive engine. it is admitted that in 10. or 12. years a vessel goes to entire decay; or, if kept in repair costs as much as would build a new one. & that a nation who could count on 12. or 15. years of peace would gain by burning it’s navy and building a new one in time. it’s extent therefore must be governed by circumstances. since my proposition for a force adequate to the pyracies of the Mediterranean, a similar necessity has arisen in our own seas15 for considerable addition to that force. indeed I wish we could have a convention with the naval powers of Europe for them to keep down the pyrates of the Mediterranean, and the slave ships on the coast of Africa16, and for us to perform the same duties for the society of nations in our seas. in this way those collisions would be avoided between the vessels of war of different nations, which beget wars and constitute the weightiest objection to navies. I salute you with constant affection & respect.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Notes1616
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop plantation house about two miles southeast of Charlottesville, Virginia. He built and rebuilt it between 1768 and 1809, and in 1822 he was living there in retirement.
Source: Monticello (building, Virginia), Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 15 October 1822Cross-reference
Adams had asked whether the warships ordered under Washington were Jefferson’s idea. He recalled that Jefferson had urged a navy in Paris, and claimed that Washington and Hamilton disliked one. He ended by asking Jefferson to correct any mistakes.
Adams to Jefferson, October 15, 1822
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 October 1822 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
American captives in AlgiersEvent
In July 1785 Algerian corsairs seized the Boston schooner Maria and the ship Dauphin and enslaved their 21 crewmen. Jefferson and Adams, then American commissioners in Europe, sent an agent to bargain for them without success. The survivors were not freed until after the 1795 treaty with Algiers.
Sources: Pirates: An Early Test for the New Country, Prologue (National Archives) (opens in a new tab); Supplementary Instructions to John Lamb, 11 October 1785, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s 1786 case for forceCross-reference
Writing from Paris on 11 July 1786, Jefferson told Adams that he would rather win peace with Algiers by war than buy it. He floated a joint naval effort with Portugal and Naples. In his reply of 31 July 1786, Adams doubted that a blockade would work.
Jefferson to Adams, July 11, 1786
Sources: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 11 July 1786, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 31 July 1786, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
report on Mediterranean tradeBook or text
Washington raised the Barbary problem in his annual message of 8 December 1790, and the House of Representatives then referred it to Jefferson. His report on American trade in the Mediterranean, dated 28 December 1790, went to the Speaker the next day along with a companion report on the Algerian captives.
Sources: Report on American Trade in the Mediterranean, 28 December 1790, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); Secretary of State to the Speaker of the House of Representatives, 29 December 1790, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
Henry KnoxPerson
Henry Knox (1750–1806), a Revolutionary War general, served as secretary of war from 1785 to the end of 1794. His department oversaw the building of the first federal warships. Adams had reported that Knox’s widow claimed Washington called the navy her husband’s “child”.
Sources: Henry Knox, Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia (opens in a new tab); Henry Knox (1789–1794), Miller Center (opens in a new tab)
Edmund RandolphPerson
Edmund Randolph (1753–1813) of Virginia became the first attorney general of the United States in September 1789. In January 1794 he succeeded Jefferson as secretary of state. Jefferson is correcting Adams, who had guessed that William Bradford, Randolph’s successor, held the post at the time.
Sources: Edmund Jennings Randolph, U.S. Department of Justice (opens in a new tab); Edmund Jennings Randolph, Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State (opens in a new tab)
Naval Act of 1794Law and politics
After Algiers seized eleven more American merchant ships in 1793, Washington signed a law on 27 March 1794 for six frigates. It said work would stop if peace came. After the 1795 treaty with Algiers only three were pushed to completion, and they were launched in 1797. Jefferson had left office by then.
Sources: President Washington Signs the Naval Act of 1794, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab); The Original Frigates, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s naval buildupEvent
During the undeclared Quasi-War with France, Congress created a separate Department of the Navy on 30 April 1798, and Benjamin Stoddert became the first secretary of the navy. Under Adams the fleet grew well beyond the frigates begun in 1794.
wooden walls of ThemistoclesQuotation
Herodotus tells how Athens, facing the Persian invasion of 480 BC, received an oracle from Delphi that a “wooden wall” would save it. The statesman Themistocles argued that the wall meant the fleet, and the Athenians fought at sea. The phrase came to mean a navy as a nation’s defense.
