Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson on Napoleon’s fall and Plato’s fog
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson reflects on aging bodies and Napoleon’s inglorious fall, worries that Britain will demand the New England fisheries, mocks Plato’s Republic and its grafting onto Christianity, and asks Adams for ideas on planning a university.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 1,856 words · 9 min read
The letter
Monticello, July 5, 1814
Monticello July 5. 14.
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
Since my letter of January 24,11 I have received yours of March 14.22 I did not acknowledge it in my short one of May 18,33 carried by Mr. Rives,44 because that letter’s only purpose was to give one of our most promising young men the advantage of making his bow to you. I learned with great regret of the serious illness mentioned in your letter, and I hope Mr. Rives will be able to tell me that you are entirely restored. But our machines have now been running for seventy or eighty years, and we must expect that, worn as they are, here a pivot, there a wheel, now a pinion, next a spring will give way. However we may tinker them up for a while, all will at last cease to move. Our watches, with works of brass and steel, wear out within that span. Shall you and I last long enough to see what course the sevenfold wonders of these times will take? The Attila of the age55 is dethroned: the ruthless destroyer of ten million human beings, whose thirst for blood seemed unquenchable, the great oppressor of the rights and liberties of the world, is shut up within the circuit of a little island of the Mediterranean,66 and has dwindled to a humble and degraded pensioner77 living on the bounty of those he has most injured. How miserably, how meanly, he has closed his inflated career! What a sample of bathos88 his history will present! He should have perished on the swords of his enemies, under the walls of Paris.
Since mine of Jan. 24.1 your’s of Mar. 14.2 was recieved. it was not acknoleged in the short one of May 18.3 by mr Rives4, the only object of that having been to enable one of our most promising young men to have the advantage of making his bow to you. I learned with great regret the serious illness mentioned in your letter: and I hope mr Rives will be able to tell me you are entirely restored. but our machines have now been running for 70. or 80. years, and we must expect that, worn as they are, here a pivot, there a wheel, now a pinion, next a spring, will be giving way: and however we may tinker them up for awhile, all will at length surcease motion. our watches, with works of brass and steel, wear out within that period. shall you and I last to see the course of the seven-fold wonders of the times will take? the Attila of the age5 dethroned, the ruthless destroyer of 10. millions of the human race, whose thirst for blood appeared unquenchable, the great oppressor of the rights & liberties of the world, shut up within the circuit of a little island of the Mediterranean6, and dwindled to the condition of an humble and degraded pensioner7 on the bounty of those he has most injured. how miserably, how meanly, has he closed his inflated career! what a sample of the Bathos8 will his history present! he should have perished on the swords of his enemies, under the walls of Paris
| “*The lion, wounded to death,* | *So in his final fury* | ||
| *Feels his life failing;* | *He roars, threatens and rages,* | ||
| *He eyes his wound,* | *And, dying, sometimes makes* | ||
| *And still does not cower.* | *The hunter tremble.*” — Metastasio, *Adriano*.[[n9]] |
| ‘Leon piagato a morte | Cosi fra l’ire estrema | ||
| Sente mancar la vita, | rugge, minaccia, e freme, | ||
| Guarda la sua ferita, | Che fa tremar morendo | ||
| Ne s’avilisce ancor. | Tal volta il cacciator.’ Metast Adriano. |
But Bonaparte was a lion in the field only. In civil life he was a cold-blooded, calculating, unprincipled usurper, without a virtue; no statesman, knowing nothing of commerce, political economy or civil government, and making up for his ignorance with bold presumption. I had thought him a great man until he entered the Council of Five Hundred1010 on the 18th Brumaire, Year VIII.1111 From that date, however, I set him down as nothing but a great scoundrel. To the wonders of his rise and fall we may add that of a Czar of Muscovy1212 dictating, in Paris, laws and limits to all the successors of the Caesars, and even holding the scales on which the fortunes of this new world hang. I admit that I rejoice, for the good of mankind, in Europe’s deliverance from the havoc that would never have ceased while Bonaparte remained in power. Yet I see with anxiety that the tyrant of the ocean remains in full vigor, and even shares in the credit for crushing