Jefferson to Adams
Jefferson on the natural aristocracy
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams
Jefferson answers Adams on Theognis and aristocracy. He separates a natural aristocracy of virtue and talents from an artificial one of wealth and birth, and argues that free elections and public schooling, not a separate senate, best tell the two apart.
- From
- Monticello, Virginia
- Period
- The Reconciliation, 1812–1826
- Length
- 2,542 words · 13 min read
The letter
Monticello, October 28, 1813
Monticello Oct. 28. 13.
Dear Sir,
Dear Sir
The passage you quote from Theognis33 has, I think, a moral rather than a political purpose. The whole piece is a moral exhortation, a paraenesis,44 and this passage in particular seems to rebuke man. With his domestic animals he takes care to improve the breed by always using the finest male, yet he pays no attention to improving his own race, and marries the vicious, the ugly or the old for the sake of wealth or ambition. It agrees with the principle the Pythagoreans adopted later, which Ocellus55 expressed in another form: “Concerning the begetting of men from one another, and so on—the union is not for the sake of pleasure.” As literally as sense allows, this may be translated as follows: “Concerning the procreation of men with one another, how and from whom it should take place, in a perfect manner and according to the laws of modesty and holiness, together, this is what I think right. First, we lay it down that we do not unite for the sake of pleasure, but for the procreation of children. For the powers, the organs and the desires for intercourse have not been given by God to man for the sake of pleasure, but for the procreation of the race. For since it would be unfitting for a mortal-born being to share in the divine life, the immortality of the race being taken away, God fulfilled that purpose by making the generations unbroken and continuous. This, therefore, we must lay down above all as a principle: that intercourse is not for the sake of pleasure.” But Nature, not trusting to this moral and abstract motive, seems to have made the survival of the species more secure by making it the effect of the sexual urge planted in the makeup of both sexes. And not only has love-making been indulged on this unholy impulse, but it has also been made to serve wealth and ambition, through marriages made without regard to the beauty, the health, the understanding or the virtue of the partner from whom we are to breed. Selecting the best male for a harem of well-chosen females, which Theognis seems to recommend from the example of our sheep and donkeys, would no doubt improve the human animal as it does the brute, and produce a race of true aristoi.69 For experience proves that the moral and physical qualities of man, whether good or evil, pass to a certain degree from father to son. But I suspect that the equal rights of men will rise up against this privileged Solomon,710 and oblige us to go on putting up with the dimming of the citizens’ stock811 that Theognis complains of, and to content ourselves with the accidental aristoi produced by the chance meeting of breeders. For I agree with you that there is a natural aristocracy among men. Its grounds are virtue and talents. Formerly bodily strength gave a man a place among the aristoi. But since the invention of gunpowder has armed the weak as well as the strong with death that strikes from a distance, bodily strength, like beauty, good humor, politeness and other accomplishments, has become only a secondary ground of distinction. There is also an artificial aristocracy, founded on wealth and birth, without either virtue or talents; for if it had these, it would belong to the first class. I consider the natural aristocracy the most precious gift of nature for the instruction, the trusts and the government of society. And indeed it would have been inconsistent in creation to have formed man for life in society and not to have provided virtue and wisdom enough to manage the concerns of that society. May we not even say that the best form of government is the one that provides most effectively for a pure selection of these natural aristoi into the offices of government? The artificial aristocracy is a harmful ingredient in government, and provision should be made to keep it from gaining the upper hand. On the question of what the best provision is, you and I differ; but we differ as rational friends, each using his own reason freely and each indulging the other’s errors. You think it best to put the pseudo-aristoi into a separate chamber of the legislature,912 where the branches alongside it can keep them from doing harm, and where they may also protect wealth against the agrarian1013 and plundering schemes of the majority of the people. I think that to give them power in order to keep them from doing harm is to arm them for it, and to increase the evil instead of curing it. For if the coordinate branches can stop their action, they can just as well stop the action of the coordinate branches. Harm may be done by blocking as well as by acting. A cabal in the Senate of the United States1114 has given many proofs of this. Nor do I believe they are needed to protect the wealthy, because enough of the wealthy will find their way into every branch of the legislature to protect themselves. Fifteen to twenty legislatures of our own, at work for the past thirty years, have proved that we need fear no equalizing of property from them. I think the best remedy is exactly the one all our constitutions provide: to leave the citizens free to elect, and to separate the aristoi from the pseudo-aristoi, the wheat from the chaff. In general they will elect the truly good and wise. In some cases wealth may corrupt them and birth blind them, but not enough to endanger society.
