Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson on pious frauds and the paper-money mania
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson answers a backlog of Adams’s letters. He dismisses Taylor’s book, traces how a mistranslation made Christianity ‘part of the common law,’ denounces banks and predicts a paper-money crash, and sends Adams a life of Rittenhouse.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 2,283 words · 11 min read
The letter
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
I have great need of the indulgence you so kindly offered in your letter of December 25,22 which allows me to answer your friendly letters at my leisure. My frequent and long absences from home are the first cause of my slowness as a correspondent. The second is the business that piles up while I am away, some of which imperiously demands my attention first. I now owe you answers to your letters of November 12, 14, 16,33 and December 3, 19 and 25.
I have great need of the indulgence so kindly extended to me in your favor of Dec. 25.2 of permitting me to answer your friendly letters at my leisure. my frequent and long absences from home are a first cause of tardiness in my correspondence, and a 2d the accumulation of business during my absence, some of which imperiously commands first attentions. I am now in arrear to you for your letters of Nov. 12. 14. 16.3 Dec. 3. 19. 25.
I have made some inquiries about Taylor’s book,44 and I learn from one of his neighbors that it has been known for some time that he was writing a political work. We had not heard here that it was published, and none of our papers has announced it. But this must be the 630-page book you have received, and certainly no one could ever mistake either the style or the substance of the author of Arator.55 In the latter work, as you observe, there are some good things, but they are so wrapped up in odd, far-fetched, affected and mystical conceits, and in flimsy theories, that who can take the trouble to dig them out?
I have made some enquiry about Taylor’s book4, and I learn from a neighbor of his that it has been understood for some time that he was writing a political work. we had not heard here of it’s publication, nor has it been announced in any of our papers. but this must be the book of 630. pages which you have recieved; and certainly neither the style nor the stuff of the author of Arator5 can ever be mistaken. in the latter work, as you observe, there are some good things, but so involved in quaint, in far-fetched, affected, mystical conciepts, and flimsy theories, that who can take the trouble of getting at them?
You ask me whether I have ever seen J. W. Goethe’s Schriften.66 Never. Nor had the question ever occurred to me before: Where did we get the Ten Commandments? The book does give them to us word for word. But where did it get them? For it tells us itself that they were written by the finger of God on tablets of stone, and that Moses destroyed those tablets. It sets out the commandments on the second set of tablets, different in form and substance, but still without saying how the first ones were recovered. But the whole history of these books is so defective and doubtful that it seems useless to attempt any detailed inquiry into it. And such tricks have been played with their text, and with the texts of other books relating to them, that we have a right, for that reason alone, to doubt seriously which parts of them are genuine. In the New Testament there is internal evidence that parts of it came from an extraordinary man, and that other parts are the work of very inferior minds. It is as easy to separate those parts as to pick out diamonds from dunghills.77 The substance of the first was the kind of thing the hearers would keep in memory and hand on by tradition for a long time; the second was the kind of stuff that might be gathered up anywhere, at any time, to embed the first in.—I have nothing by Vives or Budaeus,88 and little by Erasmus. If the personal histories of the saints, whose absence they regret, would have given us the history of the tricks these writers admit were practiced, and of the lies they agree were invented for the sake of religion, then I join them in their regrets. Those would be the only parts of such histories worth reading. It is not only the sacred books that they have interpolated, gutted and falsified in this way, but also other men’s works relating to them, and even the laws of the land. We have a curious example of one of these pious frauds in the Laws of Alfred.99 He compiled, as you know, a digest from the laws of the Heptarchy for the government of the united kingdom, and in his preface to that work he tells us expressly the sources he drew it from: namely, the laws of Ine, of Offa and of Ethelbert (not naming the Pentateuch). But his pious interpolator very clumsily puts in front of his work four chapters of Exodus (from the 20th to the 23rd) as part of the laws of the land, so that Alfred’s preface is made to stand in the body of the work. Our judges, too, have lent a ready hand to these frauds. They have been willing to lay the yoke of their own opinions on the necks of others, and to extend the coercive force of civil law to the dogmas of their religion by declaring that these dogmas are part of the law of the land. In the Year Book 34 Henry VI, folio 38,1010 in a case of quare impedit, where the question was how far the common law takes notice of church law, Prisot, Chief Justice,1111 says in the course of his argument: “To such laws as they of Holy Church have in ancient writing, it is fitting for us to give credence; for that is common law, on which all kinds of laws are founded. And also, Sir, we are bound to take notice of their law of Holy Church, and so on.”1212 Finch begins the business of falsification by mistranslating and misreading Prisot’s words this way: “to such laws of the church as have warrant in holy scripture our law gives credence,” citing the case above and Prisot’s words in the margin (Finch’s Law, Book 1, chapter 3).1313 Here, then, we find ancien scripture, ancient writing, translated as “holy scripture.” Wingate, in 1658,1414 turns this into a maxim of law in Finch’s very words, but he cites Prisot, not Finch. And Sheppard, under the title “Religion,”1515 in 1675, lays it down in the same words of Finch and quotes the Year Book, Finch and Wingate. Then comes Sir Matthew Hale, in the case of the King v. Taylor1616 (1 Ventris 293; 3 Keble 607), and declares that “Christianity is parcel of the laws of England.” He cites nobody, and rests it, along with his judgment against the witches,1717 on his own authority, which indeed was sound and good in every case that no superstition or bigotry could enter. Thus strengthened, the court in 1728, in the King v. Woolston,1818 would not allow anyone to question whether writing against Christianity was punishable at common law, saying that Hale had settled it in Taylor’s case (2 Strange 834). Wood, therefore, at page 409,1919 lays it down without hesitation as a principle that all blasphemy and profanity are offenses at common law, and cites Strange. Blackstone, in 1763, repeats in Sir Matthew Hale’s words that “Christianity is part of the laws of England,” citing Ventris and Strange in the places given above. And Lord Mansfield, in the case of the Chamberlain of London v. Evans,2020 in 1767, qualifying the position somewhat, says that “the essential principles