his brother tyrant. While the world is thus turned upside down, which side of it are we on? All the strong reasons, indeed, place us on the side of peace: the interests of the Continent, its friendly feelings, and even the interests of England. Her passions alone oppose it. Peace would now seem an easy task, since the causes of the war have been removed. The allied powers will no doubt take care of her Orders in Council,1313 and once the war ends, her impressment1414 of our seamen ends as a matter of course. But I fear there is some basis for the plan hinted at in the newspapers, of demanding that we give up our right in the fisheries.1515 What will Massachusetts say to this?1616 I mean her majority, which must be taken, through the organs it has appointed for itself, as the expression of her will. She chose to sacrifice the liberty of our seafaring citizens, in which we all had a stake, and with it her obligations to her fellow states, rather than go to war with England. Will she now sacrifice the fisheries to the same partiality? This question matters to her alone, because the fisheries are of no direct concern to the middle, southern and western states, of no more concern than the growing of tobacco, rice and cotton is to Massachusetts. I am really at a loss to guess what our unruly sister will say on this occasion. I know what I would say to her as a citizen of the Union: “Take this question ad referendum.1717 It concerns you alone. If you would rather give up the fisheries than go to war with England, we give them up. If you would rather fight for them, we will defend your interests to the last drop of our blood, choosing to set a good example rather than follow a bad one.” And I hope she will decide to fight for them. With this, however, you and I shall have nothing to do, for ours is truly the case in which “the hour needs neither such help nor such defenders.”1818 So, leaving this subject, I will turn over a new leaf.
But Bonaparte was a lion in the field only. in civil life a cold-blooded, calculating, unprincipled Usurper, without a virtue, no statesman, knowing nothing of commerce, political economy, or civil government, & supplying ignorance by bold presumption. I had supposed him a great man until his entrance into the Assembly des cinq cens10, 18. Brumaire (an. 8.)11 from that date however I set him down as a great scoundrel only. to the wonders of his rise and fall, we may add that of a Czar of Muscovy12 dictating, in Paris, laws and limits to all the successors of the Caesars, and holding even the balance in which the fortunes of this new world are suspended. I own that, while I rejoice, for the good of mankind, in the deliverance of Europe from the havoc which would have never ceased while Bonaparte should have lived in power, I see with anxiety the tyrant of the ocean remaining in vigor, and even participating in the merit of crushing his brother tyrant. while the world is thus turned upside down, on which side of it are we? all the strong reasons indeed place us on the side of peace; the interests of the continent, their friendly dispositions, & even the interests of England. her passions alone are opposed to it. peace would seem now to be an easy work, the causes of the war being removed. her orders of council13 will no doubt be taken care of by the allied powers, and, war ceasing, her impressment14 of our seamen ceases of course. but I fear there is foundation for the design intimated in the public papers, of demanding a cession of our right in the fisheries15. what will Massachusets say to this?16 I mean her majority, which must be considered as speaking, thro’ the organs it has appointed itself, as the Index of it’s will. she chose to sacrifice the liberty of our seafaring citizens, in which we were all interested, and with them her obligations to the Co-states; rather than war with England. will she now sacrifice the fisheries to the same partialities? this question is interesting to her alone: for to the middle, the Southern & Western states they are of no direct concern; of no more than the culture of tobacco, rice & cotton to Massachusets. I am really at a loss to conjecture what our refractory sister will say on this occasion. I know what, as a citizen of the Union, I would say to her, ‘take this question ad referendum17. it concerns you alone. if you would rather give up the fisheries than war with England, we give them up. if you had rather fight for them, we will defend your interests to the last drop of our blood, chusing rather to set a good example than follow a bad one.’ and I hope she will determine to fight for them.—with this however you and I shall have nothing to do; ours being truly the case wherein ‘non tali auxilio, nec defensoribus istis18 Tempus eget.’ quitting this subject therefore I will turn over another leaf.