The passage you quote from Theognis3, I think has an Ethical, rather than a political object. the whole piece is a moral exhortation, παραινεςις4, and this passage particularly seems to be a reproof to man, who, while with his domestic animals he is curious to improve the race by employing always the finest male, pays no attention to the improvement of his own race, but intermarries with the vicious, the ugly, or the old, for considerations of wealth or ambition. it is in conformity with the principle adopted afterwards by the Pythagoreans, and expressed by Ocellus5 in another form. ‘περι δε της εκ των αλληλων ανθρωπων γενεςεως Etc—ουχ ἡδονης ἑνεκα ἡ μιξις.’ which, as literally as intelligibility will admit, may be thus translated. ‘concerning the interprocreation of men, how, and of whom it shall be, in a perfect manner, and according to the laws of modesty and sanctity, conjointly, this is what I think right. first to lay it down that we do not commix for the sake of pleasure, but of the procreation of children. for the powers, the organs and desires for coition have not been given by god to man for the sake of pleasure, but for the procreation of the race. for as it were incongruous for a mortal born to partake of divine life, the immortality of the race being taken away, god fulfilled the purpose by making the generations uninterrupted and continuous. this therefore we are especially to lay down as a principle, that coition is not for the sake of pleasure.’ but Nature, not trusting to this moral and abstract motive, seems to have provided more securely for the perpetuation of the species by making it the effect of the oestrum6 implanted in the constitution of both sexes. and not only has the commerce of love7 been indulged on this unhallowed impulse, but made subservient also to wealth and ambition by marriages without regard to the beauty, the healthiness, the understanding, or virtue of the subject from which we are to breed. the selecting the best male for a Haram8 of well chosen females also, which Theognis seems to recommend from the example of our sheep and asses, would doubtless improve the human, as it does the brute animal, and produce a race of veritable αρiςτοι9. for experience proves that the moral and physical qualities of man, whether good or evil, are transmissible in a certain degree from father to son. but I suspect that the equal rights of men will rise up against this privileged Solomon10, and oblige us to continue acquiescence under the ‘Αμαυρωςις γενεος αςτων11’ which Theognis complains of, and to content ourselves with the accidental aristoi produced by the fortuitous concourse of breeders. for I agree with you that there is a natural aristocracy among men. the grounds of this are virtue & talents. formerly bodily powers gave place among the aristoi. but since the invention of gunpowder has armed the weak as well as the strong with missile death, bodily strength, like beauty, good humor, politeness and other accomplishments, has become but an auxiliary ground of distinction. there is also an artificial aristocracy founded on wealth and birth, without either virtue or talents; for with these it would belong to the first class. the natural aristocracy I consider as the most precious gift of nature, for the instruction, the trusts, and government of society. and indeed it would have been inconsistent in creation to have formed man for the social state, and not to have provided virtue and wisdom enough to manage the concerns of the society. may we not even say that that form of government is the best which provides the most effectually for a pure selection of these natural aristoi into the offices of government? the artificial aristocracy is a mischievous ingredient in government, and provision should be made to prevent it’s ascendancy. on the question, What is the best provision? you and I differ; but we differ as rational friends, using the free exercise of our own reason, and mutually indulging it’s errors. you think it best to put the Pseudo-aristoi into a separate chamber of legislation12 where they may be hindered from doing mischief by their coordinate branches, and where also they may be a protection to wealth against the Agrarian13 and plundering enterprises of the Majority of the people. I think that to give them power in order to prevent them from doing mischief, is arming them for it, and increasing instead of remedying the evil. for if the coordinate branches can arrest their action, so may they that of the coordinates. mischief may be done negatively as well as positively. of this a cabal in the Senate14 of the US. has furnished many proofs. nor do I believe them necessary to protect the wealthy; because enough of these will find their way into every branch of the legislature to protect themselves. from 15. to 20. legislatures of our own, in action for 30. years past, have proved that no fears of an equalisation of property are to be apprehended from them. I think the best remedy is exactly that provided by all our constitutions, to leave to the citizens the free election and separation of the aristoi from the pseudo-aristoi, of the wheat from the chaff. in general they will elect the real good and wise. in some instances, wealth may corrupt, and birth blind them; but not in sufficient degree to endanger the society.
Our difference of opinion is probably caused in some measure by a difference of character in the people among whom we live. From what I have seen of Massachusetts and Connecticut myself, and still more from what I have heard, and from the character you yourself have given of the former [vol. 1, p. 111],1215 you who know them so much better, there seems to be in those two states a traditional reverence for certain families, which has made the offices of government nearly hereditary in those families. I presume that from an early period of your history, members of these families who happened to have virtue and talents used them honestly for the good of the people, and by their services endeared their names to them. In coupling Connecticut with you, I mean it only politically, not morally. For having made the Bible the common law1316 of their land, they seem to have modeled their morality on the story of Jacob and Laban.1417 But although this hereditary succession to office among you may rest to some degree on real family merit, it has come in a much higher degree from your strict alliance of church and state.1518 These families are made saints in the eyes of the people on the common principle, “You tickle me, and I will tickle you.” In Virginia we have nothing of the kind. Our clergy before the Revolution, secured against rivals by fixed salaries,1619 did not take the trouble to gain influence over the people. As for wealth, great fortunes had piled up in particular families, handed down from generation to generation under the English law of entails. But the only object of ambition for the wealthy was a seat in the king’s council.1720 All their court, then, was paid to the Crown and its creatures, and in every clash between the king and the people they philippized.1821 So they were unpopular, and that unpopularity still clings to their names. A Randolph, a Carter or a Burwell1922 must have great superiority of merit over an ordinary rival to be elected by the people, even today. At the first session of our legislature after the Declaration of Independence, we passed a law abolishing entails.2023 This was followed by one abolishing the privilege of primogeniture,2124 and dividing the lands of those who die without a will equally among all their children or other heirs. These laws, which I drafted myself, laid the axe to the root of pseudo-aristocracy. And if the legislature had adopted another that I