of revealed religion are part of the common law.” So we find this whole string of authorities hanging from one another on a single hook—a mistranslation by Finch of Prisot’s words—or on nothing. For they all quote Prisot, or one another, or nobody. Thus Finch misquotes Prisot; so does Wingate, but in Finch’s words; Sheppard quotes Prisot, Finch and Wingate; Hale cites nobody; the court in Woolston’s case cites Hale; Wood cites Woolston’s case; Blackstone cites that case and Hale; and Lord Mansfield volunteers his own bare say-so. And who can now doubt that the whole Bible and Testament are part of the common law? Or that Connecticut, in her blue laws,2121 when she laid it down as a principle that the laws of God should be the laws of their land except where their own laws contradicted them, did anything more than express, with a saving clause, what the English judges had less cautiously declared without any restriction—and what, I dare say, our cunning Chief Justice2222 would swear to? He would find as many sophistries to twist it out of the general terms of our Declarations of Rights, and even out of the stricter text of the Virginia “Act for the Freedom of Religion,”2323 as he found to twist Burr’s neck out of the noose of treason. We may well say, then, with him who was all fair-mindedness and benevolence: “Woe unto you, ye lawyers, for ye lade men with burdens grievous to bear.”2424
You ask me if I have ever seen the work of J. W. Goethens Schoristen6? Never. nor did the question ever occur to me before Where got we the ten commandments? the book indeed gives them to us verbatim. but where did it get them? for itself tells us they were written by the finger of god on tables of stone, which were destroyed by Moses: it specifies those on the 2d set of tables in different form and substance, but still without saying how the others were recovered. but the whole history of these books is so defective and doubtful that it seems vain to attempt minute enquiry into it: and such tricks have been plaid with their text, and with the texts of other books relating to them, that we have a right, from that cause, to entertain much doubt what parts of them are genuine. in the New testament there is internal evidence that parts of it have proceeded from an extraordinary man; and that other parts are of the fabric of very inferior minds. it is as easy to separate those parts, as to pick out diamonds from dunghills7. the matter of the first was such as would be preserved in the memory of the hearers, and handed on by tradition for a long time; the latter such stuff as might be gathered up, for imbedding it, any where, and at any time.—I have nothing of Vives, or Budaeus8, and little of Erasmus. if the familiar histories of the saints, the want of which they regret, would have given us the histories of those tricks which these writers acknolege to have been practised, and of the lies they agree have been invented for the sake of religion, I join them in their regrets. these would be the only parts of their histories worth reading. it is not only the sacred volumes they have thus interpolated, gutted, and falsified, but the works of others relating to them, and even the laws of the land. we have a curious instance of one of these pious frauds in the Laws of Alfred9. he composed, you know, from the laws of the Heptarchy, a Digest for the government of the United kingdom, and in his preface to that work he tells us expressly the sources from which he drew it, to wit, the laws of Ina, of Offa & Aethelbert, (not naming the Pentateuch.) but his pious Interpolator, very awkwardly, premises to his work four chapters of Exodus (from the 20th to the 23d) as a part of the laws of the land; so that Alfred’s preface is made to stand in the body of the work. our judges too have lent a ready hand to further these frauds, and have been willing to lay the yoke of their own opinions on the necks of others; to extend the coercions of municipal law to the dogmas of their religion, by declaring that these make a part of the law of the land. in the Year Book 34. H. 6. fo. 38.10 in Quare impedit, where the question was how far the Common law takes notice of the Ecclesiastical law, Prisot, Chief Justice11, in the course of his argument says ‘a tiels leis que ils de Seint eglise12 ont en ancien scripture, covient a nous a donner credence; car ces Common ley sur quels touts manners leis sont fondes: et auxy, Sir, nous sumus obliges de conustre lour ley de saint eglise Etc.’ Finch begins the business of falsification by mistranslating and mistaking the words of Prisot thus ‘to such laws of the church as have warrant in holy scripture our law giveth credence,’ citing the above case & the words of Prisot in the margin. Finch’s law. B. 1. c. 3.13 here then we find ancien scripture, antient writing, translated ‘holy scripture.’ this, Wingate in 1658.14 erects into a Maxim of law, in the very words of Finch, but citing Prisot, and not Finch. and Sheppard tit. Religion15, in 1675 laying it down in the same words of Finch, quotes the Year Book, Finch and Wingate. then comes Sr Matthew Hale, in the case of the King v. Taylor16 1. Ventr. 293. 3. Keb. 607. and declares that ‘Christianity is parcel of the laws of England.’ citing nobody, and resting it, with his judgment against the witches17, on his own authority, which indeed was sound and good in all cases into which no superstition or bigotry could enter. thus strengthened, the court in 1728 in the King v. Woolston18, would not suffer it to be questioned whether to write against Christianity was punishable at Common law, saying it had been so settled by Hale in Taylor’s case. 2. Stra. 834. Wood therefore, 409.19 without scruple, lays down as a principle that all blasphemy and profaneness are offences at the Common law, and cites Strange. Blackstone, in 1763. repeats in the words of Sr Matthew Hale that ‘Christianity is part of the laws of England,’ citing Ventris and Strange ubi supra. and Ld Mansfield in the case of the Chamberlain of London v. Evans20, in 1767. qualifying somewhat the position, says that ‘the essential principles of revealed religion are part of the Common law.’ thus we find this string of authorities all hanging by one another on a single hook, a mistranslation by Finch of the words of Prisot, or on nothing. for all quote Prisot, or one another, or nobody. thus Finch misquotes Prisot; Wingate also, but using Finch’s words; Sheppard quotes Prisot, Finch and Wingate; Hale cites nobody; the court in Woolston’s case cite Hale; Wood cites Woolston’s case; Blackstone that & Hale; and Ld Mansfield volunteers his own ipse dixit. and who now can question but that the whole Bible and Testament are a part of the Common law? and that Connecticut, in her blue laws21, laying it down as a principle that the laws of god should be the laws of their land, except where their own contradicted them, did any thing more than express, with a salvo, what the English judges had less cautiously declared without any restriction? and what I dare say our cunning Chief Justice22 would swear to, and find as many sophisms to twist it out of the general terms of our Declarations of rights, and even the stricter text of the Virginia ‘act for the freedom of religion’23 as he did to twist Burr’s neck out of the halter of treason. may we not say then with him who was all candor and benevolence ‘Woe unto you, ye lawyers24, for ye lade men with burdens grievous to bear.’