I have just returned from one of my long absences, having spent the past five weeks at my other home.1919 Since I have more leisure for reading there than here, I amused myself by reading Plato’s Republic seriously. I am wrong, however, to call it amusement, for it was the heaviest task-work I ever went through. I had now and then taken up some of his other works before, but I scarcely ever had the patience to get through a whole dialogue. While wading through the whimsies, the childishness and the unintelligible jargon of this work, I often laid it down to ask myself how the world could have agreed for so long to give a reputation to such nonsense as this. How the so-called Christian world should have done it is indeed a piece of historical curiosity. But how could Roman good sense do it? And in particular, how could Cicero bestow such praise on Plato?2020 Although Cicero did not wield the dense logic of Demosthenes, he was able, learned, hardworking, practiced in the business of the world, and honest. He could not be the dupe of mere style, since he was himself the first master of it in the world. With the moderns, I think, it is more a matter of fashion and authority. Education is chiefly in the hands of men whose profession gives them an interest in the reputation and the dreams of Plato. They set the tone while we are at school, and few people, in later years, have occasion to revise their college opinions. But set fashion and authority aside and bring Plato to the test of reason: take away his sophisms, futilities and incomprehensibilities, and what remains? In truth he is one of the race of genuine Sophists,2121 who has escaped the oblivion of his brethren, first by the elegance of his language, but chiefly because his whimsies were adopted and built into the body of artificial Christianity.2222 His foggy mind is forever presenting the semblances of objects that, half seen through a mist, can be defined neither in shape nor in size. Yet this, which should have consigned him to early oblivion, actually won him immortal fame and reverence. The Christian priesthood found the doctrines of Christ brought down to every understanding and too plain to need explanation. So they saw in the mysticisms of Plato materials with which they might build up an artificial system that, because it was indistinct, might allow everlasting controversy, give employment to their order, and bring it profit, power and pre-eminence. The doctrines that flowed from the lips of Jesus himself are within the grasp of a child; but thousands of volumes have not yet explained the Platonisms grafted onto them, for this obvious reason: nonsense can never be explained. Their purposes, however, are served. Plato is canonized, and it is now thought as impious to question his merits as those of an Apostle of Jesus. He is especially appealed to as an advocate of the immortality of the soul;2323 and yet I will venture to say that if there were no better arguments for it than his, not a man in the world would believe it. It is lucky for us that Platonic republicanism has not won the same favor as Platonic Christianity, or we should now all be living, men, women and children, pell-mell together,2424 like the beasts of the field or forest. Yet “Plato is a great philosopher,” said La Fontaine.2525 “But do you find his ideas very clear?” says Fontenelle. “Oh no! He is of an impenetrable obscurity.” “Do you not find him full of contradictions?” “Certainly,” replied La Fontaine, “he is nothing but a Sophist.” Yet immediately afterward he exclaims again, “Oh, Plato was a great philosopher!” Socrates had reason indeed to complain of the misrepresentations of Plato,2626 for in truth his dialogues are libels on Socrates. But why am I dosing you with these antediluvian topics? Because I am glad to have someone to whom they are familiar, and who will not receive them as if they had dropped from the moon. Our post-revolutionary youth are born under happier stars than you and I were. They acquire all learning in their mothers’ wombs and bring it into the world ready-made. The information in books is no longer necessary, and all knowledge that is not innate is held in contempt, or at least neglected. Every folly must run its course; and so, I suppose, must this folly of self-learning and self-sufficiency, of rejecting the knowledge acquired in past ages and starting out on the new ground of intuition. When experience has sobered them, I hope our successors will turn their attention to the advantages of education. I mean education on the broad scale, and not that of the petty academies, as they call themselves, which are springing up in every neighborhood. In them one or two men who have Latin, and sometimes Greek, a knowledge of the globes,2727 and the first six books of Euclid imagine that this is the sum of science and pass it on as such. They send their pupils out onto the stage of the world with just enough taste of learning to be turned away from industrious pursuits, and not enough to do service in the ranks of science. We have some exceptions, indeed. I introduced one to you lately, and we have some others. But the terms I use are general truths. I hope the need will at last be seen to establish institutions, here as in Europe, where every branch of science that is useful today may be taught to its highest level. Have you ever turned your thoughts to the plan of such an institution?2828 I mean to a list of the particular sciences of real use in human affairs, and to how they might be grouped so as to need only as many professors as a just but enlightened economy would allow. I would be happy to have your ideas on this problem, whether rough or worked out. But to keep from being run away with by another subject, and from adding to the length and tedium of this letter, I will here offer Mrs. Adams and yourself the assurance of my constant and sincere friendship and respect.