prepared, our work would have been complete. It was a Bill for the More General Diffusion of Learning.2225 It proposed to divide every county into wards five or six miles square, like your townships; to set up in each ward a free school for reading, writing and common arithmetic; to provide for choosing each year the best pupils from these schools, who might receive a higher education at public expense in a district school; and from these district schools to choose a certain number of the most promising pupils to complete their education at a university, where all the useful sciences would be taught. Worth and genius would thus have been sought out in every condition of life, and fully prepared by education to defeat the competition of wealth and birth for public trusts. My proposal had a further aim: to give these wards the share of self-government they are best fitted for, by entrusting to them the care of their poor, their roads, police, elections, the nomination of jurors, the administration of justice in small cases, and elementary militia drill. In short, it would have made them little republics, each with a Warden at its head, for all those concerns which, being under their own eye, they would manage better than the larger republics of the county or the state. A general call of ward meetings by their Wardens on the same day throughout the state would at any time produce the true sense of the people on any point required, and would enable the state to act as one body, as your people have so often done, and to such effect, through their town meetings. The law for religious freedom,2326 which was part of this system, had put down the aristocracy of the clergy and restored to the citizen the freedom of the mind, and the laws on entails and inheritance were nurturing an equality of condition among the citizens. This law on education would have raised the mass of the people to the high ground of moral respectability necessary to their own safety and to orderly government. It would have completed the great work of fitting them to select the true aristoi for the trusts of government, and to shut out the pseudo-aristocrats. And the same Theognis who supplied the epigraphs of your two letters assures us: Good men, Cyrnus, have never yet destroyed a city.2427 Although this law has so far been acted on only to a small and ineffective degree, it is still considered to be before the legislature, along with other bills of the revised code2528 not yet taken up. And I have great hope that some patriotic spirit will, at a favorable moment, bring it up and make it the keystone of the arch of our government.
It is probable that our difference of opinion may in some measure be produced by a difference of character in those among whom we live. from what I have seen of Massachusets and Connecticut myself, and still more from what I have heard, and the character given of the former by yourself, [vol. 1. pa. 111.15] who know them so much better, there seems to be in those two states a traditionary reverence for certain families, which has rendered the offices of the government nearly hereditary in those families. I presume that from an early period of your history, members of these families happening to possess virtue and talents, have honestly exercised them for the good of the people, and by their services have endeared their names to them. in coupling Connecticut with you, I mean it politically only, not morally. for having made the Bible the Common law16 of their land they seem to have modelled their morality on the story of Jacob and Laban17. but altho’ this hereditary succession to office with you may in some degree be founded in real family merit, yet in a much higher degree it has proceeded from your strict alliance of church and state18. these families are canonised in the eyes of the people on the common principle ‘you tickle me, and I will tickle you.’ in Virginia we have nothing of this. our clergy, before the revolution, having been secured against rivalship by fixed salaries19, did not give themselves the trouble of acquiring influence over the people. of wealth, there were great accumulations in particular families, handed down from generation to generation under the English law of entails. but the only object of ambition for the wealthy was a seat in the king’s council20. all their court then was paid to the crown and it’s creatures; and they Philipised21 in all collisions between the king & people. hence they were unpopular; and that unpopularity continues attached to their names. a Randolph, a Carter, or a Burwell22 must have great personal superiority over a common competitor to be elected by the people, even at this day. at the first session of our legislature after the Declaration of Independance, we passed a law abolishing entails23. and this was followed by one abolishing the privilege of Primogeniture24, and dividing the lands of intestates equally among all their children, or other representatives. these laws, drawn by myself, laid the axe to the root of Pseudo-aristocracy. and had another which I prepared been adopted by the legislature, our work would have been compleat. it was a Bill for the more general diffusion of learning25. this proposed to divide every county into wards of 5. or 6. miles square, like your townships; to establish in each ward a free school for reading, writing and common arithmetic; to provide for the annual selection of the best subjects from these schools who might recieve at the public expence a higher degree of education at a district school; and from these district schools to select a certain number of the most promising subjects to be compleated at an University, where all the useful sciences should be taught. worth and genius would thus have been sought out from every condition of life, and compleatly prepared by education for defeating the competition of wealth & birth for public trusts. my proposition had for a further object to impart to these wards those portions of self-government for which they are best qualified, by confiding to them the care of their poor, their roads, police, elections, the nomination of jurors, administration of justice in small cases, elementary exercises of militia, in short, to have made them little republics, with a Warden at the head of each, for all those concerns which, being under their eye, they would better manage than the larger republics of the county or state. a general call of ward-meetings by their Wardens on the same day thro’ the state would at any time produce the genuine sense of the people on any required point, and would enable the state to act in mass, as your people have so often done, and with so much effect, by their town-meetings. the law for religious freedom26, which made a part of this system, having put down the aristocracy of the clergy, and restored to the citizen the freedom of the mind, and those of entails and descents nurturing an equality of condition among them, this on Education would have raised the mass of the people to the high ground of moral respectability necessary to their own safety, & to orderly government; and would have compleated the great object of qualifying them to select the veritable aristoi, for the trusts of government, to the exclusion of the Pseudalists: and the same Theognis who has furnished the epigraphs of your two letters assures us that ‘Ουδεμιαν πω, Κυρν’, αγαθοι πολιν ωλεςαν ανδρες27.’ altho’ this law has not yet been acted on but in a small and inefficient degree, it is still considered as before the legislature, with other bills of the revised code28, not yet taken up, and I have great hope that some patriotic spirit will, at a favorable moment, call it up, and make it the key-stone of the arch of our government.