I agree with you that Priestley,2525 in his comparison of the doctrines of philosophy and of revelation, did not do the undertaking justice; but he felt the hand of death pressing on him. Enfield2626 has given us a clearer account of the ethics of the ancient philosophers. But the great work of which Enfield’s is an abridgment, Brucker’s History of Philosophy,2727 is the treasure I would like to own, though only as a book of reference or for special research. For who could read six quarto volumes of 1,000 closely printed pages each, in modern Latin? Your account of d’Argens’s Ocellus2828 makes me wish I had it too. Ocellus offers a fruitful text for a sensible and learned commentator. The Abbé Batteux’s version, which I have, is a meager thing.
I think with you that Priestley25, in his comparison of the doctrines of Philosophy and of revelation, did not do justice to the undertaking, but he felt himself pressed by the hand of death. Enfield26 has given us a more distinct account of the ethics of the antient philosophers; but the great work, of which Enfield’s is an abridgment, Brucker’s history of Philosophy27, is the treasure which I would wish to possess, as a book of reference or of special research only, for who could read 6. vols 4to of 1000 pages each, closely printed, of modern Latin? your account of D’Argens’ Ocellus28 makes me wish for him also. Ocellus furnishes a fruitful text for a sensible and learned commentator. the Abbé Batteux’, which I have, is a meagre thing.
You surprise me with your account of how strong family distinction2929 still is in your state. With us it is so totally extinguished that not a spark of it can be found, except lurking in the hearts of some of our old Tories. But all bigotries hang together; and this one, in the Eastern states, hangs, I suspect, on the bigotry of the priesthood. Here youth, beauty, mind and manners are valued more than a pedigree.
You surprise me with the account you give of the strength of family distinction29 still existing in your state. with us it is so totally extinguished that not a spark of it is to be found but lurking in the hearts of some of our old tories. but all bigotries hang to one another; and this in the Eastern states, hangs, as I suspect, to that of the priesthood. here youth, beauty, mind and manners are more valued than a pedigree.
I do not remember the conversation between us that you mention in yours of November 15,3030 about your proposal to give Congress the exclusive power of establishing banks. My opposition to it must have rested not on taking the power from the states, but on leaving any trace of it in existence, even in the hands of Congress, because that would only have changed the organ of abuse. I have always been an enemy of banks: not of those that discount for cash, but of those that foist their own paper into circulation and so drive out our cash. My zeal against those institutions was so warm and open when the Bank of the United States3131 was established that I was mocked as a maniac by the tribe of bank-mongers, who were seeking to filch their swindling and barren gains from the public. But the errors of that day cannot be undone. The evils they have bred are now upon us, and the question is how we are to get out of them. Shall we build an altar to the old paper money of the Revolution, which ruined individuals but saved the republic, and burn on it all the bank charters, present and future, and their notes with them? For these will ruin both the republic and individuals. This cannot be done. The mania is too strong. By its delusions and corruptions it has seized all the members of our governments, general, special and individual. Our circulating paper last year was estimated at 200 million dollars. The new banks now being petitioned for in the respective legislatures would add about 60 million of capital, and so, of course, 180 million of additional circulation. That nearly doubles last year’s circulation and raises the whole mass to nearly 400 million, or forty times the healthy amount of circulation for a population of 8 million in our circumstances. And you remember how fast our money fell after our forty-for-one settlement3232 in the Revolution. I doubt the present trash can hold out as long. I think the 380 million must blow everything up in the course of this year; or certainly the ruin will be completed by the doubling that will follow, as a matter of course, at the legislative sessions next winter. Ought not prudent men who own stock in any moneyed institution either to draw out the cash and hoard it, now while they can, or to exchange it for canal stock, or for some other stock that, being founded on immovable property, will come through the crash unhurt? I have been trying to persuade a friend in our legislature to try to save this state from the general ruin by stepping in in time. I propose to him: first, to prohibit all foreign paper at once; second, to give our own banks six months to call in all their five-dollar bills (the lowest we allow), another six months to call in their ten-dollar notes, and six months more to call in all notes below fifty dollars. This would shrink the currency so gradually that it would not shock contracts already made. In the end it would leave only bills of a size needed in dealings between merchant and merchant, and it would ensure a metal currency for the mass of citizens. But it will not be done. You might as well, like the sailors, whistle to the wind as suggest precautions against having too much money. We must scud, then, before the gale, and try to hold fast, ourselves, to some plank of the wreck. God send us all a safe deliverance, and send you every other kind and degree of happiness.
