Adams to Jefferson
Adams answers Jefferson on war with Algiers
John Adams to Thomas Jefferson
Adams answers Jefferson’s case for war with Algiers. He would fight only if America would fight forever, and he doubts that force alone could beat the Barbary states. He predicts that Congress and the states will pay for neither war nor peace, and he passes on news about trade and debts.
- From
- London
- Period
- Ministers in Europe, 1784–1789
- Length
- 714 words · 4 min read
The letter
London, July 31, 1786
London July 31. 1786
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I have received your letter of the 11th of this month.33 It urges great and weighty reasons for arming against the Algerines,45 and I confess that if our states could be brought to agree on the measure, I would be very willing to resolve on eternal war with them. But in that case we ought to wage the war with vigor and protect our trade and our people. A resolution to fight them would raise the spirits and courage of our countrymen at once, and we might win the glory of finally breaking up these nests of bandits. But Congress56 will never take any such resolution, or at least not for years, and in the meantime our trade and our honor suffer beyond calculation. We ought not to fight them at all unless we resolve to fight them forever.
Your favour of the 11th.3 instant4 I have received. There are great and weighty Considerations urged in it in favour of arming against the Algerines5, and I confess, if our States could be brought to agree in the Measure, I Should be very willing to resolve upon eternal War with them. But in Such a Case We ought to conduct the War with Vigour, and protect our Trade and People. The Resolution to fight them would raise the Spirits and Courage of our Countrymen immediately, and we might obtain the Glory of finally breaking up these nests of Banditti. But Congress6 will never, or at least not for years, take any such Resolution, and in the mean time our Trade and Honour suffers beyond Calculation. We ought not to fight them at all, unless we determine to fight them forever.
This thought, I fear, is too rugged for our people to bear. To fight them at a cost of millions, and then make peace after all by giving more money and larger presents67 than would now buy a perpetual peace, does not seem economical. Did Monsieur de Massac78 carry his point without making the presents? Did Louis XIV89 get his way without making the presents? Has France not made presents ever since? Did any nation ever make peace with any single Barbary state without making the presents? Is there one example of it? I believe not, and I suspect you will find that even Massac himself made the presents.
This thought is I fear, too rugged for our People to bear. To fight them at the Expence of Millions, and make Peace after all by giving more Money and larger Presents7 than would now procure perpetual Peace Seems not be be œconomical.—Did Monsieur De Massac8 carry his Point without making the Presents? Did Louis 14.9 obtain his Point without making the Presents? Has not France made Presents ever Since? Did any Nation ever make Peace with any one Barbary State, without making the Presents? Is there one Example of it? I believe not, and fancy you will find that even Massac himself made the Presents.
I agree with you on the wisdom and necessity of a navy910 for other purposes, but I fear it will only make bad worse with the Algerines. I will go all lengths with you in promoting a navy, whether it is to be used against the Algerines or not. But I think that at the same time we should negotiate. Your letter, however, has eased my mind on this point. Nevertheless, I think you have somewhat underestimated the force needed to humble the Algerines. They now have fifty gunboats, and these, being small targets in smooth water, are very formidable against great ships in rough water. None of them existed in Monsieur Massac’s time. The harbor of Algiers, too, is now fortified all around, as it was not in Mr. Massac’s time, and this makes a blockade more difficult and dangerous to attempt.
I agree in opinion of the Wisdom and Necessity of a Navy10 for other Uses, but am apprehensive it will only make bad worse with the Algerines. I will go all Lengths with you in promoting a Navy, whether to be applied to the Algerines or not. But I think at the Same time We should treat. Your Letter however has made me easier upon this Point.—Nevertheless I think you have rather undercalculated the Force necessary to humble the Algerines. They have now fifty Gun Boats, which being Small objects in Smooth Water, against great Ships in rough Water are very formidable. None of these existed in the time of Monsieur Massac. The Harbour of Algiers too is fortified all round, which it was not in Mr. Massac’s time, which renders it more difficult and dangerous to attempt a Blockade.
I do not know how far we can depend on Portugal and Naples1011 in case of a war with the Barbarians. Perhaps they might help us to some degree.
I know not what dependence is to be had upon Portugal and Naples11, in Case of a War with the Barbarians. Perhaps they might assist us in some degree.
Blockading Algiers would not win us peace with Morocco, Tunis or Tripoli,1112 so our commerce would still be exposed.