As to aristocracy, we should also consider that before the American states were established, history knew nothing but the man of the Old World, crowded within limits either small or overfilled, and steeped in the vices that such a situation breeds. A government suited to such men would be one thing; a government for the man of these states would be a very different one. Here everyone may have land to work for himself if he chooses; or, if he prefers some other occupation, he may demand such pay for it as will not only give him a comfortable living but also let him provide for rest from labor in old age. Everyone, through his property or his satisfactory situation, has a stake in upholding law and order. And such men may safely and usefully keep for themselves a healthy control over their public affairs, and a degree of freedom which, in the hands of the rabble of the cities of Europe, would at once be turned to the demolition and destruction of everything public and private. The history of the last twenty-five years in France, and of the last forty years in America—indeed, of its last two hundred years—proves the truth of both parts of this observation.
With respect to Aristocracy we should further consider that, before the establishment of the American states, nothing was known to History but the Man of the old world, crouded within limits either small or overcharged, and steeped in the vices which that situation generates. a government adapted to such men would be one thing; but a very different one that for the Man of these states. here every one may have land to labor for himself if he chuses; or, preferring the exercise of any other industry, may exact for it such compensation as not only to afford a comfortable subsistence, but wherewith to provide for a cessation from labor in old age. every one, by his property, or by his satisfactory situation, is interested in the support of law and order. and such men may safely and advantageously reserve to themselves a wholsome controul over their public affairs, and a degree of freedom, which in the hands of the Canaille29 of the cities of Europe, would be instantly perverted to the demolition and destruction of every thing public and private. the history of the last 25. years of France, and of the last 40. years in America, nay of it’s last 200. years, proves the truth of both parts of this observation.
But even in Europe a change has noticeably taken place in the mind of man. Science had freed the ideas of those who read and reflect, and the American example had kindled in the people a feeling for their rights. Consequently, an insurrection of science, talent and courage has begun2631 against rank and birth, which have fallen into contempt. It has failed in its first attempt, because the city mobs, the instrument used to carry it out, were degraded by ignorance, poverty and vice, and could not be held to rational action. But the world will recover from the panic of this first catastrophe. Science is progressive, and talent and enterprise are on the alert. Recourse may be had to the people of the countryside, a more governable force because of their principles and their habits of subordination; and rank and birth and tinsel aristocracy will at last shrink into insignificance even there. This, however, we have no right to meddle with. It is enough for us if the moral and physical condition of our own citizens fits them to choose the able and good to direct their government, with elections coming round at such short intervals that they can remove an unfaithful servant before the harm he plans becomes beyond repair.
But even in Europe a change has sensibly30 taken place in the mind of Man. science had liberated the ideas of those who read and reflect, and the American example had kindled feelings of right in the people. an insurrection has consequently begun31, of science, talents & courage against rank and birth, which have fallen into contempt. it has failed in it’s first effort, because the mobs of the cities, the instrument used for it’s accomplishment, debased by ignorance, poverty and vice, could not be restrained to rational action. but the world will recover from the panic of this first catastrophe. science is progressive, and talents and enterprize on the alert. resort may be had to the people of the country, a more governable power from their principles & subordination; and rank and birth and tinsel-aristocracy will finally shrink into insignificance even there. this however we have no right to meddle with. it suffices for us, if the moral & physical condition of our own citizens qualifies them to select the able and good for the direction of their government, with a recurrence of elections at such short periods as will enable them to displace an unfaithful servant before the mischief he meditates may be irremediable.
I have set out my opinion on a point where we differ, not with a view to controversy, for we are both too old to change opinions that are the fruit of a long life of inquiry and reflection, but because a former letter of yours2732 suggested that we ought not to die before we have explained ourselves to each other. We acted in perfect harmony through a long and perilous struggle for our liberty and independence. We have gained a constitution which, though neither of us thinks it perfect, both of us consider able to make our fellow citizens the happiest and the most secure on whom the sun has ever shone. If we do not think exactly alike about its imperfections, it matters little to our country. After devoting long lives of unselfish labor to it, we have handed it over to those who follow us in life, and they will be able to take care of it, and of themselves.
I have thus stated my opinion on a point on which we differ, not with a view to controversy, for we are both too old to change opinions which are the result of a long life of enquiry and reflection; but on the suggestion of a former letter of yours32 that we ought not to die before we have explained ourselves to each other. we acted in perfect harmony thro’ a long and perilous contest for our liberty and independance. a constitution has been acquired which, tho neither of us think perfect, yet both consider as competent to render our fellow-citizens the happiest and the securest on whom the sun has ever shone. if we do not think exactly alike as to it’s imperfections, it matters little to our country which, after devoting to it long lives of disinterested33 labor, we have delivered over to our successors in life, who will be able to take care of it, and of themselves.