Source: Herodotus, Histories 7.141–143 (Godley translation), Perseus/Perseids (opens in a new tab)
Naval Peace Establishment ActLaw and politics
The act “providing for a naval peace establishment” was approved on 3 March 1801, Adams’s last full day as president. It kept thirteen frigates, six of them in active service, and let the president sell the navy’s other vessels.
Sources: Samuel Smith to Thomas Jefferson, 4 May 1801, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); An Act providing for a naval peace establishment (1801), The Captain's Clerk (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s dry-dock planEvent
In 1802 President Jefferson had the architect Benjamin Latrobe draw plans for a roofed dock at the Washington Navy Yard that could hold twelve 44-gun frigates out of the water. Latrobe estimated the cost at about $417,000. Jefferson raised the plan in his annual message of 15 December 1802, but Congress never paid for it.
Sources: Robert Smith to Thomas Jefferson, 8 December 1802, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson, Second Annual Message, 15 December 1802, Avalon Project (opens in a new tab)
gradual increase of the navyLaw and politics
An act of 29 April 1816 provided a million dollars a year for new warships. It let the president have hulls framed and then left unlaunched in the shipyard, kept in good repair, so they could be finished quickly when needed. Ships built this way were sheltered under roofed ship-houses.
Sources: An Act for the gradual increase of the Navy of the United States, 29 April 1816 (3 Stat.), Historic Fort Norfolk transcription (opens in a new tab); Annual Report of the Secretary of the Navy, 1835, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
the navy in the War of 1812Event
In the War of 1812 with Britain, American frigates won a string of single-ship battles in 1812. The Constitution beat HMS Guerriere and later HMS Java, and the United States took HMS Macedonian. These wins shook belief in British naval supremacy and lifted American spirits.
Sources: Summer 1812: The USS Constitution Shatters the Aura of British Naval Superiority, National Park Service (opens in a new tab); USS Constitution history, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
West Indies piracyEvent
In the early 1820s pirates based largely in Spanish Cuba attacked merchant ships in the Caribbean, and the navy sent cruisers into the West Indies to hunt them. A month after this letter, in December 1822, President Monroe told Congress that the piracy there had become “organized into a system”.
anti-slave-trade patrolsLaw and politics
Importing enslaved people into the United States had been illegal since 1808. A law of 3 March 1819 let the president send armed vessels to the African coast to seize American slave ships, and Monroe reported in December 1822 that a cruise was being kept up there.
Sources: An act in addition to the acts prohibiting the slave trade, 3 March 1819 (3 Stat. 532), GovInfo (opens in a new tab); James Monroe, Sixth Annual Message, 3 December 1822, American Presidency Project (opens in a new tab)
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop plantation house about two miles southeast of Charlottesville, Virginia. He built and rebuilt it between 1768 and 1809, and in 1822 he was living there in retirement.
Source: Monticello (building, Virginia), Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of 15 October 1822Cross-reference
Adams had asked whether the warships ordered under Washington were Jefferson’s idea. He recalled that Jefferson had urged a navy in Paris, and claimed that Washington and Hamilton disliked one. He ended by asking Jefferson to correct any mistakes.
Adams to Jefferson, October 15, 1822
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 October 1822 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
American captives in AlgiersEvent
In July 1785 Algerian corsairs seized the Boston schooner Maria and the ship Dauphin and enslaved their 21 crewmen. Jefferson and Adams, then American commissioners in Europe, sent an agent to bargain for them without success. The survivors were not freed until after the 1795 treaty with Algiers.
Sources: Pirates: An Early Test for the New Country, Prologue (National Archives) (opens in a new tab); Supplementary Instructions to John Lamb, 11 October 1785, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s 1786 case for forceCross-reference
Writing from Paris on 11 July 1786, Jefferson told Adams that he would rather win peace with Algiers by war than buy it. He floated a joint naval effort with Portugal and Naples. In his reply of 31 July 1786, Adams doubted that a blockade would work.
Jefferson to Adams, July 11, 1786
Sources: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 11 July 1786, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 31 July 1786, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
report on Mediterranean tradeBook or text
Washington raised the Barbary problem in his annual message of 8 December 1790, and the House of Representatives then referred it to Jefferson. His report on American trade in the Mediterranean, dated 28 December 1790, went to the Speaker the next day along with a companion report on the Algerian captives.
Sources: Report on American Trade in the Mediterranean, 28 December 1790, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); Secretary of State to the Speaker of the House of Representatives, 29 December 1790, Founders Online (opens in a new tab)
Henry KnoxPerson
Henry Knox (1750–1806), a Revolutionary War general, served as secretary of war from 1785 to the end of 1794. His department oversaw the building of the first federal warships. Adams had reported that Knox’s widow claimed Washington called the navy her husband’s “child”.