I am just returned from one of my long absences, having been at my other home19 for five weeks past. having more leisure there than here for reading, I amused myself with reading seriously Plato’s republic. I am wrong however in calling it amusement, for it was the heaviest task-work I ever went through. I had occasionally before taken up some of his other works, but scarcely ever had patience to go through a whole dialogue. while wading thro’ the whimsies, the puerilities, & unintelligible jargon of this work, I laid it down often to ask myself how it could have been that the world should have so long consented to give reputation to such nonsense as this? how the soi-disant Christian world indeed should have done it, is a piece of historical curiosity. but how could the Roman good sense do it? and particularly how could Cicero bestow such eulogies on Plato20? altho’ Cicero did not wield the dense logic of Demosthenes, yet he was able, learned, laborious, practised in the business of the world, & honest. he could not be the dupe of mere style, of which he was himself the first master in the world. with the moderns, I think, it is rather a matter of fashion and authority. education is chiefly in the hands of persons who, from their profession, have an interest in the reputation and the dreams of Plato. they give the tone while at school, and few, in their after-years, have occasion to revise their college opinions. but fashion and authority apart, and bringing Plato to the test of reason, take from him his sophisms, futilities, & incomprehensibilities, and what remains? in truth he is one of the race of genuine Sophists21, who has escaped the oblivion of his brethren, first by the elegance of his diction, but chiefly by the adoption & incorporation of his whimsies into the body of artificial Christianity22. his foggy mind, is for ever presenting the semblances of objects which, half seen thro’ a mist, can be defined neither in form or dimension. yet this which should have consigned him to early oblivion really procured him immortality of fame & reverence. the Christian priesthood, finding the doctrines of Christ levelled to every understanding, and too plain to need explanation, saw, in the mysticisms of Plato, materials with which they might build up an artificial system which might, from it’s indistinctness, admit everlasting controversy, give employment for their order, and introduce it to profit, power & pre-eminence. the doctrines which flowed from the lips of Jesus himself are within the comprehension of a child; but thousands of volumes have not yet explained the Platonisms engrafted on them: and for this obvious reason that nonsense can never be explained. their purposes however are answered. Plato is canonised: and it is now deemed as impious to question his merits as those of an Apostle of Jesus. he is peculiarly appealed to as an advocate of the immortality of the soul23; and yet I will venture to say that were there no better arguments than his in proof of it, not a man in the world would believe it. it is fortunate for us that Platonic republicanism has not obtained the same favor as Platonic Christianity; or we should now have been all living, men, women and children, pell mell together24, like the beasts of the field or forest. yet ‘Plato is a great Philosopher,’ said La Fontaine25. but says Fontenelle ‘do you find his ideas very clear’?—‘oh no! he is of an obscurity impenetrable.’—‘do you not find him full of contradictions?’—‘certainly, replied La Fontaine, he is but a Sophist.’ yet immediately after, he exclaims again, ‘oh Plato was a great philosopher.’—Socrates had reason indeed to complain of the misrepresentations of Plato26; for in truth his dialogues are libels on Socrates.—but why am I dosing you with these Ante-diluvian topics? because I am glad to have some one to whom they are familiar, and who will not recieve them as if dropped from the moon. our post-revolutionary youth are born under happier stars than you and I were. they acquire all learning in their mothers’ womb, and bring it into the world ready-made. the information of books is no longer necessary; and all knolege which is not innate, is in contempt, or neglect at least. every folly must run it’s round; and so, I suppose, must that of self-learning, & self sufficiency; of rejecting the knolege acquired in past ages, and starting on the new ground of intuition. when sobered by experience I hope our successors will turn their attention to the advantages of education. I mean of education on the broad scale, and not that of the petty academies, as they call themselves, which are starting up in every neighborhood, and where one or two men, possessing Latin, & sometimes Greek, a knolege of the globes27, and the first six books of Euclid, imagine & communicate this as the sum of science. they commit their pupils to the theatre of the world with just taste enough of learning to be alienated from industrious pursuits, and not enough to do service in the ranks of science. we have some exceptions indeed. I presented one to you lately, and we have some others. but the terms I use are general truths. I hope the necessity will at length be seen of establishing institutions, here as in Europe, where every branch of science, useful at this day, may be taught in it’s highest degrees. have you ever turned your thoughts to the plan of such an institution28? I mean to a specification of the particular sciences of real use in human affairs, and how they might be so grouped as to require so many professors only as might bring them within the views of a just but enlightened economy? I should be happy in a communication of your ideas on this problem, either loose or digested. but to avoid my being run away with by another subject, and adding to the length and ennui of the present letter, I will here present to mrs Adams & yourself the assurance of my constant & sincere friendship and respect.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Notes2828
Jefferson’s letter of 24 JanuaryCross-reference
Jefferson’s previous full letter, written 24 January 1814, which opened by apologizing for being slow to answer Adams’s letters of late 1813. Adams answered it in the letter Jefferson mentions next.