Of the pamphlet on aristocracy2834 that has been sent to you, or of who its author may be, I have heard nothing except through your letter. If it is the person you suspect,2935 he may be known by the odd, mystical and exaggerated ideas, wrapped in affected, newfangled and pedantic terms, that stamp his writings. Whatever it may be, I hope your peace is not to be disturbed at this late day by the rudeness or the excesses of scribblers, but that you may go on living in tranquility and rejoicing in the prosperity of our country until it is your own wish to take your seat among the aristoi who have gone before you. Ever and affectionately yours,
Of the pamphlet on aristocracy34 which has been sent to you, or who may be it’s author, I have heard nothing but thro’ your letter. if the person you suspect35 it may be known from the quaint, mystical and hyperbolical ideas, involved in affected, new-fangled and pedantic terms, which stamp his writings. whatever it be, I hope your quiet is not to be affected at this day by the rudeness or intemperance of scribblers; but that you may continue in tranquility to live and to rejoice in the prosperity of our country until it shall be your own wish to take your seat among the Aristoi who have gone before you. ever and affectionately yours.
Th. Jefferson
Th: Jefferson
Postscript
Notes3036
your letter of Aug. 16Cross-reference
Adams’s letter begun about 14 August 1813 and finished with a postscript of 16 August, which Jefferson filed under the later date. It quoted Theognis on how men breed their animals with care but marry for money.
your letter of Sep. 2Cross-reference
Adams’s letter of 2 September 1813, which opened with another Greek couplet from Theognis and pressed Jefferson on who the aristoi, the ‘best’ people, really are.
Adams to Jefferson, September 2, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 2 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
TheognisPerson
Greek elegiac poet of Megara, active in the mid-sixth century BC. About 1,400 lines of moral and political advice survive under his name, many addressed to a young man, Cyrnus. He held that virtue is inherited and scorned the newly rich, which made him apt for a debate on aristocracy.
Source: Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
paraenesisLanguage
Greek for ‘exhortation’ or ‘advice’. Adams had taken his lines from an edition titled ‘The Advice (Paraineseis) of Theognis of Megara’, so Jefferson is classing the poem as moral counsel rather than political theory.
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 16 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Ocellus LucanusPerson
A supposed Pythagorean philosopher of Lucania in southern Italy. The short treatise ‘On the Nature of the Universe’ that Jefferson translates from goes under his name, but modern scholars regard it as a forgery written no earlier than the first century BC. Its last chapter deals with marriage and procreation.
Sources: Ocellus Lucanus, Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), via Wikisource (opens in a new tab); Ocellus Lucanus on the Nature of the Universe, trans. Thomas Taylor (Project Gutenberg) (opens in a new tab)
aristoiLanguage
Greek for ‘the best’, the root of ‘aristocracy’. In these letters Adams and Jefferson use the word for people of real merit, as opposed to people with only money or family name.
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 2 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
privileged SolomonBook or text
In 1 Kings 11:3, King Solomon keeps seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines. Jefferson uses his name for the one chosen male who would father the race under a Theognis-style breeding plan.
Source: 1 Kings 11 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
Amaurosis geneos astonLanguage
Greek, roughly ‘the dimming of the citizens’ stock’. Jefferson turns into a noun the complaint in the Theognis passage Adams had quoted: good families decline when nobles marry low-born partners for money.
Sources: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 16 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a separate chamber for the aristoiIdea
This is Adams’s theory of a balanced constitution, set out in his Defense of the Constitutions (1787–88). The rich and well-born would be gathered in a senate, where a popular house and a strong executive could watch and check them.
AgrarianIdea
The word comes from Rome’s agrarian laws, above all the land reform of Tiberius Gracchus, which took public land the great landholders had seized and handed it out to poor citizens. ‘Agrarian’ schemes therefore meant levelling property by taking it from the rich.
Source: Agrarian law, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a cabal in the SenateEvent
Probably the ‘Invisibles’, a faction of Republican senators led by Samuel Smith of Maryland and including William Branch Giles of Virginia. They obstructed Madison’s administration and in 1809 blocked Albert Gallatin’s nomination as secretary of state. Jefferson names no one, so the identification is not certain.
Sources: Macon and the Invisibles, NCpedia / North Carolina History (opens in a new tab); William Branch Giles, U.S. Senate featured biography (opens in a new tab)
vol. 1, p. 111Book or text
Jefferson’s bracketed page reference is to the first volume of Adams’s Defense of the Constitutions, printed in London in 1787. That is where, Jefferson says, Adams had described the political character of Massachusetts.
the Bible as Connecticut’s lawLaw and politics
Connecticut’s early codes, including the capital laws of 1642 and Roger Ludlow’s code of 1650, justified many offenses, especially capital ones, by citing Old Testament verses in the margin. In practice English law was also a major model.
Sources: Capitall Lawes of Connecticut (Teaching American History) (opens in a new tab); The Code of 1650 (Connecticut General Assembly) (opens in a new tab)
Jacob and LabanBook or text
In Genesis 29–31, Laban tricks his nephew Jacob into marrying the wrong daughter and keeps changing his wages. Jacob then outwits him by breeding the speckled flocks that their bargain gave him. The allusion points to sharp dealing on both sides.
Source: Genesis 29–31 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
church and state in New EnglandCustom
Massachusetts and Connecticut still supported Congregational churches through public taxes in 1813, a system known as the Standing Order. Connecticut ended it with its 1818 constitution, and Massachusetts in 1833.
fixed salaries of the Virginia clergyCustom
Colonial Virginia’s Church of England ministers were paid by law: a 1748 act set each parish minister’s salary at 16,000 pounds of tobacco a year. Attempts to cut that pay led to the famous ‘Parsons’ Cause’ lawsuits of the 1760s.