Blocking Algiers would not obtain Peace with Morocco Tunis or Tripoli12, so that our Commerce would still be exposed.
After all, though I am glad we have exchanged letters on the subject, I see that neither force nor money will be used. Our states are so backward that they will do nothing for some years. If they raise enough money to meet the demands upon them in Europe1213 that they have already incurred, I shall be agreeably disappointed. Among our citizens a disposition seems rather to prevail to give up all ideas of shipping and naval power, and so to lay themselves at the mercy of foreigners, even for the price of their produce. It is their concern, and we must submit, for your plan of fighting will no more be adopted than my plan of negotiating. This is more humiliating to me than giving the presents would be. I have a letter from Mr. Jay1314 of July 7, which came by packet,1415 containing nothing but an acknowledgment that he had received our letter of April 25.1516
After all, tho I am glad We have exchanged a Letter upon the subject, I percieve that neither Force nor Money will be applied. Our States are so backward that they will do nothing for some years. If they get Money enough to discharge the Demands upon them in Europe13, already incurred, I shall be agreably disappointed. A Disposition Seems rather to prevail among our Citizens to give up all Ideas of Navigation and naval Power, and lay themselves consequently at the Mercy of Foreigners, even for the Price of their Produce. It is their Concern, and We must submit, for your Plan of fighting will no more be adopted than mine of negotiating. This is more humiliating to me, than giving the Presents would be. I have a Letter from Mr. Jay14 of 7. July, by Packet15, containing nothing but an Acknowledgment of the Receipt our Letter of 25. of April16.
John Adams
John Adams
Notes2122
the Prussian TreatyLaw and politics
The 1785 Treaty of Amity and Commerce between the United States and Prussia. Franklin, Jefferson and Adams each signed it in a different city, and the Prussian envoy signed at The Hague on 10 September 1785. Congress ratified it on 17 May 1786, and the two governments exchanged ratifications at The Hague on 8 August 1786.
Baron de ThulemeierPerson
Friedrich Wilhelm von Thulemeier, a Prussian privy counsellor of embassy and envoy extraordinary, who negotiated the treaty for King Frederick II and signed it at The Hague. Adams had to go to the Dutch capital to exchange ratifications with him.
your letter of 11 JulyCross-reference
Jefferson’s letter from Paris of 11 July 1786. In it he argued that the United States should win peace with Algiers by war rather than buy it, and he estimated the cost of a fleet of 150 guns. This letter is Adams’s answer.
AlgerinesPlace
The people and government of Algiers, the most powerful of the North African Barbary states. In July 1785 its corsairs captured two American merchant ships, the Maria and the Dauphin, and the Dey then demanded a large ransom for their crews.
Sources: Pirates: An Early Test for the New Country (National Archives, Prologue blog) (opens in a new tab); First Barbary War (Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
CongressLaw and politics
The Congress of the Confederation, the only national government under the Articles of Confederation. It could ask the states for money but could not levy taxes itself, so it could pay for neither a war fleet nor a purchased peace unless the states contributed.
Sources: Diplomacy under the Articles of Confederation (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab); Articles of Confederation (Encyclopaedia Britannica) (opens in a new tab)
the PresentsCustom
Gifts of money and goods that Barbary rulers required from foreign governments as the price of making or renewing a treaty; in effect, tribute. In March 1786, for example, Tripoli’s envoy in London had asked 30,000 guineas for his government, plus £3,000 for himself, for a perpetual peace.
Sources: The American Commissioners to John Jay, 28 March 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab); Barbary Wars, 1801–1805 and 1815–1816 (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab)
Monsieur de MassacPerson
Probably the marquis de Massiac, a French naval commander who later served briefly as navy minister. Jefferson’s letter of 11 July claimed that about forty years earlier Massac, with one large and two small frigates, had blockaded Algiers for three months and forced it to accept France’s terms. The identification is probable rather than certain.
Jefferson to Adams, July 11, 1786
Sources: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, Paris, July 11, 1786 (University of Groningen, American History documents) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to John Jay, 23 May 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Louis XIV and AlgiersEvent
Louis XIV of France (reigned 1643–1715) sent Admiral Abraham Duquesne to bombard Algiers in 1682 and again in 1683. Adams asks whether even these heavy attacks won a peace without the customary gifts.