I do not remember the conversation between us which you mention in yours of Nov. 15.30 on your proposition to vest in Congress the exclusive power of establishing banks. my opposition to it must have been grounded, not on taking the power from the states, but on leaving any vestige of it in existence, even in the hands of Congress; because it would only have been a change of the organ of abuse. I have ever been the enemy of banks; not of those discounting for cash; but of those foisting their own paper into circulation, and thus banishing our cash. my zeal against those institutions was so warm and open at the establishment of the bank of the US.31 that I was derided as a Maniac by the tribe of bank-mongers, who were seeking to filch from the public their swindling, and barren gains. but the errors of that day cannot be recalled. the evils they have engendered are now upon us, and the question is how we are to get out of them? shall we build an altar to the old paper money of the revolution, which ruined individuals but saved the republic, and burn on that all the bank charters present and future, and their notes with them? for these are to ruin both republic and individuals. this cannot be done. the Mania is too strong. it has siesed by it’s delusions & corruptions all the members of our governments, general, special, and individual. our circulating paper of the last year was estimated at 200. millions of dollars. the new banks now petitioned for, to the several legislatures, are for about 60. millions additional capital, & of course 180. millions of additional circulation, nearly doubling that of the last year; and raising the whole mass to near 400. millions, or 40. for 1. of the wholsome amount of circulation for a population of 8. millions circumstanced as we are: and you remember how rapidly our money went down after our 40. for 1. establishment32 in the revolution. I doubt if the present trash can hold as long. I think the 380. millions must blow all up in the course of the present year; or certainly it will be consummated by the reduplication to take place of course at the legislative meetings of the next winter. should not prudent men, who possess stock in any monied institution, either draw & hoard the cash, now while they can, or exchange it for canal stock, or such other as being bottomed on immoveable property, will remain unhurt by the crush? I have been endeavoring to persuade a friend in our legislature to try and save this state from the general ruin by timely interference. I propose to him 1. to prohibit instantly all foreign paper. 2. to give our own banks 6. months to call in all their 5. Dollar bills (the lowest we allow.) another 6. months to call in their 10.D. notes, and 6. months more to call in all below 50. Dollars. this would produce so gradual a diminution of medium as not to shock contracts already made; would leave finally bills of such size as would be called for only in transactions between merchant and merchant, and ensure a metallic circulation for those of the mass of citizens. but it will not be done. you might as well, with the sailors, whistle to the wind, as suggest precautions against having too much money. we must scud then before the gale, and try to hold fast, ourselves, by some plank of the wreck. god send us all a safe deliverance, and to yourself every other species and degree of happiness.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Postscript
P.S. I return your letter of November 15, as it asks. And supposing that the recently published life of our good and truly great Rittenhouse3333 may not have reached you, I am sending you a copy for your acceptance. Even its episodes and digressions may add to the amusement it will give you. But if the history of the world were written on the same scale, the whole world would not hold it. As an astronomer, Rittenhouse would stand level with any man of his time, and as a mechanician he has certainly never been equaled. In this respect he was truly great. But set beside Newton, every human character must look tiny, and no one would have shrunk more feelingly from the painful comparison than the modest and amiable Rittenhouse, whose genius and merit are no less for this exaggerated comparison by his overzealous biographer.
P.S. I return your letter of Nov. 15. as it requests: and supposing that the late publication of the life of our good & really great Rittenhouse33 may not have reached you I send a copy for your acceptance. even it’s episodes and digressions may add to the amusement it will furnish you. but if the history of the world were written on the same scale, the whole world would not hold it. Rittenhouse, as an astronomer, would stand on a line with any of his time, and as a mechanician he certainly has not been equalled. in this view he was truly great. but, placed along side of Newton, every human character must appear diminutive, & none would have shrunk more feelingly from the painful parallel than the modest and amiable Rittenhouse, whose genius and merit are not the less for this exaggerated comparison of his over zealous biographer.
Notes3333
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop house and plantation near Charlottesville in Albemarle County, Virginia. He lived there in retirement after leaving the presidency in 1809, and wrote this letter from there.
Adams’s letter of 25 DecemberCross-reference
Adams’s short letter of 25 December 1813 told Jefferson to answer whenever he liked and not to worry, because Adams wrote mainly as a refuge from boredom.
Adams to Jefferson, December 25, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 25 December 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the unanswered Adams lettersCross-reference
Jefferson lists six Adams letters he has not yet answered, written between 12 November and 25 December 1813. The correspondence has no Adams letter of 16 November. The third date is evidently a slip for 15 November, the letter Jefferson cites correctly later in this letter and returns in his postscript.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Taylor’s InquiryBook or text
John Taylor of Caroline (1753–1824) was a Virginia planter, sometime senator and Republican political writer. His long book An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United States came out at Fredericksburg in 1814. It was written largely as a rebuttal of the political theory in Adams’s Defense of the Constitutions.
Sources: Library of Virginia, Virginia Imprints: An inquiry into the principles and policy of the government of the United States (1814) (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: John Taylor (opens in a new tab)
AratorBook or text
Taylor’s Arator, a series of essays on farming laced with political argument, first appeared as a book at Georgetown in 1813. Jefferson had ordered a copy that year, so he already knew Taylor’s prose.
Goethe’s SchriftenBook or text
These are the collected Schriften (‘Writings’) of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, which Adams asked about in his letter of 14 November 1813. They included Goethe’s 1773 essay arguing that the commandments cut on Moses’ stone tablets were the covenant laws of Exodus 34, not the familiar ten of Exodus 20. In the original the title appears as ‘Goethens Schoristen’.