Sources: Henry Knox, Mount Vernon Digital Encyclopedia (opens in a new tab); Henry Knox (1789–1794), Miller Center (opens in a new tab)
Edmund RandolphPerson
Edmund Randolph (1753–1813) of Virginia became the first attorney general of the United States in September 1789. In January 1794 he succeeded Jefferson as secretary of state. Jefferson is correcting Adams, who had guessed that William Bradford, Randolph’s successor, held the post at the time.
Sources: Edmund Jennings Randolph, U.S. Department of Justice (opens in a new tab); Edmund Jennings Randolph, Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State (opens in a new tab)
Naval Act of 1794Law and politics
After Algiers seized eleven more American merchant ships in 1793, Washington signed a law on 27 March 1794 for six frigates. It said work would stop if peace came. After the 1795 treaty with Algiers only three were pushed to completion, and they were launched in 1797. Jefferson had left office by then.
Sources: President Washington Signs the Naval Act of 1794, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab); The Original Frigates, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s naval buildupEvent
During the undeclared Quasi-War with France, Congress created a separate Department of the Navy on 30 April 1798, and Benjamin Stoddert became the first secretary of the navy. Under Adams the fleet grew well beyond the frigates begun in 1794.
wooden walls of ThemistoclesQuotation
Herodotus tells how Athens, facing the Persian invasion of 480 BC, received an oracle from Delphi that a “wooden wall” would save it. The statesman Themistocles argued that the wall meant the fleet, and the Athenians fought at sea. The phrase came to mean a navy as a nation’s defense.
Source: Herodotus, Histories 7.141–143 (Godley translation), Perseus/Perseids (opens in a new tab)
Naval Peace Establishment ActLaw and politics
The act “providing for a naval peace establishment” was approved on 3 March 1801, Adams’s last full day as president. It kept thirteen frigates, six of them in active service, and let the president sell the navy’s other vessels.
Sources: Samuel Smith to Thomas Jefferson, 4 May 1801, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); An Act providing for a naval peace establishment (1801), The Captain's Clerk (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s dry-dock planEvent
In 1802 President Jefferson had the architect Benjamin Latrobe draw plans for a roofed dock at the Washington Navy Yard that could hold twelve 44-gun frigates out of the water. Latrobe estimated the cost at about $417,000. Jefferson raised the plan in his annual message of 15 December 1802, but Congress never paid for it.
Sources: Robert Smith to Thomas Jefferson, 8 December 1802, Founders Online (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson, Second Annual Message, 15 December 1802, Avalon Project (opens in a new tab)
gradual increase of the navyLaw and politics
An act of 29 April 1816 provided a million dollars a year for new warships. It let the president have hulls framed and then left unlaunched in the shipyard, kept in good repair, so they could be finished quickly when needed. Ships built this way were sheltered under roofed ship-houses.
Sources: An Act for the gradual increase of the Navy of the United States, 29 April 1816 (3 Stat.), Historic Fort Norfolk transcription (opens in a new tab); Annual Report of the Secretary of the Navy, 1835, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
the navy in the War of 1812Event
In the War of 1812 with Britain, American frigates won a string of single-ship battles in 1812. The Constitution beat HMS Guerriere and later HMS Java, and the United States took HMS Macedonian. These wins shook belief in British naval supremacy and lifted American spirits.
Sources: Summer 1812: The USS Constitution Shatters the Aura of British Naval Superiority, National Park Service (opens in a new tab); USS Constitution history, Naval History and Heritage Command (opens in a new tab)
West Indies piracyEvent
In the early 1820s pirates based largely in Spanish Cuba attacked merchant ships in the Caribbean, and the navy sent cruisers into the West Indies to hunt them. A month after this letter, in December 1822, President Monroe told Congress that the piracy there had become “organized into a system”.
anti-slave-trade patrolsLaw and politics
Importing enslaved people into the United States had been illegal since 1808. A law of 3 March 1819 let the president send armed vessels to the African coast to seize American slave ships, and Monroe reported in December 1822 that a cruise was being kept up there.
Sources: An act in addition to the acts prohibiting the slave trade, 3 March 1819 (3 Stat. 532), GovInfo (opens in a new tab); James Monroe, Sixth Annual Message, 3 December 1822, American Presidency Project (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 1 November 1822 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-19-02-0089
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of June 22, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 1 November 1822. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-19-02-0089. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1822-11-01-jefferson-to-adams/.