Jefferson to Adams, January 24, 1814
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 24 January 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of early 1814Cross-reference
Probably Adams’s long letter begun in February 1814 and finished 3 March 1814. Jefferson’s date does not match, but it is Adams’s only letter between January and July, and it mentions his long illness and confinement.
letter of 18 May 1814Cross-reference
A brief letter of 18 May 1814 introducing William Cabell Rives, to be handed to Adams in person. When Adams replied on 16 July, Rives had not yet arrived.
Jefferson to Adams, May 18, 1814
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 18 May 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
William Cabell RivesPerson
William Cabell Rives (1793–1868), a young Virginian who had graduated from the College of William and Mary in 1809 and joined the bar about 1814. He later served Virginia in the House and Senate and was twice U.S. minister to France.
Source: RIVES, William Cabell, History, Art & Archives, U.S. House of Representatives (opens in a new tab)
AttilaPerson
Attila (died 453) was king of the Huns. His raids on the Roman Empire made him remembered as the “Scourge of God.” Jefferson gives the name to Napoleon, who had abdicated in April 1814.
Source: Attila, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
ElbaPlace
Elba, an island off the coast of Tuscany. The Treaty of Fontainebleau (11 April 1814) gave Napoleon rule over it as a small principality, and he arrived there in May 1814. He escaped in February 1815, months after this letter.
Source: Napoleon I: Downfall and abdication, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Napoleon’s pensionMoney
Under the Treaty of Fontainebleau, Napoleon was promised a yearly income of two million francs, to be paid by the French government of the restored Bourbon king, his enemies.
bathosWord
A sudden, ridiculous drop from the grand to the trivial. Alexander Pope made the term famous in his mock treatise on bad writing, Peri Bathous, or the Art of Sinking in Poetry (1728).
Source: Bathos, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
- 9
Metastasio’s dying lionQuotation
Lines from Adriano in Siria (1732), an opera libretto by the Italian court poet Pietro Metastasio (1698–1782). In translation: “The lion, wounded to death, feels his life failing; he eyes his wound and still does not cower. So in his last fury he roars, threatens and rages, and dying, sometimes makes the hunter tremble.”
Source: Pietro Metastasio, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Council of Five HundredLaw and politics
The lower house of the French legislature under the Directory (1795–1799). When Bonaparte entered its session at Saint-Cloud during his coup, its deputies met him with a storm of abuse, and soldiers then cleared the hall.
Source: Coup of 18–19 Brumaire, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
18 Brumaire, Year VIIIEvent
A date in the French Revolutionary calendar: 9 November 1799, the first day of the coup that overthrew the Directory and replaced it with the Consulate under Bonaparte. His confrontation with the Five Hundred came on the second day, 10 November.
Source: Coup of 18–19 Brumaire, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Alexander I of RussiaPerson
Alexander I (1777–1825), emperor of Russia from 1801, who rode into Paris in triumph with the allied armies in March 1814. He then took a leading part in the peace settlement and in calling the Congress of Vienna.
Source: Alexander I, emperor of Russia, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Orders in CouncilLaw and politics
British decrees of 1807 that cut off neutral trade with France and its allies, a chief American grievance before the war. Britain revoked them on 23 June 1812, days after the United States had declared war, too late to stop it.
Sources: Napoleonic Wars: The Continental System and the blockade, 1807–11, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Trade restrictions, The War of 1812, Indiana University Libraries (opens in a new tab)
impressmentCustom
The Royal Navy’s practice of boarding American merchant ships and forcing sailors into British service, claiming them as British subjects or deserters. Thousands of Americans were taken, and it was a main cause of the War of 1812.
Sources: Impressment, National Park Service (opens in a new tab); The War of 1812 and impressment, Prologue Magazine, National Archives (opens in a new tab)
the North Atlantic fisheriesEvent
Article 3 of the 1783 peace treaty secured Americans’ right to fish off Newfoundland and in the Gulf of St. Lawrence. Adams, a peace commissioner then, had insisted on it as a condition of peace. The Treaty of Ghent (24 December 1814) left fishing out entirely.