Source: Two Penny Acts (1755, 1758), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the king’s councilLaw and politics
The Governor’s Council of colonial Virginia: about a dozen of the colony’s wealthiest planters, appointed by the Crown, who advised the royal governor. Membership was held by a small web of interrelated families.
Source: The Governor's Council, Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
PhilipisedWord
To ‘philippize’ is to speak or act for a power that has corrupted you. The word comes from the charge that the oracle at Delphi gave answers favoring Philip II of Macedon. Here it means the Virginia grandees sided with the Crown.
Source: Philippize, Wordsmith.org (A.Word.A.Day) (opens in a new tab)
Randolph, Carter, BurwellPerson
Three of colonial Virginia’s great planter families. Robert ‘King’ Carter (d. 1732) was among the richest men in British America, and the Burwells, his descendants, held seats on the Governor’s Council. Jefferson’s own mother was a Randolph.
Sources: Robert Carter (ca. 1664–1732), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Lewis Burwell (1711 or 1712–1756), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the law abolishing entailsLaw and politics
An entail bound land, and in Virginia also slaves, to a fixed line of heirs, so no holder could sell or divide it. Jefferson’s act of October 1776 turned all entailed property into ordinary property its owners could sell or bequeath freely.
PrimogenitureLaw and politics
The English rule that a landowner who died without a will left all his land to his eldest son. Virginia replaced it in 1785 with Jefferson’s revisal bill on descents, which divided such estates among all the children. James Madison carried it through the assembly while Jefferson was in France.
Sources: The Revisal of the Laws, 1776–1786, editorial note (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The General Assembly Session of October 1785, editorial note (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the bill on educationLaw and politics
Jefferson’s ‘Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge’, Bill 79 of the revised code. It proposed three years of tax-funded schooling for all free children, girls included. It was presented in 1778 and 1780 but never passed. A much weaker school law of 1796 left action to the county courts and achieved little.
Sources: A Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia (Monticello) (opens in a new tab); 79. A Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the law for religious freedomLaw and politics
The Virginia Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom, drafted by Jefferson in 1777 and adopted in January 1786. It ended state support for the Church of England in Virginia and barred any penalty for a person’s religious beliefs. Jefferson had it listed among his three achievements on his tombstone.
Sources: Virginia Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom (1786), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia (Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
Theognis on good menQuotation
Line 43 of Theognis, addressed to Cyrnus, roughly ‘Good men, Cyrnus, have never yet brought a city to ruin.’ Jefferson answers Adams with the poet Adams himself had quoted.
Source: Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
the revised codeLaw and politics
In 1776 Virginia set up a committee to revise its laws. Jefferson, George Wythe and Edmund Pendleton reported 126 bills in June 1779. Some were enacted in 1779, 1785 and 1786, but the assembly never adopted the code as a whole.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson and George Wythe to Benjamin Harrison, 18 June 1779 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Report of the Committee of Revisors, Wythepedia (William & Mary Law Library) (opens in a new tab)
the insurrection against rank and birthEvent
Probably the French Revolution, which began in 1789 and which Jefferson has just mentioned as the last 25 years of France. Its early reforms against hereditary privilege gave way to Paris crowd violence, the Terror and, by 1813, Napoleon’s empire.
Source: French Revolution, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a former letter of yoursCross-reference
Adams’s letter of 15 July 1813. There he said that he and Jefferson should each set out their views plainly to the other while they still lived.
Adams to Jefferson, July 15, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 July 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the pamphlet on aristocracyBook or text
Adams had received early printed sheets of a long attack on his views of aristocracy. It was published at Fredericksburg in 1814 as ‘An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United States’. In his letter of 15 September 1813 Adams guessed that John Taylor wrote it.
Adams to Jefferson, September 15, 1813
Sources: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Imprint record: Taylor, An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy (1814), Library of Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the person you suspectPerson
John Taylor of Caroline (1753–1824), a Virginia planter, sometime U.S. senator and agrarian Republican writer, known for his farming book ‘Arator’. He was the author of the Inquiry, and Adams later answered it in a long series of letters to him beginning in 1814.
Sources: John Taylor to Thomas Jefferson, 10 July 1816 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to John Taylor, 13 January 1815 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
my letter of Aug. 22Cross-reference
Jefferson’s letter of 22 August 1813 asked Adams who had drafted various petitions and addresses of the Continental Congress. Adams answered on 12 November that he did not know and never had.
Jefferson to Adams, August 22, 1813
Sources: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 22 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 12 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
6 more notes explain words of the original that the modern text does not use. Switch to the original to read them.
your letter of Aug. 16Cross-reference
Adams’s letter begun about 14 August 1813 and finished with a postscript of 16 August, which Jefferson filed under the later date. It quoted Theognis on how men breed their animals with care but marry for money.
your letter of Sep. 2Cross-reference
Adams’s letter of 2 September 1813, which opened with another Greek couplet from Theognis and pressed Jefferson on who the aristoi, the ‘best’ people, really are.
Adams to Jefferson, September 2, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 2 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
TheognisPerson
Greek elegiac poet of Megara, active in the mid-sixth century BC. About 1,400 lines of moral and political advice survive under his name, many addressed to a young man, Cyrnus. He held that virtue is inherited and scorned the newly rich, which made him apt for a debate on aristocracy.