Adams to Jefferson, November 14, 1813
Sources: From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 14 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Concordia Theological Monthly, vol. 9 (on Goethe and the Decalogue) (opens in a new tab)
diamonds and dunghillsCross-reference
Jefferson had used the same image in his letter of 12 October 1813. There he described how easily the genuine sayings of Jesus, which he had cut out of the Gospels for his own use, could be told apart from the surrounding material.
Vives and BudaeusPerson
Juan Luis Vives (1493–1540) was a Spanish humanist, and Guillaume Budé, Latinized as Budaeus (1467–1540), was France’s foremost classical scholar. Adams’s letter of 3 December 1813 had named them with Erasmus and passed on complaints that the lives of the saints were written with less care than the lives of philosophers.
Adams to Jefferson, December 3, 1813
Sources: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Juan Luis Vives (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Guillaume Budé (opens in a new tab)
Alfred’s law codeLaw and politics
Alfred the Great, king of Wessex (871–899), issued an Old English law book, the domboc, late in his reign. It opens with a long prologue rendering the Ten Commandments and much of Exodus 21–23. Modern scholars treat that prologue as Alfred’s own work, not the later insertion Jefferson believed it to be.
Sources: Historical Society of the New York Courts: The Anglo-Saxon Dooms, Part 2, Dooms of the Kingdom of Wessex (opens in a new tab); Jurasinski and Oliver, The Laws of Alfred (Cambridge University Press), excerpt (opens in a new tab)
the Year BooksBook or text
The Year Books were reports of arguments in the medieval English royal courts, written in Law French. The citation points to the volume for the 34th year of Henry VI’s reign (1455–56), leaf 38.
Source: Boston University School of Law: Legal History, The Year Books (Seipp's index) (opens in a new tab)
Sir John PrisotPerson
Sir John Prisot (died about 1460) was Chief Justice of the Court of Common Pleas from 1449. His remark in this case about a church patronage dispute is the first link in the chain of legal authorities Jefferson traces through the rest of the paragraph.
Sources: Dictionary of National Biography (1885–1900): Prisot, John (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 10 February 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Prisot’s words in Law FrenchLanguage
Law French was the Norman-derived French used in English courts. Roughly: ‘To such laws as they of Holy Church have in ancient writing, it is fitting that we give credence, for that is common law, on which all kinds of law are founded; and also, Sir, we are bound to take notice of their law of Holy Church.’
Source: Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 10 February 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Finch’s LawBook or text
Sir Henry Finch (died 1625) was a serjeant-at-law whose treatise Nomotechnia (1613, in Law French) appeared in his own English version as Law, or a Discourse Thereof (1627). Jefferson cites book 1, chapter 3.
Source: Folger Shakespeare Library catalog: Finch, Law, or, a discourse thereof (1627) (opens in a new tab)
Edmund WingatePerson
Edmund Wingate (1596–1656) was a mathematician and lawyer. His Maximes of Reason, or the Reason of the Common Law of England, a collection of 214 legal maxims with commentary, was published after his death in 1658.
Source: Wythepedia (William & Mary Law Library): Maximes of Reason (opens in a new tab)
William SheppardPerson
William Sheppard (died about 1675) was a prolific legal writer. His Grand Abridgment of the Common and Statute Law of England (1675) arranged the law alphabetically under headings. Jefferson cites the heading (‘title’) ‘Religion’.
Sources: University of Virginia Law Library catalogue: Sheppard's Abridgment, London, 1675 (opens in a new tab); Lexicons of Early Modern English: William Sheppard, A Grand Abridgement (1675) (opens in a new tab)
Taylor’s CaseEvent
In this blasphemy case of 1676 (some reports say 1675), Sir Matthew Hale, Chief Justice of King’s Bench, punished John Taylor for scurrilous words against Christ and religion. It is often called the first reported common-law blasphemy case. ‘Ventr.’ and ‘Keb.’ are the law reports of Ventris and Keble.
Hale and the Bury witchesEvent
In March 1662 at Bury St Edmunds, Hale presided at the trial of Rose Cullender and Amy Denny, two widows from Lowestoft accused of bewitching children. They were convicted and hanged.
Woolston’s caseEvent
Thomas Woolston, an unorthodox English clergyman, argued in his Six Discourses on the Miracles of Our Saviour (1727–29) that Christ’s miracles should be read only as allegories. He was convicted of blasphemy in 1729, fined and imprisoned, and he died in custody. ‘Stra.’ refers to Sir John Strange’s law reports.
Source: Encyclopedia.com: Woolston, Thomas (opens in a new tab)
Thomas WoodPerson
Thomas Wood (1661–1722) wrote An Institute of the Laws of England (1720). It was a standard students’ guide to English law before Blackstone’s Commentaries and went through ten editions. Jefferson cites its page 409.
Source: Wellcome Collection catalog: Wood, An institute of the laws of England (1720) (opens in a new tab)
the Evans caseEvent
The City of London tried to fine Allen Evans, a Protestant Dissenter, for refusing the office of sheriff, which as a non-Anglican he could not lawfully hold. In 1767 the House of Lords unanimously upheld judgment for Evans. Lord Mansfield’s speech in the case became known as a defense of toleration for Dissenters.
Connecticut blue lawsLaw and politics
The strict moral codes of colonial Connecticut and New Haven, which leaned heavily on Scripture. The name and the most lurid list of these laws came from the loyalist clergyman Samuel Peters’s General History of Connecticut (London, 1781), much of which was invented.