Source: Duquesne, Abraham (Columbia Encyclopedia, via Encyclopedia.com) (opens in a new tab)
a NavyEvent
At this time the United States had no navy. Congress had sold the Alliance, the last warship of the Continental Navy, in 1785, and it did not authorize new frigates until the Naval Act of 1794, which was passed largely in response to Algiers.
Sources: The Original Six Frigates of the United States Navy (Naval History and Heritage Command) (opens in a new tab); Continental Navy (George Washington's Mount Vernon, Digital Encyclopedia) (opens in a new tab)
Portugal and NaplesPlace
Two Mediterranean naval powers that had no peace with Algiers. In his letter of 11 July Jefferson had argued that Naples would join an American war against Algiers, and he assumed that Portugal would also remain at war with it.
Morocco, Tunis and TripoliPlace
The other three Barbary states, each of which needed its own treaty. The American agent Thomas Barclay was then concluding a treaty with Morocco, sealed at Marrakesh in late June 1786. Tunis and Tripoli still had no treaty with the United States.
Sources: Treaty with Morocco, June 28 and July 15, 1786 (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Barclay to the American Commissioners, 16 July 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the demands in EuropeMoney
The interest and repayments due on the loans Congress had raised from France and from Dutch bankers, including the 1782 Dutch loan that Adams himself negotiated. Congress depended on the states for the money and could not keep up its payments, so the foreign debt kept growing until 1790.
Sources: Loans and Debts, 1784–1800 (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab); Debts, Colonial and Continental (Dictionary of American History, via Encyclopedia.com) (opens in a new tab)
Mr. JayPerson
John Jay (1745–1829) of New York, Secretary for Foreign Affairs to the Confederation Congress from 1784 to 1789. Adams and Jefferson sent their official reports to him.
Source: John Jay (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab)
packetWord
A packet was a mail ship that sailed on a fixed schedule. After the war the British Post Office ran a monthly packet service between New York and Falmouth in Cornwall, which is how official letters usually crossed the Atlantic. Adams does not name the ship that carried Jay’s letter.
Source: Anthony Todd to Benjamin Franklin, 19 September 1783 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
our letter of 25 AprilCross-reference
The joint report that Adams and Jefferson sent Jay from London on 25 April 1786, during Jefferson’s visit there. It saw little hope of a commercial treaty with Britain and said a treaty with Portugal was nearly finished. It was addressed to Jay, so it is not part of this correspondence.
the states’ Navigation ActsLaw and politics
State laws of 1785 that penalized British shipping. After a partial repeal in November 1785, the Massachusetts act applied in full only to British vessels, and Rhode Island suspended its act in February 1786. On 11 July 1786 Governor James Bowdoin told Adams that Massachusetts had suspended its act until other states passed similar laws.
Sources: James Bowdoin to John Adams, 12 January 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab); James Bowdoin to John Adams, 11 July 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab)
the ConventionEvent
The Annapolis Convention. In January 1786 Virginia invited the states to meet that September to consider a uniform system of trade regulation. Only five states came (11–14 September 1786), and their report called for a wider convention in Philadelphia in 1787, which drafted the Constitution.
Sources: Annapolis Convention (Encyclopaedia Britannica) (opens in a new tab); Proceedings of Commissioners to Remedy Defects of the Federal Government, September 11–14, 1786 (Encyclopedia Virginia) (opens in a new tab)
Carmarthen’s answerBook or text
The reply of 28 February 1786 from the Marquis of Carmarthen, the British foreign secretary, to Adams’s memorial. It attached a long list of state laws that blocked British creditors, as proof that America had broken the peace treaty first. Jefferson was in London from March to April 1786.
Sources: The Marquis of Carmarthen to John Adams, 28 February 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The American Commissioners to John Jay, 25 April 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab)
my memorial of 30 NovemberBook or text
Adams’s formal note of 30 November 1785 to Carmarthen, which he handed over on 8 December. It demanded that Britain withdraw its garrisons from the frontier posts on American soil, as the 1783 peace treaty required.
Mr. RamsayPerson
David Ramsay (1749–1815), a Charleston physician and historian of the Revolution. As a South Carolina delegate he presided over Congress as president pro tempore from November 1785 to May 1786. In a letter to Adams of 14 May 1786 he predicted that Britain’s keeping the posts would lead the states to repeal their laws against debt collection.