Source: Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
paraenesisLanguage
Greek for ‘exhortation’ or ‘advice’. Adams had taken his lines from an edition titled ‘The Advice (Paraineseis) of Theognis of Megara’, so Jefferson is classing the poem as moral counsel rather than political theory.
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 16 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Ocellus LucanusPerson
A supposed Pythagorean philosopher of Lucania in southern Italy. The short treatise ‘On the Nature of the Universe’ that Jefferson translates from goes under his name, but modern scholars regard it as a forgery written no earlier than the first century BC. Its last chapter deals with marriage and procreation.
Sources: Ocellus Lucanus, Encyclopaedia Britannica (1911), via Wikisource (opens in a new tab); Ocellus Lucanus on the Nature of the Universe, trans. Thomas Taylor (Project Gutenberg) (opens in a new tab)
oestrumWord
From the Latin and Greek word for the gadfly, and so a frenzy. In English it came to mean sexual heat in animals. Jefferson uses it for the sexual urge built into human beings, men and women alike.
Sources: Estrus, Merriam-Webster (opens in a new tab); Estrus, Online Etymology Dictionary (opens in a new tab)
commerceWord
Here ‘commerce’ means sexual relations, an older sense of the word, not trade.
HaramWord
An old spelling of ‘harem’: the women of a household kept apart for one man, or the quarters where they lived.
aristoiLanguage
Greek for ‘the best’, the root of ‘aristocracy’. In these letters Adams and Jefferson use the word for people of real merit, as opposed to people with only money or family name.
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 2 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
privileged SolomonBook or text
In 1 Kings 11:3, King Solomon keeps seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines. Jefferson uses his name for the one chosen male who would father the race under a Theognis-style breeding plan.
Source: 1 Kings 11 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
Amaurosis geneos astonLanguage
Greek, roughly ‘the dimming of the citizens’ stock’. Jefferson turns into a noun the complaint in the Theognis passage Adams had quoted: good families decline when nobles marry low-born partners for money.
Sources: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 16 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a separate chamber for the aristoiIdea
This is Adams’s theory of a balanced constitution, set out in his Defense of the Constitutions (1787–88). The rich and well-born would be gathered in a senate, where a popular house and a strong executive could watch and check them.
AgrarianIdea
The word comes from Rome’s agrarian laws, above all the land reform of Tiberius Gracchus, which took public land the great landholders had seized and handed it out to poor citizens. ‘Agrarian’ schemes therefore meant levelling property by taking it from the rich.
Source: Agrarian law, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a cabal in the SenateEvent
Probably the ‘Invisibles’, a faction of Republican senators led by Samuel Smith of Maryland and including William Branch Giles of Virginia. They obstructed Madison’s administration and in 1809 blocked Albert Gallatin’s nomination as secretary of state. Jefferson names no one, so the identification is not certain.
Sources: Macon and the Invisibles, NCpedia / North Carolina History (opens in a new tab); William Branch Giles, U.S. Senate featured biography (opens in a new tab)
vol. 1, p. 111Book or text
Jefferson’s bracketed page reference is to the first volume of Adams’s Defense of the Constitutions, printed in London in 1787. That is where, Jefferson says, Adams had described the political character of Massachusetts.
the Bible as Connecticut’s lawLaw and politics
Connecticut’s early codes, including the capital laws of 1642 and Roger Ludlow’s code of 1650, justified many offenses, especially capital ones, by citing Old Testament verses in the margin. In practice English law was also a major model.
Sources: Capitall Lawes of Connecticut (Teaching American History) (opens in a new tab); The Code of 1650 (Connecticut General Assembly) (opens in a new tab)
Jacob and LabanBook or text
In Genesis 29–31, Laban tricks his nephew Jacob into marrying the wrong daughter and keeps changing his wages. Jacob then outwits him by breeding the speckled flocks that their bargain gave him. The allusion points to sharp dealing on both sides.
Source: Genesis 29–31 (KJV), Bible Gateway (opens in a new tab)
church and state in New EnglandCustom
Massachusetts and Connecticut still supported Congregational churches through public taxes in 1813, a system known as the Standing Order. Connecticut ended it with its 1818 constitution, and Massachusetts in 1833.
fixed salaries of the Virginia clergyCustom
Colonial Virginia’s Church of England ministers were paid by law: a 1748 act set each parish minister’s salary at 16,000 pounds of tobacco a year. Attempts to cut that pay led to the famous ‘Parsons’ Cause’ lawsuits of the 1760s.
Source: Two Penny Acts (1755, 1758), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the king’s councilLaw and politics
The Governor’s Council of colonial Virginia: about a dozen of the colony’s wealthiest planters, appointed by the Crown, who advised the royal governor. Membership was held by a small web of interrelated families.
Source: The Governor's Council, Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
PhilipisedWord
To ‘philippize’ is to speak or act for a power that has corrupted you. The word comes from the charge that the oracle at Delphi gave answers favoring Philip II of Macedon. Here it means the Virginia grandees sided with the Crown.
Source: Philippize, Wordsmith.org (A.Word.A.Day) (opens in a new tab)
Randolph, Carter, BurwellPerson
Three of colonial Virginia’s great planter families. Robert ‘King’ Carter (d. 1732) was among the richest men in British America, and the Burwells, his descendants, held seats on the Governor’s Council. Jefferson’s own mother was a Randolph.