Sources: ConnecticutHistory.org: The Long, Ambiguous History of Connecticut's Blue Laws (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: blue law (opens in a new tab)
John Marshall and the Burr trialPerson
John Marshall, a Federalist, was Chief Justice of the United States from 1801 and a long-standing political opponent of Jefferson. At Aaron Burr’s treason trial in Richmond in 1807 he ruled that the prosecution had to prove Burr took part in an overt act of war. The jury acquitted Burr on 1 September 1807.
Sources: Constitution Annotated (Cornell LII): Trial of Aaron Burr (opens in a new tab); Federal Judicial Center: The Burr Treason Trial (opens in a new tab)
Virginia Statute for Religious FreedomLaw and politics
This was Jefferson’s own bill, drafted in 1777 and adopted by the Virginia General Assembly on 16 January 1786. It barred the state from compelling worship or support of any church, and from penalizing anyone for religious opinions.
‘Woe unto you, ye lawyers’Quotation
These are the words of Jesus in Luke 11:46 (King James Version), spoken against experts in the religious law. Jesus is the person Jefferson calls ‘all candor and benevolence’.
Source: Luke 11:46, King James Version (Bible Gateway) (opens in a new tab)
Priestley’s Doctrines of Heathen PhilosophyBook or text
Joseph Priestley’s The Doctrines of Heathen Philosophy, Compared with Those of Revelation was printed at Northumberland, Pennsylvania, in 1804, after his death that year. Adams’s letter of 25 December 1813 had faulted its thin treatment of the Pythagoreans.
William EnfieldPerson
William Enfield (1741–1797) was an English Dissenting minister. His two-volume History of Philosophy (London, 1791) condensed Brucker’s Latin history and remained the standard English survey for decades.
Brucker’s Historia critica philosophiaeBook or text
Johann Jakob Brucker (1696–1770) was a German Lutheran scholar. His Historia critica philosophiae, a vast critical history of philosophy in Latin, was published in quarto volumes at Leipzig in 1742–44, with a further volume in 1767. It was the leading history of philosophy before Kant.
Source: Wellcome Collection catalog: Brucker, Historia critica philosophiae (opens in a new tab)
d’Argens’s Ocellus LucanusBook or text
Ocellus Lucanus was an early Pythagorean philosopher. The treatise on the eternal universe that bears his name is now judged a much later forgery. The Marquis d’Argens published its Greek text with a French translation and long commentary in 1762, which Adams praised on 25 December 1813. Abbé Charles Batteux’s rival translation followed in 1768.
Adams to Jefferson, December 25, 1813
Sources: Sowerby, Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 2, p. 26 (Monticello) (opens in a new tab); Kathleen Freeman, Ancilla to the Pre-Socratic Philosophers: Ocellus (opens in a new tab)
old Massachusetts familiesCross-reference
In his letter of 15 November 1813 Adams wrote that Massachusetts still honored its old families, such as the Winthrops, Winslows, Bradfords, Saltonstalls and Quincys, for their names and connections.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: The Founders' Constitution: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s bank proposalCross-reference
In his letter of 15 November 1813 Adams recalled proposing, at his table in Philadelphia, a constitutional amendment forbidding the states to create banks. Congress would instead charter a single national bank, with branches in each state and capital capped at ten million dollars. Adams said Jefferson had rejected the idea.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: The Founders' Constitution: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (opens in a new tab)
first Bank of the United StatesEvent
The first national bank was proposed by Alexander Hamilton and chartered by Congress in February 1791. Jefferson, then Secretary of State, advised Washington in writing that Congress had no constitutional power to create it. The bank’s twenty-year charter lapsed in 1811.
Sources: Jefferson's Opinion on the Constitutionality of a National Bank, 15 February 1791 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Avalon Project: Jefferson's Opinion on the Constitutionality of a National Bank (opens in a new tab)
forty-for-one revaluationMoney
On 18 March 1780 Congress valued its depreciated Continental paper money at forty dollars to one silver dollar, and called in the old bills in exchange for a new issue backed by the states. The scheme collapsed within about a year as the paper went on falling.
Sources: University of Notre Dame, Colonial Currency: Devaluation of Continental currency (opens in a new tab); Samuel Huntington to Thomas Jefferson, 4 August 1780 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Barton’s life of RittenhouseBook or text
William Barton (1754–1817), Rittenhouse’s nephew, published Memoirs of the Life of David Rittenhouse at Philadelphia in 1813. Rittenhouse (1732–1796) was a clockmaker, astronomer and instrument maker, famous for his orrery, a working model of the solar system, and he succeeded Franklin as president of the American Philosophical Society.
Sources: Wythepedia: Memoirs of the Life of David Rittenhouse (opens in a new tab); Monticello: David Rittenhouse (opens in a new tab)
MonticelloPlace
Jefferson’s mountaintop house and plantation near Charlottesville in Albemarle County, Virginia. He lived there in retirement after leaving the presidency in 1809, and wrote this letter from there.
Adams’s letter of 25 DecemberCross-reference
Adams’s short letter of 25 December 1813 told Jefferson to answer whenever he liked and not to worry, because Adams wrote mainly as a refuge from boredom.
Adams to Jefferson, December 25, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 25 December 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the unanswered Adams lettersCross-reference
Jefferson lists six Adams letters he has not yet answered, written between 12 November and 25 December 1813. The correspondence has no Adams letter of 16 November. The third date is evidently a slip for 15 November, the letter Jefferson cites correctly later in this letter and returns in his postscript.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Taylor’s InquiryBook or text
John Taylor of Caroline (1753–1824) was a Virginia planter, sometime senator and Republican political writer. His long book An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United States came out at Fredericksburg in 1814. It was written largely as a rebuttal of the political theory in Adams’s Defense of the Constitutions.