Sources: RAMSAY, David (U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives) (opens in a new tab); David Ramsay to John Adams, 14 May 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
laws against recovering private debtsLaw and politics
State laws that delayed or blocked British merchants’ lawsuits to recover debts Americans had owed them since before the war. Such laws broke Article 4 of the 1783 Treaty of Paris, which promised creditors no lawful impediment, and Britain cited them to justify keeping the frontier posts.
Sources: The Definitive Treaty of Peace, 1783 (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (opens in a new tab); The Marquis of Carmarthen to John Adams, 28 February 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
One more note explains a word of the original that the modern text does not use. Switch to the original to read it.
the Prussian TreatyLaw and politics
The 1785 Treaty of Amity and Commerce between the United States and Prussia. Franklin, Jefferson and Adams each signed it in a different city, and the Prussian envoy signed at The Hague on 10 September 1785. Congress ratified it on 17 May 1786, and the two governments exchanged ratifications at The Hague on 8 August 1786.
Baron de ThulemeierPerson
Friedrich Wilhelm von Thulemeier, a Prussian privy counsellor of embassy and envoy extraordinary, who negotiated the treaty for King Frederick II and signed it at The Hague. Adams had to go to the Dutch capital to exchange ratifications with him.
your letter of 11 JulyCross-reference
Jefferson’s letter from Paris of 11 July 1786. In it he argued that the United States should win peace with Algiers by war rather than buy it, and he estimated the cost of a fleet of 150 guns. This letter is Adams’s answer.
instantWord
In dates, “instant” (often shortened to “inst.”) means “of the present month”. Here the 11th instant is 11 July 1786.
Source: Merriam-Webster Dictionary: instant (opens in a new tab)
AlgerinesPlace
The people and government of Algiers, the most powerful of the North African Barbary states. In July 1785 its corsairs captured two American merchant ships, the Maria and the Dauphin, and the Dey then demanded a large ransom for their crews.
Sources: Pirates: An Early Test for the New Country (National Archives, Prologue blog) (opens in a new tab); First Barbary War (Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
CongressLaw and politics
The Congress of the Confederation, the only national government under the Articles of Confederation. It could ask the states for money but could not levy taxes itself, so it could pay for neither a war fleet nor a purchased peace unless the states contributed.
Sources: Diplomacy under the Articles of Confederation (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab); Articles of Confederation (Encyclopaedia Britannica) (opens in a new tab)
the PresentsCustom
Gifts of money and goods that Barbary rulers required from foreign governments as the price of making or renewing a treaty; in effect, tribute. In March 1786, for example, Tripoli’s envoy in London had asked 30,000 guineas for his government, plus £3,000 for himself, for a perpetual peace.
Sources: The American Commissioners to John Jay, 28 March 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab); Barbary Wars, 1801–1805 and 1815–1816 (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab)
Monsieur de MassacPerson
Probably the marquis de Massiac, a French naval commander who later served briefly as navy minister. Jefferson’s letter of 11 July claimed that about forty years earlier Massac, with one large and two small frigates, had blockaded Algiers for three months and forced it to accept France’s terms. The identification is probable rather than certain.
Jefferson to Adams, July 11, 1786
Sources: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, Paris, July 11, 1786 (University of Groningen, American History documents) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to John Jay, 23 May 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Louis XIV and AlgiersEvent
Louis XIV of France (reigned 1643–1715) sent Admiral Abraham Duquesne to bombard Algiers in 1682 and again in 1683. Adams asks whether even these heavy attacks won a peace without the customary gifts.
Source: Duquesne, Abraham (Columbia Encyclopedia, via Encyclopedia.com) (opens in a new tab)
a NavyEvent
At this time the United States had no navy. Congress had sold the Alliance, the last warship of the Continental Navy, in 1785, and it did not authorize new frigates until the Naval Act of 1794, which was passed largely in response to Algiers.
Sources: The Original Six Frigates of the United States Navy (Naval History and Heritage Command) (opens in a new tab); Continental Navy (George Washington's Mount Vernon, Digital Encyclopedia) (opens in a new tab)
Portugal and NaplesPlace
Two Mediterranean naval powers that had no peace with Algiers. In his letter of 11 July Jefferson had argued that Naples would join an American war against Algiers, and he assumed that Portugal would also remain at war with it.
Morocco, Tunis and TripoliPlace
The other three Barbary states, each of which needed its own treaty. The American agent Thomas Barclay was then concluding a treaty with Morocco, sealed at Marrakesh in late June 1786. Tunis and Tripoli still had no treaty with the United States.