Sources: Robert Carter (ca. 1664–1732), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Lewis Burwell (1711 or 1712–1756), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the law abolishing entailsLaw and politics
An entail bound land, and in Virginia also slaves, to a fixed line of heirs, so no holder could sell or divide it. Jefferson’s act of October 1776 turned all entailed property into ordinary property its owners could sell or bequeath freely.
PrimogenitureLaw and politics
The English rule that a landowner who died without a will left all his land to his eldest son. Virginia replaced it in 1785 with Jefferson’s revisal bill on descents, which divided such estates among all the children. James Madison carried it through the assembly while Jefferson was in France.
Sources: The Revisal of the Laws, 1776–1786, editorial note (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); The General Assembly Session of October 1785, editorial note (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the bill on educationLaw and politics
Jefferson’s ‘Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge’, Bill 79 of the revised code. It proposed three years of tax-funded schooling for all free children, girls included. It was presented in 1778 and 1780 but never passed. A much weaker school law of 1796 left action to the county courts and achieved little.
Sources: A Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia (Monticello) (opens in a new tab); 79. A Bill for the More General Diffusion of Knowledge (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
the law for religious freedomLaw and politics
The Virginia Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom, drafted by Jefferson in 1777 and adopted in January 1786. It ended state support for the Church of England in Virginia and barred any penalty for a person’s religious beliefs. Jefferson had it listed among his three achievements on his tombstone.
Sources: Virginia Statute for Establishing Religious Freedom (1786), Encyclopedia Virginia (opens in a new tab); Virginia Statute for Religious Freedom, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia (Monticello) (opens in a new tab)
Theognis on good menQuotation
Line 43 of Theognis, addressed to Cyrnus, roughly ‘Good men, Cyrnus, have never yet brought a city to ruin.’ Jefferson answers Adams with the poet Adams himself had quoted.
Source: Theognis, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
the revised codeLaw and politics
In 1776 Virginia set up a committee to revise its laws. Jefferson, George Wythe and Edmund Pendleton reported 126 bills in June 1779. Some were enacted in 1779, 1785 and 1786, but the assembly never adopted the code as a whole.
Sources: Thomas Jefferson and George Wythe to Benjamin Harrison, 18 June 1779 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Report of the Committee of Revisors, Wythepedia (William & Mary Law Library) (opens in a new tab)
CanailleLanguage
French for the rabble or riffraff: the poorest and most disorderly people of a city.
Source: Canaille, Merriam-Webster Word of the Day (opens in a new tab)
sensiblyWord
Here it means ‘perceptibly’ or ‘noticeably’: the change can be felt and seen. It does not mean ‘wisely’.
the insurrection against rank and birthEvent
Probably the French Revolution, which began in 1789 and which Jefferson has just mentioned as the last 25 years of France. Its early reforms against hereditary privilege gave way to Paris crowd violence, the Terror and, by 1813, Napoleon’s empire.
Source: French Revolution, Encyclopaedia Britannica (opens in a new tab)
a former letter of yoursCross-reference
Adams’s letter of 15 July 1813. There he said that he and Jefferson should each set out their views plainly to the other while they still lived.
Adams to Jefferson, July 15, 1813
Source: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 July 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
disinterestedWord
Unselfish, done without thought of personal gain. It does not mean ‘uninterested’.
the pamphlet on aristocracyBook or text
Adams had received early printed sheets of a long attack on his views of aristocracy. It was published at Fredericksburg in 1814 as ‘An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United States’. In his letter of 15 September 1813 Adams guessed that John Taylor wrote it.
Adams to Jefferson, September 15, 1813
Sources: John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 15 September 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); Imprint record: Taylor, An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy (1814), Library of Virginia (opens in a new tab)
the person you suspectPerson
John Taylor of Caroline (1753–1824), a Virginia planter, sometime U.S. senator and agrarian Republican writer, known for his farming book ‘Arator’. He was the author of the Inquiry, and Adams later answered it in a long series of letters to him beginning in 1814.
Sources: John Taylor to Thomas Jefferson, 10 July 1816 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to John Taylor, 13 January 1815 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
my letter of Aug. 22Cross-reference
Jefferson’s letter of 22 August 1813 asked Adams who had drafted various petitions and addresses of the Continental Congress. Adams answered on 12 November that he did not know and never had.
Jefferson to Adams, August 22, 1813
Sources: To John Adams from Thomas Jefferson, 22 August 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab); From John Adams to Thomas Jefferson, 12 November 1813 (Founders Online) (opens in a new tab)
Source and provenance
- Original text
Transcription from Founders Online (National Archives), as published in The Papers of Thomas Jefferson: Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 28 October 1813 (opens in a new tab)
founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-06-02-0446
- Copy we read
Wayback Machine snapshot (opens in a new tab) of May 29, 2026. Founders Online returned errors when this edition was built, so the text was read from the Internet Archive’s copy of the page.
- Also printed in
- The Adams Papers (opens in a new tab) (founders.archives.gov)
- Modern text and notes
Drafted by AI agents under automatic checks for completeness, meaning and sources. This letter’s review is not yet complete. For scholarship, rely on the original text. How the modern text is made.
- How to cite
Thomas Jefferson to John Adams, 28 October 1813. Founders Online, National Archives, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Jefferson/03-06-02-0446. Modern text and notes: The Jefferson–Adams Letters, https://jefferson-adams-letters.pages.dev/letters/1813-10-28-jefferson-to-adams/.