Sources: From John Adams to William Thomas, 10 August 1822 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Treaty of Ghent, Milestone Documents, National Archives (opens in a new tab)
Massachusetts and the warEvent
Massachusetts, governed by Federalists under Governor Caleb Strong, opposed the War of 1812. Its House voted to condemn the war, and in 1812 Strong refused to place the state militia under federal command.
Source: Federalists oppose Madison's War, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
ad referendumLanguage
Latin, “for referral”: a diplomatic term for a question that is held over until the party it concerns has agreed to it.
Virgil, Aeneid 2.521Quotation
Latin, “The hour needs neither such help nor such defenders.” In Virgil’s Aeneid, Queen Hecuba says this to old King Priam as he straps on armor while Troy falls, urging him to take refuge at the altar.
Source: Vergil, Aeneid II.506–525, Dickinson College Commentaries (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
Jefferson’s retreat house and plantation in Bedford County, Virginia, near Lynchburg. From about 1810 he went there several times a year, staying for weeks at a time and keeping books there for reading.
Source: Poplar Forest, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Cicero’s praise of PlatoBook or text
The Roman orator and philosopher Cicero (106–43 BC) often praised Plato. Most famously, in the Tusculan Disputations (1.39) he says he would rather be wrong with Plato than right with other philosophers.
Source: Cicero, Tusculan Disputations, trans. C. D. Yonge (Project Gutenberg) (opens in a new tab)
SophistsIdea
Traveling teachers in fifth-century BC Greece who charged fees to teach rhetoric and other skills. Plato’s dialogues portray them as dealers in clever but false argument, which is why “sophistry” became an insult.
Source: The Sophists (Ancient Greek), Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy (opens in a new tab)
Platonism in Christian doctrineIdea
Jefferson rejected the Trinity and the divinity of Jesus. Following Joseph Priestley’s An History of the Corruptions of Christianity (1782), he held that later theologians had grafted Greek philosophy onto Jesus’ simple teachings. He told Adams in August 1813 that he had read Priestley’s books over and over.
Jefferson to Adams, August 22, 1813
Sources: Jefferson's Religious Beliefs, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 22 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Plato’s PhaedoBook or text
Plato’s chief case for the soul’s survival is the Phaedo. Set on Socrates’ last day before his execution, it gives several arguments for immortality, including the claims that learning is recollection and that opposites arise from opposites.
Source: Plato: Phaedo, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy (opens in a new tab)
Plato’s ideal stateBook or text
In Book 5 of Plato’s Republic, Socrates proposes that the guardian class share wives and children in common, so that no parent knows their own child, with breeding arranged by the rulers.
La Fontaine and Fontenelle on PlatoBook or text
A French literary anecdote. It pairs the fable writer Jean de La Fontaine (1621–1695) with Bernard Le Bovier de Fontenelle (1657–1757), a man of letters known for popularizing science. Here La Fontaine goes on praising Plato even after admitting he is obscure and a sophist.
Sources: Jean de La Fontaine, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Bernard Le Bovier, sieur de Fontenelle, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Socrates’ complaintBook or text
Diogenes Laertius, an ancient biographer of the philosophers, tells a story that Socrates heard Plato read his dialogue Lysis and exclaimed at how many lies the young man told about him. Modern scholars treat the story as probably invented.
Sources: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Book 3 (Perseus/Perseids) (opens in a new tab); Penner and Rowe, Plato's Lysis, Preface (Cambridge University Press) (opens in a new tab)
the use of the globesCustom
A standard school subject of the period. Pupils learned to work problems of geography and astronomy, such as time differences between places, on a matched pair of terrestrial and celestial globes, and academies regularly advertised it.
Jefferson’s university plansEvent
In spring 1814 Jefferson became a trustee of the Albemarle Academy. That September he set out a scheme of studies for it in a letter to Peter Carr. The academy became Central College and then the University of Virginia, chartered in 1819. Adams took up the subject in June 1815.
Adams to Jefferson, June 19, 1815
Sources: Letter from Thomas Jefferson to Peter Carr, 7 September 1814, Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Central College, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Jefferson’s letter of 24 JanuaryCross-reference
Jefferson’s previous full letter, written 24 January 1814, which opened by apologizing for being slow to answer Adams’s letters of late 1813. Adams answered it in the letter Jefferson mentions next.