Sources: Treaty with Morocco, June 28 and July 15, 1786 (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (opens in a new tab); Thomas Barclay to the American Commissioners, 16 July 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the demands in EuropeMoney
The interest and repayments due on the loans Congress had raised from France and from Dutch bankers, including the 1782 Dutch loan that Adams himself negotiated. Congress depended on the states for the money and could not keep up its payments, so the foreign debt kept growing until 1790.
Sources: Loans and Debts, 1784–1800 (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab); Debts, Colonial and Continental (Dictionary of American History, via Encyclopedia.com) (opens in a new tab)
Mr. JayPerson
John Jay (1745–1829) of New York, Secretary for Foreign Affairs to the Confederation Congress from 1784 to 1789. Adams and Jefferson sent their official reports to him.
Source: John Jay (Office of the Historian, U.S. Department of State) (opens in a new tab)
packetWord
A packet was a mail ship that sailed on a fixed schedule. After the war the British Post Office ran a monthly packet service between New York and Falmouth in Cornwall, which is how official letters usually crossed the Atlantic. Adams does not name the ship that carried Jay’s letter.
Source: Anthony Todd to Benjamin Franklin, 19 September 1783 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
our letter of 25 AprilCross-reference
The joint report that Adams and Jefferson sent Jay from London on 25 April 1786, during Jefferson’s visit there. It saw little hope of a commercial treaty with Britain and said a treaty with Portugal was nearly finished. It was addressed to Jay, so it is not part of this correspondence.
the states’ Navigation ActsLaw and politics
State laws of 1785 that penalized British shipping. After a partial repeal in November 1785, the Massachusetts act applied in full only to British vessels, and Rhode Island suspended its act in February 1786. On 11 July 1786 Governor James Bowdoin told Adams that Massachusetts had suspended its act until other states passed similar laws.
Sources: James Bowdoin to John Adams, 12 January 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab); James Bowdoin to John Adams, 11 July 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab)
the ConventionEvent
The Annapolis Convention. In January 1786 Virginia invited the states to meet that September to consider a uniform system of trade regulation. Only five states came (11–14 September 1786), and their report called for a wider convention in Philadelphia in 1787, which drafted the Constitution.
Sources: Annapolis Convention (Encyclopaedia Britannica) (opens in a new tab); Proceedings of Commissioners to Remedy Defects of the Federal Government, September 11–14, 1786 (Encyclopedia Virginia) (opens in a new tab)
Carmarthen’s answerBook or text
The reply of 28 February 1786 from the Marquis of Carmarthen, the British foreign secretary, to Adams’s memorial. It attached a long list of state laws that blocked British creditors, as proof that America had broken the peace treaty first. Jefferson was in London from March to April 1786.
Sources: The Marquis of Carmarthen to John Adams, 28 February 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The American Commissioners to John Jay, 25 April 1786 (Papers of John Adams, Massachusetts Historical Society) (opens in a new tab)
my memorial of 30 NovemberBook or text
Adams’s formal note of 30 November 1785 to Carmarthen, which he handed over on 8 December. It demanded that Britain withdraw its garrisons from the frontier posts on American soil, as the 1783 peace treaty required.
Mr. RamsayPerson
David Ramsay (1749–1815), a Charleston physician and historian of the Revolution. As a South Carolina delegate he presided over Congress as president pro tempore from November 1785 to May 1786. In a letter to Adams of 14 May 1786 he predicted that Britain’s keeping the posts would lead the states to repeal their laws against debt collection.
Sources: RAMSAY, David (U.S. House of Representatives, History, Art & Archives) (opens in a new tab); David Ramsay to John Adams, 14 May 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
laws against recovering private debtsLaw and politics
State laws that delayed or blocked British merchants’ lawsuits to recover debts Americans had owed them since before the war. Such laws broke Article 4 of the 1783 Treaty of Paris, which promised creditors no lawful impediment, and Britain cited them to justify keeping the frontier posts.
Sources: The Definitive Treaty of Peace, 1783 (Avalon Project, Yale Law School) (opens in a new tab); The Marquis of Carmarthen to John Adams, 28 February 1786 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: To Thomas Jefferson from John Adams, 31 July 1786 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-10-02-0106
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of November 8, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 31 July 1786. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/01-10-02-0106. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1786-07-31-adams-to-jefferson/.