Sources: Library of Virginia, Virginia Imprints: An inquiry into the principles and policy of the government of the United States (1814) (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: John Taylor (opens in a new tab)
AratorBook or text
Taylor’s Arator, a series of essays on farming laced with political argument, first appeared as a book at Georgetown in 1813. Jefferson had ordered a copy that year, so he already knew Taylor’s prose.
Goethe’s SchriftenBook or text
These are the collected Schriften (‘Writings’) of Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, which Adams asked about in his letter of 14 November 1813. They included Goethe’s 1773 essay arguing that the commandments cut on Moses’ stone tablets were the covenant laws of Exodus 34, not the familiar ten of Exodus 20. In the original the title appears as ‘Goethens Schoristen’.
Adams to Jefferson, November 14, 1813
Sources: From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 14 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Concordia Theological Monthly, vol. 9 (on Goethe and the Decalogue) (opens in a new tab)
diamonds and dunghillsCross-reference
Jefferson had used the same image in his letter of 12 October 1813. There he described how easily the genuine sayings of Jesus, which he had cut out of the Gospels for his own use, could be told apart from the surrounding material.
Vives and BudaeusPerson
Juan Luis Vives (1493–1540) was a Spanish humanist, and Guillaume Budé, Latinized as Budaeus (1467–1540), was France’s foremost classical scholar. Adams’s letter of 3 December 1813 had named them with Erasmus and passed on complaints that the lives of the saints were written with less care than the lives of philosophers.
Adams to Jefferson, December 3, 1813
Sources: Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Juan Luis Vives (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: Guillaume Budé (opens in a new tab)
Alfred’s law codeLaw and politics
Alfred the Great, king of Wessex (871–899), issued an Old English law book, the domboc, late in his reign. It opens with a long prologue rendering the Ten Commandments and much of Exodus 21–23. Modern scholars treat that prologue as Alfred’s own work, not the later insertion Jefferson believed it to be.
Sources: Historical Society of the New York Courts: The Anglo-Saxon Dooms, Part 2, Dooms of the Kingdom of Wessex (opens in a new tab); Jurasinski and Oliver, The Laws of Alfred (Cambridge University Press), excerpt (opens in a new tab)
the Year BooksBook or text
The Year Books were reports of arguments in the medieval English royal courts, written in Law French. The citation points to the volume for the 34th year of Henry VI’s reign (1455–56), leaf 38.
Source: Boston University School of Law: Legal History, The Year Books (Seipp's index) (opens in a new tab)
Sir John PrisotPerson
Sir John Prisot (died about 1460) was Chief Justice of the Court of Common Pleas from 1449. His remark in this case about a church patronage dispute is the first link in the chain of legal authorities Jefferson traces through the rest of the paragraph.
Sources: Dictionary of National Biography (1885–1900): Prisot, John (opens in a new tab); Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 10 February 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Prisot’s words in Law FrenchLanguage
Law French was the Norman-derived French used in English courts. Roughly: ‘To such laws as they of Holy Church have in ancient writing, it is fitting that we give credence, for that is common law, on which all kinds of law are founded; and also, Sir, we are bound to take notice of their law of Holy Church.’
Source: Thomas Jefferson to Thomas Cooper, 10 February 1814 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Finch’s LawBook or text
Sir Henry Finch (died 1625) was a serjeant-at-law whose treatise Nomotechnia (1613, in Law French) appeared in his own English version as Law, or a Discourse Thereof (1627). Jefferson cites book 1, chapter 3.
Source: Folger Shakespeare Library catalog: Finch, Law, or, a discourse thereof (1627) (opens in a new tab)
Edmund WingatePerson
Edmund Wingate (1596–1656) was a mathematician and lawyer. His Maximes of Reason, or the Reason of the Common Law of England, a collection of 214 legal maxims with commentary, was published after his death in 1658.
Source: Wythepedia (William & Mary Law Library): Maximes of Reason (opens in a new tab)
William SheppardPerson
William Sheppard (died about 1675) was a prolific legal writer. His Grand Abridgment of the Common and Statute Law of England (1675) arranged the law alphabetically under headings. Jefferson cites the heading (‘title’) ‘Religion’.
Sources: University of Virginia Law Library catalogue: Sheppard's Abridgment, London, 1675 (opens in a new tab); Lexicons of Early Modern English: William Sheppard, A Grand Abridgement (1675) (opens in a new tab)
Taylor’s CaseEvent
In this blasphemy case of 1676 (some reports say 1675), Sir Matthew Hale, Chief Justice of King’s Bench, punished John Taylor for scurrilous words against Christ and religion. It is often called the first reported common-law blasphemy case. ‘Ventr.’ and ‘Keb.’ are the law reports of Ventris and Keble.
Hale and the Bury witchesEvent
In March 1662 at Bury St Edmunds, Hale presided at the trial of Rose Cullender and Amy Denny, two widows from Lowestoft accused of bewitching children. They were convicted and hanged.
Woolston’s caseEvent
Thomas Woolston, an unorthodox English clergyman, argued in his Six Discourses on the Miracles of Our Saviour (1727–29) that Christ’s miracles should be read only as allegories. He was convicted of blasphemy in 1729, fined and imprisoned, and he died in custody. ‘Stra.’ refers to Sir John Strange’s law reports.
Source: Encyclopedia.com: Woolston, Thomas (opens in a new tab)
Thomas WoodPerson
Thomas Wood (1661–1722) wrote An Institute of the Laws of England (1720). It was a standard students’ guide to English law before Blackstone’s Commentaries and went through ten editions. Jefferson cites its page 409.