Jefferson to Adams, January 24, 1814
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 24 January 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s letter of early 1814Cross-reference
Probably Adams’s long letter begun in February 1814 and finished 3 March 1814. Jefferson’s date does not match, but it is Adams’s only letter between January and July, and it mentions his long illness and confinement.
letter of 18 May 1814Cross-reference
A brief letter of 18 May 1814 introducing William Cabell Rives, to be handed to Adams in person. When Adams replied on 16 July, Rives had not yet arrived.
Jefferson to Adams, May 18, 1814
Source: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 18 May 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
William Cabell RivesPerson
William Cabell Rives (1793–1868), a young Virginian who had graduated from the College of William and Mary in 1809 and joined the bar about 1814. He later served Virginia in the House and Senate and was twice U.S. minister to France.
Source: RIVES, William Cabell, History, Art & Archives, U.S. House of Representatives (opens in a new tab)
AttilaPerson
Attila (died 453) was king of the Huns. His raids on the Roman Empire made him remembered as the “Scourge of God.” Jefferson gives the name to Napoleon, who had abdicated in April 1814.
Source: Attila, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
ElbaPlace
Elba, an island off the coast of Tuscany. The Treaty of Fontainebleau (11 April 1814) gave Napoleon rule over it as a small principality, and he arrived there in May 1814. He escaped in February 1815, months after this letter.
Source: Napoleon I: Downfall and abdication, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Napoleon’s pensionMoney
Under the Treaty of Fontainebleau, Napoleon was promised a yearly income of two million francs, to be paid by the French government of the restored Bourbon king, his enemies.
bathosWord
A sudden, ridiculous drop from the grand to the trivial. Alexander Pope made the term famous in his mock treatise on bad writing, Peri Bathous, or the Art of Sinking in Poetry (1728).
Source: Bathos, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
- 9
Metastasio’s dying lionQuotation
Lines from Adriano in Siria (1732), an opera libretto by the Italian court poet Pietro Metastasio (1698–1782). In translation: “The lion, wounded to death, feels his life failing; he eyes his wound and still does not cower. So in his last fury he roars, threatens and rages, and dying, sometimes makes the hunter tremble.”
Source: Pietro Metastasio, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Council of Five HundredLaw and politics
The lower house of the French legislature under the Directory (1795–1799). When Bonaparte entered its session at Saint-Cloud during his coup, its deputies met him with a storm of abuse, and soldiers then cleared the hall.
Source: Coup of 18–19 Brumaire, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
18 Brumaire, Year VIIIEvent
A date in the French Revolutionary calendar: 9 November 1799, the first day of the coup that overthrew the Directory and replaced it with the Consulate under Bonaparte. His confrontation with the Five Hundred came on the second day, 10 November.
Source: Coup of 18–19 Brumaire, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Alexander I of RussiaPerson
Alexander I (1777–1825), emperor of Russia from 1801, who rode into Paris in triumph with the allied armies in March 1814. He then took a leading part in the peace settlement and in calling the Congress of Vienna.
Source: Alexander I, emperor of Russia, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Orders in CouncilLaw and politics
British decrees of 1807 that cut off neutral trade with France and its allies, a chief American grievance before the war. Britain revoked them on 23 June 1812, days after the United States had declared war, too late to stop it.
Sources: Napoleonic Wars: The Continental System and the blockade, 1807–11, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Trade restrictions, The War of 1812, Indiana University Libraries (opens in a new tab)
impressmentCustom
The Royal Navy’s practice of boarding American merchant ships and forcing sailors into British service, claiming them as British subjects or deserters. Thousands of Americans were taken, and it was a main cause of the War of 1812.
Sources: Impressment, National Park Service (opens in a new tab); The War of 1812 and impressment, Prologue Magazine, National Archives (opens in a new tab)
the North Atlantic fisheriesEvent
Article 3 of the 1783 peace treaty secured Americans’ right to fish off Newfoundland and in the Gulf of St. Lawrence. Adams, a peace commissioner then, had insisted on it as a condition of peace. The Treaty of Ghent (24 December 1814) left fishing out entirely.
Sources: From John Adams to William Thomas, 10 August 1822 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Treaty of Ghent, Milestone Documents, National Archives (opens in a new tab)
Massachusetts and the warEvent
Massachusetts, governed by Federalists under Governor Caleb Strong, opposed the War of 1812. Its House voted to condemn the war, and in 1812 Strong refused to place the state militia under federal command.
Source: Federalists oppose Madison's War, National Park Service (opens in a new tab)
ad referendumLanguage
Latin, “for referral”: a diplomatic term for a question that is held over until the party it concerns has agreed to it.
Virgil, Aeneid 2.521Quotation
Latin, “The hour needs neither such help nor such defenders.” In Virgil’s Aeneid, Queen Hecuba says this to old King Priam as he straps on armor while Troy falls, urging him to take refuge at the altar.
Source: Vergil, Aeneid II.506–525, Dickinson College Commentaries (opens in a new tab)
Poplar ForestPlace
Jefferson’s retreat house and plantation in Bedford County, Virginia, near Lynchburg. From about 1810 he went there several times a year, staying for weeks at a time and keeping books there for reading.
Source: Poplar Forest, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Cicero’s praise of PlatoBook or text
The Roman orator and philosopher Cicero (106–43 BC) often praised Plato. Most famously, in the Tusculan Disputations (1.39) he says he would rather be wrong with Plato than right with other philosophers.
Source: Cicero, Tusculan Disputations, trans. C. D. Yonge (Project Gutenberg) (opens in a new tab)
SophistsIdea
Traveling teachers in fifth-century BC Greece who charged fees to teach rhetoric and other skills. Plato’s dialogues portray them as dealers in clever but false argument, which is why “sophistry” became an insult.
Source: The Sophists (Ancient Greek), Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy (opens in a new tab)
Platonism in Christian doctrineIdea
Jefferson rejected the Trinity and the divinity of Jesus. Following Joseph Priestley’s An History of the Corruptions of Christianity (1782), he held that later theologians had grafted Greek philosophy onto Jesus’ simple teachings. He told Adams in August 1813 that he had read Priestley’s books over and over.
Jefferson to Adams, August 22, 1813
Sources: Jefferson's Religious Beliefs, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab); To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 22 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Plato’s PhaedoBook or text
Plato’s chief case for the soul’s survival is the Phaedo. Set on Socrates’ last day before his execution, it gives several arguments for immortality, including the claims that learning is recollection and that opposites arise from opposites.
Source: Plato: Phaedo, Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy (opens in a new tab)
Plato’s ideal stateBook or text
In Book 5 of Plato’s Republic, Socrates proposes that the guardian class share wives and children in common, so that no parent knows their own child, with breeding arranged by the rulers.
La Fontaine and Fontenelle on PlatoBook or text
A French literary anecdote. It pairs the fable writer Jean de La Fontaine (1621–1695) with Bernard Le Bovier de Fontenelle (1657–1757), a man of letters known for popularizing science. Here La Fontaine goes on praising Plato even after admitting he is obscure and a sophist.
Sources: Jean de La Fontaine, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab); Bernard Le Bovier, sieur de Fontenelle, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
Socrates’ complaintBook or text
Diogenes Laertius, an ancient biographer of the philosophers, tells a story that Socrates heard Plato read his dialogue Lysis and exclaimed at how many lies the young man told about him. Modern scholars treat the story as probably invented.
Sources: Diogenes Laertius, Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Book 3 (Perseus/Perseids) (opens in a new tab); Penner and Rowe, Plato's Lysis, Preface (Cambridge University Press) (opens in a new tab)
the use of the globesCustom
A standard school subject of the period. Pupils learned to work problems of geography and astronomy, such as time differences between places, on a matched pair of terrestrial and celestial globes, and academies regularly advertised it.
Jefferson’s university plansEvent
In spring 1814 Jefferson became a trustee of the Albemarle Academy. That September he set out a scheme of studies for it in a letter to Peter Carr. The academy became Central College and then the University of Virginia, chartered in 1819. Adams took up the subject in June 1815.
Adams to Jefferson, June 19, 1815
Sources: Letter from Thomas Jefferson to Peter Carr, 7 September 1814, Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Central College, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, Monticello (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 5 July 1814 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-07-02-0341
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of March 7, 2026. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 5 July 1814. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-07-02-0341. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1814-07-05-jefferson-to-adams/.