Source: Wellcome Collection catalog: Wood, An institute of the laws of England (1720) (opens in a new tab)
the Evans caseEvent
The City of London tried to fine Allen Evans, a Protestant Dissenter, for refusing the office of sheriff, which as a non-Anglican he could not lawfully hold. In 1767 the House of Lords unanimously upheld judgment for Evans. Lord Mansfield’s speech in the case became known as a defense of toleration for Dissenters.
Connecticut blue lawsLaw and politics
The strict moral codes of colonial Connecticut and New Haven, which leaned heavily on Scripture. The name and the most lurid list of these laws came from the loyalist clergyman Samuel Peters’s General History of Connecticut (London, 1781), much of which was invented.
Sources: ConnecticutHistory.org: The Long, Ambiguous History of Connecticut's Blue Laws (opens in a new tab); Encyclopaedia Britannica: blue law (opens in a new tab)
John Marshall and the Burr trialPerson
John Marshall, a Federalist, was Chief Justice of the United States from 1801 and a long-standing political opponent of Jefferson. At Aaron Burr’s treason trial in Richmond in 1807 he ruled that the prosecution had to prove Burr took part in an overt act of war. The jury acquitted Burr on 1 September 1807.
Sources: Constitution Annotated (Cornell LII): Trial of Aaron Burr (opens in a new tab); Federal Judicial Center: The Burr Treason Trial (opens in a new tab)
Virginia Statute for Religious FreedomLaw and politics
This was Jefferson’s own bill, drafted in 1777 and adopted by the Virginia General Assembly on 16 January 1786. It barred the state from compelling worship or support of any church, and from penalizing anyone for religious opinions.
‘Woe unto you, ye lawyers’Quotation
These are the words of Jesus in Luke 11:46 (King James Version), spoken against experts in the religious law. Jesus is the person Jefferson calls ‘all candor and benevolence’.
Source: Luke 11:46, King James Version (Bible Gateway) (opens in a new tab)
Priestley’s Doctrines of Heathen PhilosophyBook or text
Joseph Priestley’s The Doctrines of Heathen Philosophy, Compared with Those of Revelation was printed at Northumberland, Pennsylvania, in 1804, after his death that year. Adams’s letter of 25 December 1813 had faulted its thin treatment of the Pythagoreans.
William EnfieldPerson
William Enfield (1741–1797) was an English Dissenting minister. His two-volume History of Philosophy (London, 1791) condensed Brucker’s Latin history and remained the standard English survey for decades.
Brucker’s Historia critica philosophiaeBook or text
Johann Jakob Brucker (1696–1770) was a German Lutheran scholar. His Historia critica philosophiae, a vast critical history of philosophy in Latin, was published in quarto volumes at Leipzig in 1742–44, with a further volume in 1767. It was the leading history of philosophy before Kant.
Source: Wellcome Collection catalog: Brucker, Historia critica philosophiae (opens in a new tab)
d’Argens’s Ocellus LucanusBook or text
Ocellus Lucanus was an early Pythagorean philosopher. The treatise on the eternal universe that bears his name is now judged a much later forgery. The Marquis d’Argens published its Greek text with a French translation and long commentary in 1762, which Adams praised on 25 December 1813. Abbé Charles Batteux’s rival translation followed in 1768.
Adams to Jefferson, December 25, 1813
Sources: Sowerby, Catalogue of the Library of Thomas Jefferson, vol. 2, p. 26 (Monticello) (opens in a new tab); Kathleen Freeman, Ancilla to the Pre-Socratic Philosophers: Ocellus (opens in a new tab)
old Massachusetts familiesCross-reference
In his letter of 15 November 1813 Adams wrote that Massachusetts still honored its old families, such as the Winthrops, Winslows, Bradfords, Saltonstalls and Quincys, for their names and connections.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: The Founders' Constitution: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (opens in a new tab)
Adams’s bank proposalCross-reference
In his letter of 15 November 1813 Adams recalled proposing, at his table in Philadelphia, a constitutional amendment forbidding the states to create banks. Congress would instead charter a single national bank, with branches in each state and capital capped at ten million dollars. Adams said Jefferson had rejected the idea.
Adams to Jefferson, November 15, 1813
Source: The Founders' Constitution: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 November 1813 (opens in a new tab)
first Bank of the United StatesEvent
The first national bank was proposed by Alexander Hamilton and chartered by Congress in February 1791. Jefferson, then Secretary of State, advised Washington in writing that Congress had no constitutional power to create it. The bank’s twenty-year charter lapsed in 1811.
Sources: Jefferson's Opinion on the Constitutionality of a National Bank, 15 February 1791 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Avalon Project: Jefferson's Opinion on the Constitutionality of a National Bank (opens in a new tab)
forty-for-one revaluationMoney
On 18 March 1780 Congress valued its depreciated Continental paper money at forty dollars to one silver dollar, and called in the old bills in exchange for a new issue backed by the states. The scheme collapsed within about a year as the paper went on falling.
Sources: University of Notre Dame, Colonial Currency: Devaluation of Continental currency (opens in a new tab); Samuel Huntington to Thomas Jefferson, 4 August 1780 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Barton’s life of RittenhouseBook or text
William Barton (1754–1817), Rittenhouse’s nephew, published Memoirs of the Life of David Rittenhouse at Philadelphia in 1813. Rittenhouse (1732–1796) was a clockmaker, astronomer and instrument maker, famous for his orrery, a working model of the solar system, and he succeeded Franklin as president of the American Philosophical Society.
Sources: Wythepedia: Memoirs of the Life of David Rittenhouse (opens in a new tab); Monticello: David Rittenhouse (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 24 January 1814 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-07-02-0083
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of November 6, 2025. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 24 January 1814. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-07-02-0083. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1814-01-24-jefferson-to-adams/.